The Bitter End Of A Best Friendship: Unpacking The Brianna Chickenfry And Grace O'Malley Barstool Drama

The public fallout between former co-hosts and childhood best friends, Brianna "Chickenfry" LaPaglia and Grace O’Malley, has dominated social media feeds in late 2024 and early 2025. What began as a successful podcast partnership on Barstool Sports for their show *PlanBri Uncut* quickly devolved into one of the most talked-about "friendship breakups" of the year, culminating in Grace O'Malley's departure from the company and a messy, viral DMs scandal. This comprehensive article breaks down the background of the two creators, the timeline of the split, and the specific, dramatic details that led to the end of their years-long relationship. The drama centers on the sudden end of their podcast and the revelations that followed, which saw both creators speaking out about the rift on their respective platforms, leaving fans divided and curious about the true reasons behind the split.

Biographies and Career Milestones: Brianna Chickenfry and Grace O'Malley

To understand the depth of the fallout, it is essential to first know the individuals involved. Both Brianna LaPaglia and Grace O’Malley are New England natives who rose to prominence through candid, relatable content on TikTok before transitioning into the world of podcasting with Barstool Sports.

Brianna "Chickenfry" LaPaglia

• Full Name: Brianna LaPaglia
• Nickname: Brianna Chickenfry
• Date of Birth: June 17, 1999
• Age (as of late 2024): 25 years old
• Career Start: Gained massive traction on TikTok with short-form video content, comedic testimonials, and lip-syncs.
• Key Milestones: Joined Barstool Sports, co-hosted the successful *PlanBri Uncut* podcast, became a major social media personality, and was in a high-profile relationship with country music star Zach Bryan.
• Current Status: Continues her career with Barstool Sports, focusing on new projects following the end of *PlanBri Uncut*.

Grace O'Malley

• Full Name: Grace O'Malley
• Age (as of late 2024): 25 years old
• Career Start: Gained a following on TikTok for her candid, NYC-based comedian persona and relatable content.
• Key Milestones: Co-hosted *PlanBri Uncut* alongside Brianna, establishing herself as a prominent podcaster and comedian. She is known for her stand-up comedy and witty social commentary.
• Current Status: Departed from Barstool Sports and is focusing on her stand-up comedy career and independent content creation.

The Rise and Fall of PlanBri Uncut: A Timeline of the Friendship Breakup

The relationship between Brianna and Grace was not just professional; they were friends since the fifth grade, a fact that made their public separation all the more dramatic. Their shared history formed the foundation of their podcast’s success, offering fans an authentic, unfiltered look into their lives.

The Genesis of a Podcast Partnership

Brianna LaPaglia first joined Barstool Sports, and Grace O'Malley was later brought on as her co-host for *PlanBri Uncut* in 2022. The podcast quickly became a hit, capitalizing on their natural chemistry and shared history as childhood best friends. They discussed everything from pop culture and dating to their personal lives, establishing a strong, loyal fanbase.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

October 2024: The Unraveling Begins

The first major sign of trouble emerged in October 2024. Brianna LaPaglia reportedly approached Barstool founder Dave Portnoy to express her desire to end *PlanBri Uncut* to potentially start a fresh project. Shortly after, Grace O'Malley officially announced her departure from both the podcast and Barstool Sports entirely, stating the split was on "bad terms" with her former co-host.

The Public Fallout: Accusations and DMs Drama

Following the professional split, the drama spilled over onto social media. The core of the controversy centered around the "DMs Drama," where screenshots of alleged private messages sent by Brianna LaPaglia surfaced on TikTok. These messages allegedly showed Brianna speaking negatively about Grace to fans, which many interpreted as a betrayal and the final nail in the coffin of their friendship. This public airing of grievances quickly polarized the internet, with many fans rallying behind Grace O'Malley.

The Aftermath: Comparing Splits and Moving Forward

The intensity of the fallout was notable, prompting both women to address the situation in separate interviews and podcasts, offering their own perspectives on the end of their partnership and friendship.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

Brianna’s Comparison to the Zach Bryan Split

In a candid moment, Brianna LaPaglia spoke out about the friendship breakup, drawing a surprising parallel to her very recent, highly public split with country star Zach Bryan. She reportedly compared the emotional difficulty and public scrutiny of losing her best friend to the experience of her romantic breakup, highlighting the depth of the pain and complexity of the situation. This comparison underscored just how significant the rift with Grace was to her personal life.

Grace O'Malley’s New Chapter

Grace O'Malley, now operating independently of Barstool Sports, has been more open about the emotional toll of the split. In a new interview, she discussed the fallout with her former co-host, confirming the end of their friendship and professional relationship. Her focus has shifted entirely to her stand-up comedy career and independent content creation, a move that many fans see as a positive step toward establishing her own brand outside of the shadow of a major media company and a fraught partnership. Her decision to leave Barstool and *PlanBri Uncut* suggests a definitive closure to that chapter of her life.

The Impact of the Barstool Friendship Breakup

The drama between Brianna Chickenfry and Grace O'Malley serves as a potent case study in the volatile world of influencer-driven media. When a partnership is built on an authentic, years-long friendship, the professional and personal lines blur, making any split inherently messy and public. The use of social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram as battlegrounds for public opinion further amplified the conflict, turning a private disagreement into a viral spectacle.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

• Topical Authority Entities: Brianna LaPaglia, Grace O'Malley, PlanBri Uncut, Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy, Zach Bryan, TikTok, Instagram, New England, NYC-based comedian, friendship breakup, DMs drama, tell-all, UNFILTERED podcast, Zillennial Zine, country star, social media personality, comedy career.

While the *PlanBri Uncut* podcast is officially over, both Brianna and Grace have embarked on new paths. Brianna remains a key figure at Barstool, and Grace is carving out a niche for herself in the comedy world. The legacy of their partnership, however, will forever be tied to their dramatic, public, and highly scrutinized friendship breakup.