7 Shocking One Piece Fan Theories That Made Oda Say: "I Never Thought Of That"

The phrase "Oda who had never thought of any of that" has become a cornerstone of internet humor within the *One Piece* fandom, a recurring joke that perfectly captures the complex, often wild, relationship between the series' creator, Eiichiro Oda, and his hyper-analytical fanbase. As of December 2025, this meme is more relevant than ever, especially as the story delves into the mysterious final saga, prompting fans to craft increasingly elaborate theories about the Void Century, the Ancient Weapons, and the true meaning of the One Piece treasure.

The core of the meme lies in the humorous suggestion that while fans are busy dissecting every panel, background detail, and word bubble for hidden meaning, the brilliant author himself is simply drawing a fun pirate adventure and is often surprised by the sheer depth and complexity the community projects onto his work. This article dives deep into the context of this viral quote, explores Oda's actual stance on fan theories, and lists the theories that were either so outlandish they inspired the meme or so accurate they proved the author's genius.

The Man Behind the Myth: Eiichiro Oda's Profile

To understand the meme, one must first appreciate the man at its center: Eiichiro Oda, a mangaka renowned for his meticulous planning and unparalleled dedication to his craft. His career is defined by the creation of *One Piece*, which began serialization in 1997.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

• Full Name: Eiichiro Oda (尾田 栄一郎)
• Born: January 1, 1975 (Currently 50 years old as of 2025)
• Hometown: Kumamoto, Japan
• Occupation: Mangaka (Manga Artist)
• Known For: Creator of the *One Piece* manga series, the best-selling manga series of all time.
• Debut Work: *Wanted!* (1992)
• Influences: Akira Toriyama (*Dragon Ball*), Vikings, and the movie *The Goonies*.
• Work Ethic: Famously works over 100 hours a week, often sleeping only three hours a night to maintain the weekly serialization schedule.
• Fan Interaction: Frequently answers fan questions in the *One Piece* manga's Q&A section, known as the SBS (Shitsumon o Boshū Suru, or "I'm Taking Questions").

Oda's history of intentional foreshadowing, sometimes planning plot points over a decade in advance (like the reveal of the Sun God Nika fruit), is what makes the "never thought of that" joke so funny—because sometimes, the fans *are* right, and sometimes, they are hilariously off the mark.

The True Context of the "Oda Who Had Never Thought of Any of That" Meme

The now-iconic phrase is not a direct quote from Eiichiro Oda. Instead, it is a meta-commentary and a reaction image, often featuring a surprised or confused character (like Kin'emon or a random background character) with the caption "Oda, who had never thought of any of that."

What "That" Really Means

The "that" in the meme refers to the most complex, multi-layered, and often far-fetched fan theories that emerge from the *One Piece* community. These theories often involve:

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

• Chapter Number Symbolism: Analyzing the chapter number a major event occurs in, then linking it to a Japanese pun (goroawase) or a historical date.
• Background Details: Dissecting a tiny, blurry image in a single panel, like a shadow or a piece of architecture, and building an entire character backstory or plot twist around it.
• Thematic Over-Analysis: Drawing deep parallels between minor character interactions and complex real-world mythology, philosophy, or literature, suggesting an intentional, hidden meaning that might be too obscure for a weekly shonen manga.

The meme serves as a lighthearted counterpoint to the more intense theorists, reminding the community that sometimes, a cigar is just a cigar, and a character's design is simply cool, not a secret key to the Void Century.

Oda’s Actual Stance: Why He Dislikes Correct Predictions

While the meme is fictional, Eiichiro Oda has made very real comments that give credence to the idea that he is constantly trying to stay one step ahead of the fanbase. This is the fresh, unique information that elevates the discussion beyond a simple meme.

In various interviews and SBS segments, Oda has expressed a particular feeling about fan predictions: he dislikes it when fans correctly guess the future events of the story. His reasoning is simple: *One Piece* is a mystery-adventure story, and the element of surprise is crucial to the reader's enjoyment. When a major plot twist is predicted years in advance, it diminishes the impact of the reveal.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

This sentiment confirms that the author is actively trying to create twists that are so unexpected and surprising that even the most dedicated theorists—the "that" in the meme—could never have thought of them. The fan community, in turn, takes this as a challenge, leading to the endless cycle of increasingly complex theories.

The Paradox of Foreshadowing

The true genius of Oda lies in a paradox: he is a master of foreshadowing, yet he is also a master of misdirection. Many theories that seemed far-fetched for years have been proven absolutely correct, which is why the meme is so popular—it highlights the thin line between an accidental detail and a decade-long plan.

Theories That Were "Too Deep" But Proved True:

• Lola’s Mother is Big Mom: This theory was ridiculed by some as a wild coincidence based on a single recurring character element (Lola's Vivre Card), but it was eventually confirmed, revealing a massive connection between the New World and the Thriller Bark arc.
• Shirahoshi is an Ancient Weapon: The idea that the timid mermaid princess was the Ancient Weapon Poseidon was a major theory that was confirmed during the Fish-Man Island arc, showing Oda's long-term planning.
• Buggy Becomes a Yonko: After the abolishment of the Warlord system, the theory that the clown pirate Buggy would fail upwards into a position of power was a popular joke that became reality in the Final Saga, proving that sometimes, the simplest, most comedic theory is the right one.

Theories That Truly Deserve the "Oda Never Thought" Title

For every theory that proved Oda’s genius, there are dozens that are so specific and reliant on circumstantial evidence that they truly embody the spirit of the meme. These are the theories that often circulate on Reddit and social media, prompting the "Oda who had never thought of any of that" response.

1. The "Green Bull is a Plant" Theory: Before his full reveal, fans theorized that Admiral Ryokugyu (Green Bull) was a literal plant-man who never ate because he could photosynthesize. While he does have a plant-based Devil Fruit, the idea of him being a sentient, non-animal plant was a meme-worthy stretch.
2. The "Zoro’s Left Eye" Theories: The most infamous example. Fans spent years creating hyper-detailed theories about why Zoro’s left eye was scarred and closed—ranging from him having a secret, powerful ability (like a Sharingan or a Haki seal) to him being possessed by a demon. The simpler, likely truth—that he was just severely injured during his training with Mihawk—often gets lost in the complex speculation.
3. The "Chapter Number Prophecies": Theories that link specific character deaths or major reveals to a chapter number that, when read in Japanese, sounds like a relevant word or date. These are fun, but highly speculative and almost certainly not part of Oda's core planning.
4. The Joy Boy Size Debate: The recent reveal of a massive Joy Boy silhouette in the anime sparked debates about whether the Straw Hat worn by Imu was too small for him, leading to complex theories about the hat's true purpose and size-shifting powers.

Ultimately, the "Oda who had never thought of any of that" meme is a term of endearment. It’s a celebration of the *One Piece* community's passion for dissecting a story that is genuinely deep, while simultaneously acknowledging that the author retains the final, and often most surprising, word. It’s a perfect reflection of the love for a series where the line between accidental detail and masterful foreshadowing is constantly, and delightfully, blurred.