Blocked And Desperate: 5 Heartbreaking Truths About Catelynn, Tyler, And Carly's Closed Adoption In 2025

The tumultuous journey of Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra with their biological daughter, Carly, has taken a deeply heartbreaking turn in late 2024 and early 2025. After over a decade of navigating a complex open adoption, the Teen Mom stars have confirmed that contact with Carly and her adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, has been severely restricted, leading to a "closed" status and a period of painful separation. This latest update reveals the severe emotional toll on the couple as they grapple with the reality of being cut off from the daughter they placed for adoption back in 2009.

As of December 2025, the relationship is fraught with tension and communication breakdowns, with the couple admitting to desperate measures to reach their now 16-year-old daughter. The long-running saga, which began on 16 and Pregnant, continues to be one of the most emotional and defining storylines of the entire Teen Mom franchise, highlighting the rarely discussed complexities and pain of open adoption agreements.

Catelynn and Tyler Baltierra: A Complete Biographical Profile

Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra have been a central couple in the MTV reality universe since their debut in 2009. Their decision to place their first child for adoption became a defining moment in their lives and the show's history.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

• Catelynn Lowell Baltierra (née Lowell):
  • Born: March 12, 1992 (Age 33 in 2025)
  • Hometown: Marine City, Michigan
  • Career: Reality Television Personality, Author, Public Speaker, Mental Health Advocate.
  • First Appearance: MTV's 16 and Pregnant (2009).
• Tyler Baltierra:
  • Born: January 12, 1992 (Age 33 in 2025)
  • Hometown: Marine City, Michigan
  • Career: Reality Television Personality, Author, Poet, Mental Health Advocate.
  • Relationship Status: Married to Catelynn Lowell (since 2015).
• Carly Elizabeth Davis (Biological Daughter):
  • Born: 2009 (Age 16 in 2025)
  • Birth Parents: Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra.
  • Adoptive Parents: Brandon and Teresa Davis.
  • Adoption Type: Originally an open adoption.
• Other Children: The couple shares three other daughters: Novalee Reign Baltierra (born 2015), Vaeda Luma Baltierra (born 2019), and Rya Rose Baltierra (born 2021).

The Shocking Shift to a 'Closed' Adoption Status

The core intention of Catelynn and Tyler's choice—an open adoption—was to maintain a continuous, loving connection with their biological daughter, Carly. This arrangement was initially successful, featuring annual visits and regular communication with the adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis. However, as Carly entered her teenage years, the dynamic shifted dramatically, culminating in the current, painful reality.

The tension began building over several years, with Brandon and Teresa expressing discomfort with the level of exposure and discussion about Carly on the reality show, Teen Mom: The Next Chapter. Catelynn and Tyler's desire to have a more direct and unmediated relationship with Carly often clashed with the adoptive parents' need to protect their daughter's privacy and stability. This fundamental disagreement over boundaries is what ultimately led to the current crisis.

In a recent and heartbreaking revelation on the show, Catelynn confirmed that she and Tyler were effectively "blocked" by Brandon and Teresa, with communication coming to a complete halt. The original open adoption agreement has now become a closed one, or at the very least, a "pause" in contact, leaving the birth parents devastated and feeling a profound sense of loss.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

1. The Desperate Attempt to Contact Carly's Friend

The most shocking recent update, reported in late 2024, highlighted the couple's desperation. Feeling completely cut off from their biological daughter, Catelynn and Tyler admitted to reaching out to one of Carly's "minor" friends via text message. Tyler described the action as being driven by "desperation" to get an update on Carly's life and mental well-being, acknowledging that the move was inappropriate but born out of deep parental yearning.

This incident further strained the already fractured relationship with Brandon and Teresa Davis, who viewed the action as a massive overstep of the established boundaries. This event served as a painful reminder of the emotional extremes the birth parents are willing to go to simply to maintain a connection to their firstborn child. It underscores the profound difficulty of navigating the birth parent-adoptive parent relationship, especially when a child reaches an age where they begin to seek autonomy.

2. The Pain of Missing Carly's Milestones

As Carly turned 16 in 2025, the lack of communication became even more painful for Catelynn and Tyler. Milestones such as birthdays, school events, and simply watching their daughter grow up are now experienced from a distance, or not at all. Tyler has been vocal about the emotional difficulty of the day he and Catelynn placed Carly for adoption, calling it the "hardest day" of his life, a feeling that resurfaces with every missed opportunity to connect.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

The couple has expressed deep sadness over the fact that their other three daughters—Novalee, Vaeda, and Rya—are unable to have a consistent relationship with their older biological sister. The dream of a large, blended family where all the girls knew each other has been largely put on hold due to the restrictions imposed by the adoptive parents.

3. Catelynn's Regret Over Adoptive Parent Choice

In one of the most candid moments of the recent season, Catelynn admitted to feeling regret over her choice of adoptive parents. While she has always stood by the decision to place Carly for adoption, she confessed to wishing she had chosen a different couple who would have been more flexible with the open adoption agreement. This sentiment reflects the deep-seated frustration and emotional turmoil that comes from feeling like a promise—the promise of a continuous, open relationship—was broken.

The couple has frequently discussed their attempts to understand the perspective of Brandon and Teresa, recognizing their right as legal parents to protect Carly. However, the emotional pain of being cut off often overshadows this understanding, leading to public criticism and a cycle of conflict that is difficult to break.

What the Future Holds for Carly and Her Birth Parents

The current status of the adoption remains tense and officially "paused." Catelynn and Tyler have stated that they will no longer discuss the specifics of the adoption on the show, a decision likely made to respect the Davis family's privacy and to avoid further jeopardizing any potential future contact.

The hope for Catelynn and Tyler now lies in the future, specifically when Carly turns 18. At that age, Carly will legally be able to make her own decisions regarding contact with her birth parents, regardless of the wishes of her adoptive parents. The couple holds onto the hope that their biological daughter will choose to reconnect with them and her three younger sisters when she is an adult.

The complex story of Carly, Catelynn, and Tyler serves as a powerful, real-world case study on the challenges of open adoption. It highlights the delicate balance of the birth parents' emotional needs and the adoptive parents' responsibility to provide a stable, protected life for their child. For now, the Baltierra family continues to navigate this painful separation, focusing on their mental health and the well-being of their other children while waiting patiently for the day their first daughter might choose to reach out.