The Ultimate Unmasking: Every Shocking Celebrity Relative Revealed On Claim To Fame Season 2

The second season of ABC's hit reality competition, Claim to Fame, delivered a masterclass in deception, clue-deciphering, and outright chaotic drama, establishing itself as one of the most compelling and talked-about reality shows of the last few years. As of today, December 18, 2025, fans are still buzzing about the incredible twists, from the unforgettable meltdown in the premiere episode to the final, nail-biting Guess Off that crowned a champion. This season featured a dozen contestants—all related to an A-list celebrity—living together while desperately trying to hide their lineage, with the ultimate goal of taking home the $100,000 grand prize.

The premise is simple: guess everyone else's famous relative before they guess yours. However, the celebrity relatives in Season 2 were arguably more obscure and harder to pin down than in the first, leading to some truly spectacular misdirects and shocking reveals. Hosted once again by the charismatic duo Kevin and Frankie Jonas, the season was packed with layered clues, cryptic challenges, and alliances that crumbled under the pressure of keeping a massive secret. Below is the definitive breakdown of every contestant, their true identity, and how the ultimate winner managed to outplay the competition.

The Full Roster: Every Celebrity Relative Revealed on Claim to Fame Season 2

The Season 2 cast included a complex mix of siblings, children, and grandchildren of some of the world's most recognizable figures in music, film, comedy, and politics. Identifying the celebrity relatives required the contestants—and viewers at home—to piece together cryptic clues hidden in the house, from a life-size donkey to a pair of oversized shoes. Here is the complete list of the 12 celebrity relatives who competed for the prize, listed in order of their elimination or final placement.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

• Carly Reeves: The first contestant eliminated after a dramatic Guess Off. Her celebrity relative was revealed to be her uncle, Academy Award-winning actor Tom Hanks. Her clue included a bench, referencing Forrest Gump.
• Travis: Eliminated in Episode 2. He was the son of legendary astrophysicist, author, and science communicator Neil deGrasse Tyson.
• Jane (Jada Star): Eliminated in Episode 3. She was the daughter of the iconic R&B singer and actress Dolly Parton's sister, Stella Parton. The clue was a butterfly, referencing Dolly's hit song "Love Is Like a Butterfly."
• Shayne: Eliminated in Episode 4. She was the daughter of Grammy-winning singer-songwriter and record producer Eddie Murphy.
• Cole Cook: Voluntarily left the competition in Episode 5. His celebrity relative is his sister, 15-time Grammy-winning singer-songwriter Alicia Keys. His clue featured a piano.
• Olivia: Eliminated in Episode 6. The most shocking misdirect of the season, as many contestants believed she was related to comedian Carrot Top. She was actually the niece of actress, model, and television host Jenny McCarthy.
• JR (Robert Lamar Stafford): Eliminated in Episode 7 after being correctly guessed by Monay. He is the brother of Grammy-winning rapper and singer Lil Nas X. His clue included a cowboy hat.
• Hugo Wentzel: Eliminated in Episode 8. He was revealed to be the grandson of the 39th President of the United States, Jimmy Carter. His clue was a peanut, referencing the former President's career as a peanut farmer.
• Karsyn: Finished in 4th place. Karsyn's celebrity relative was her grandfather, NASCAR legend Dale Earnhardt Sr. Her clue was a checkered flag.
• Chris Osmond: Finished in 3rd place. Chris is the son of singer, actor, and former teen idol Donny Osmond. His clues included a purple sock and a coat of many colors, referencing his father's role in Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat.
• Monay (Jerrica Monay Brooks): Finished as the runner-up. Monay's celebrity relative is her father, comedian and actor J.B. Smoove, best known for his role as Leon in Curb Your Enthusiasm.
• Gabriel Ezra Cannon: The Season 2 Winner. Gabriel is the brother of television host, actor, and rapper Nick Cannon.

The Shocking Finale: Winner, Runner-Up, and Final Clues

The final episode of Claim to Fame Season 2 was a high-stakes showdown between the final three: Gabriel, Monay, and Chris. The final challenge was a memory game that tested the contestants' knowledge of all the clues revealed throughout the season, which was crucial for gaining a strategic advantage in the final Guess Off.

Gabriel, who had shown himself to be a formidable player and a master of challenges, dominated the final memory game, securing the final spot in the Guess Off and the power to choose the first guesser. His ability to maintain a low profile while strategically gathering information proved to be his winning strategy. His celebrity relative, the multifaceted Nick Cannon, was one of the most difficult to guess, with clues pointing to his numerous children (a reference to a large family), his birthplace of San Diego, and his multiple career roles.

The final Guess Off came down to Gabriel and Monay. Gabriel, with the advantage, correctly guessed Monay's celebrity relative as comedian J.B. Smoove. This correct guess automatically crowned Gabriel as the Season 2 winner, earning him the $100,000 prize. Monay, the runner-up, had played an exceptional game, keeping her father's identity a secret until the very end. She had successfully led others to believe her relative was Steve Harvey, making her one of the season's best deceivers.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

The Most Dramatic Moments and Biggest Mistakes

Season 2 was not short on drama, providing several viral moments that captivated viewers and became instant reality TV classics. These moments often centered around a contestant's inability to handle the pressure or a stunning miscalculation in the Guess Off. The high-stakes environment of the competition, where one wrong guess means immediate elimination, is what makes the show so compelling.

Carly Reeves' Unforgettable Meltdown

The most explosive moment of the season happened in the very first episode with Carly Reeves. After being correctly guessed by Hugo, Carly was revealed to be the niece of Tom Hanks. Her reaction to being eliminated—a dramatic, tearful outburst where she repeatedly screamed, "I didn't even get to do any challenges!"—immediately went viral across social media platforms. This moment set the tone for the entire season, proving that even family members of Hollywood royalty can't handle the heat of the competition.

The Olivia/Jenny McCarthy Misdirect

One of the season's most effective red herrings involved contestant Olivia. The house was convinced, based on some cryptic clues, that she was related to comedian Carrot Top. This theory dominated the conversation for weeks. When Monay correctly guessed that Olivia’s aunt was Jenny McCarthy, the entire house was shocked. Olivia’s ability to sell the Carrot Top story was a testament to her deceptive gameplay, even if it ultimately led to her elimination.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

JR's Lil Nas X Reveal

JR, who consistently struggled with the clues and the social dynamics, was correctly guessed by Monay. He was revealed to be the brother of "Old Town Road" superstar Lil Nas X. His identity was the source of much confusion, with contestants initially guessing everyone from professional athletes to other rappers. The reveal of his connection to the boundary-pushing artist was a major highlight, showcasing the incredible range of celebrity relatives this season managed to secure.

The success of Claim to Fame Season 2 lies in its perfect blend of mystery, reality TV drama, and the pure fun of celebrity trivia. The contestants were all memorable, and their famous relatives were a perfect mix of Hollywood legends and contemporary superstars. Gabriel Cannon's victory was a well-earned win, proving that the best strategy is often a combination of challenge prowess and social subtlety. With the show renewed for a third season, fans can only wait to see which new crop of celebrity relatives will attempt to hide their famous lineage next.