5 Jaw-Dropping Reasons Aaron And Kaylor Broke Up After Love Island USA Season 6

The dramatic relationship between Kaylor Martin and Aaron Evans, one of the most talked-about couples from *Love Island USA* Season 6, officially ended shortly after the show’s reunion. The split, which was confirmed by Kaylor herself in a candid interview, came as little surprise to viewers who witnessed the tumultuous nature of their connection, especially following the explosive events of Casa Amor. As of December 12, 2025, the couple remains separated, with Kaylor making it clear that the events she watched back after leaving the villa were the definitive factor in her decision to walk away from the relationship. The core of the breakup stems from a significant breach of trust and a final, shocking lie that was exposed on camera, proving that the foundation of their relationship was not strong enough to withstand the scrutiny of the outside world. This article breaks down the definitive timeline and the surprising factors that led to the permanent split of the *Love Island* duo.

The Profiles: Kaylor Martin and Aaron Evans Biography

Before diving into the reasons for the split, here is a quick look at the two reality stars who captured—and then broke—the hearts of *Love Island USA* fans.

Kaylor Martin

• Full Name: Kaylor Martin
• Age: 22 (at the time of the show)
• Hometown: Connellsville, Pennsylvania
• Occupation: Graduate College Student / Social Media Influencer
• Love Island USA Status: Original Islander (Day 1 entry, dumped on Day 30)
• Social Media Presence: Known for fashion and swimwear modeling, boasting over 1 million followers.

Aaron Evans

• Full Name: Aaron Evans
• Age: 26 (at the time of the show)
• Hometown: Devon, England
• Birthplace: Marbella, Spain (born in 1998)
• Occupation: Deckhand / Reality TV Star
• Love Island USA Status: Original Islander (Day 1 entry)
• Family: Has a brother named Bailey.

The Casa Amor Catastrophe: The Unforgivable Lie

The relationship between Kaylor and Aaron was put to the ultimate test during the infamous Casa Amor segment, a challenge that historically breaks even the strongest *Love Island* couples. While the pair had a dramatic and often emotional connection in the main villa, the separation revealed a critical lack of commitment from Aaron, which Kaylor only fully grasped after she had been dumped from the island.

1. The Physical Deception with Daniela Ortiz-Rivera

The primary reason for the breakup was Aaron's behavior with new Casa Amor bombshell Daniela Ortiz-Rivera. During a moment of flirtation, Aaron was seen on camera putting his hands down Daniela's pants. This act was a significant betrayal of Kaylor’s trust and a clear sign that Aaron was exploring other connections in a way that Kaylor found disrespectful and unacceptable.

2. The Subsequent Denial and Withholding of Truth

What made the situation worse was Aaron's failure to be honest with Kaylor about the full extent of his actions. When he returned to the main villa, he downplayed the seriousness of his interactions during Casa Amor. Kaylor, who had been dumped and was watching the season back, saw the footage of the incident with Daniela and realized Aaron had actively lied to her. This deception, more than the action itself, was the final nail in the coffin.

The Final Straw: The Reunion Confrontation and Public Split

The tension between Kaylor and Aaron reached its peak during the highly anticipated *Love Island USA* reunion show. While many couples use the reunion to confirm their status, for Kaylor and Aaron, it was the setting for their public and definitive split.

3. Aaron’s Last-Minute Confession

During the reunion, under the pressure of being on camera and facing Kaylor, Aaron finally confessed to the full truth about the Casa Amor incident—specifically the part about putting his hands down Daniela’s pants. This confession, which Kaylor had been waiting for him to admit, came too late and only served to confirm his pattern of dishonesty. Kaylor’s reaction was immediate and decisive, telling him she never wanted to see him again.

4. Kaylor's Public Announcement on the 'BFFs' Podcast

The official announcement of the breakup to the wider public was made by Kaylor on the popular Barstool Sports podcast, *BFFs*. She confirmed that she and Aaron were "not okay," stating clearly, "we're done." This interview solidified the end of their brief post-villa relationship. The decision was met with widespread support from viewers who felt Kaylor deserved better after witnessing Aaron’s behavior on the show.

The Underlying Relationship Issues That Hastened the End

Beyond the Casa Amor drama, the couple faced several pre-existing issues that made their post-villa relationship incredibly fragile. These factors contributed to the swiftness of their breakup.

5. Emotional Instability and Communication Breakdown

Even within the villa, the couple's communication was often strained. Kaylor was frequently seen crying due to Aaron's "hot and cold" behavior, where he would alternate between calling her his "wifey" and then withdrawing or showing interest in other women. This emotional inconsistency created an unstable environment. Once outside the controlled environment of the villa, the lack of effective communication and the inability to establish a solid, trusting foundation proved insurmountable. The combination of Aaron's major betrayal at Casa Amor, his subsequent lies, and the pre-existing emotional turbulence ultimately led Kaylor Martin to make a definitive decision for her own well-being. Unlike the three other couples from *Love Island USA* Season 6—Serena Page and Kordell Beckham, JaNa Craig and Kenny Rodriguez, and Leah Kateb and Miguel Harichi—who managed to stay together, Kaylor and Aaron’s relationship was a casualty of the show's intense drama and a fundamental lack of trust. The breakup served as a powerful reminder to fans that what happens on the island does not always translate to a successful real-world romance.