7 Shocking Realities Of Serena Pitt And Joe Amabile's Married Life After Bachelor In Paradise

The fairy tale didn't end with a final rose; it ended with two weddings and a major life crossroads. Bachelor Nation fan-favorites Serena Pitt and Joe Amabile, affectionately known as "Grocery Joe," have captivated viewers ever since their whirlwind romance on the beaches of Mexico. As of the end of 2024 and heading into 2025, the couple is navigating the exciting and challenging "next chapter" of their life, which includes major decisions about where to call home and when to start a family. Their journey from a chaotic reality TV beach to a chic Charleston wedding has been one of the franchise's most genuine success stories, proving that true love can, in fact, be found in Paradise.

The latest updates, current in December 2025, show the married duo celebrating key anniversaries and openly discussing their future, including the much-anticipated "baby buzz" and a potential move away from their current New York City base. Their candidness on their podcast and social media has given fans a fresh, unfiltered look at the realities of post-show marriage, making them one of the most relatable couples in the entire *Bachelor* franchise. The foundation they built on *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 7 has solidified into a strong, modern marriage.

Complete Biography and Professional Profile: Serena Pitt and Joe Amabile

The couple's individual backgrounds and careers are as diverse as their journey to finding each other, combining Canadian charm with Chicago hustle. Understanding their professional lives offers insight into the "hard decisions" they face today regarding their permanent residence and future endeavors.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Serena Pitt: The Canadian Publicist

• Full Name: Serena Pitt
• Date of Birth: October 25, 1997
• Age (as of 2025): 28
• Hometown/Origin: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
• Education: Graduated from Wilfrid Laurier University in 2019 with a degree in Communications and a minor in Business Management.
• Pre-Show Career: Worked as a Publicist in Toronto.
• Bachelor Franchise History: Contestant on Matt James' season of *The Bachelor* (Season 25), where she self-eliminated, and later a successful contestant on *Bachelor in Paradise* (Season 7).
• Current Endeavors: Reality TV personality, social media influencer, and co-host of the *Click Bait with Bachelor Nation* podcast.

Joe Amabile: "Grocery Joe"

• Full Name: Joe Amabile
• Date of Birth: April 12, 1986
• Age (as of 2025): 39
• Hometown/Origin: Chicago, Illinois, USA
• Pre-Show Career: Owned a successful grocery store in Chicago, which earned him the famous nickname "Grocery Joe." He was also one of the youngest traders on the Chicago stock exchange.
• Bachelor Franchise History: Contestant on Becca Kufrin's season of *The Bachelorette* (Season 14), a fan-favorite contestant on *Bachelor in Paradise* (Season 5), and his final, successful run on *Bachelor in Paradise* (Season 7). He also competed on *Dancing with the Stars* (Season 27).
• Current Endeavors: Reality TV personality, social media influencer, co-host of the popular *Click Bait with Bachelor Nation* podcast, and co-host of the *Trading Secrets* podcast.
• Estimated Net Worth: Varies widely, with estimates ranging from $1 million to $4 million, primarily from his business ventures, TV appearances, and podcasting career.

The Two Weddings: A Modern Bachelor Nation Love Story

Serena and Joe's path to marriage was unique, featuring two distinct ceremonies that satisfied both their desire for intimacy and their need for a grand celebration with family and friends. This decision to have two weddings has become a major talking point for Bachelor Nation couples navigating the post-show pressure.

1. The Intimate City Hall Ceremony (October 2022)

In a surprising move, the couple first tied the knot in a private, impromptu ceremony at a New York City courthouse in October 2022. This decision came about because they were already living together and felt that a legal marriage was the next logical step, regardless of their planned large wedding. The simple "I do's" served as their official, legal union, celebrated quietly before the stress of a major wedding build-up.

2. The "Magical" Charleston Celebration (September 2, 2023)

Almost a year later, the couple hosted their dream wedding in Charleston, South Carolina, on September 2, 2023. The event was a lavish, "magical" affair held at The Cedar Room, a historic venue in Charleston. This second ceremony was the one filmed and shared with the public, allowing them to celebrate their love with approximately 150 guests, including many fellow *Bachelor in Paradise* castmates and franchise alumni. Serena wore a stunning gown for the day, which was a beautiful contrast to their casual courthouse attire.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

The Next Chapter: Move, Babies, and Life in 2025

As the couple moves past the wedding planning phase, their focus has shifted entirely to building their life together, which involves major decisions that many young couples face: location and family planning. These discussions have been central to their public updates throughout late 2024 and early 2025.

The "Hard Decision" on Location

Serena and Joe have been living in New York City since their engagement, but they have openly discussed the "hard decision" of finding a more permanent home. Their two primary options reflect their roots: Chicago (Joe's hometown) and Toronto (Serena's hometown). A move to either city would bring them closer to their respective families, a priority as they plan their future. This crossroads is a major theme on their joint social media and podcast appearances, as they weigh career opportunities against family proximity.

• Chicago: Offers a return to Joe's roots and the city where he built his initial business career.
• Toronto: Would bring Serena closer to her family and original support system in Canada.
• New York City: While they enjoy it, they have indicated it may not be their long-term home for raising a family.

The Anticipated "Baby Buzz"

One of the most frequent questions the couple receives is about when they plan to have children, a topic Joe has addressed directly, stating that kids are definitely in their "near future." The couple has been open about wanting to have two children, and the discussions about starting a family have intensified now that the wedding celebrations are complete. While there has been "baby buzz" and speculation from fans, no official pregnancy announcement has been made as of late 2024, but it remains a highly anticipated milestone for the couple.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

Their journey from being strangers on a beach to a happily married couple navigating the complexities of their late 20s and late 30s has cemented their status as a Bachelor Nation success story. The genuine connection forged on *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 7 continues to thrive, promising many more major life updates for fans to follow in the coming years.