The Ultimate Cast List: 5 Major Stars Confirmed To Join The Returning Horsemen In Now You See Me 3

The magic is back, and the roster of illusionists has expanded dramatically. As of December 2025, the latest updates confirm that the highly anticipated third installment in the franchise, officially titled *Now You See Me: Now You Don't*, has wrapped filming and is set for a 2025 release, featuring a thrilling mix of original stars and A-list newcomers. This sequel, which promises to elevate the spectacle of the *Now You See Me* universe, is bringing back the core members of The Four Horsemen while introducing a "new generation of illusionists" to the fold, setting the stage for the biggest heist and most complex mystery yet. The production, helmed by director Ruben Fleischer, began filming in May 2024 across global locations including New York, Budapest, and Paris, indicating a grand, international scope for the new film. After nearly a decade since the last movie, the excitement is palpable, with the returning cast praising the new script as "astounding." Get ready to dive into the definitive list of everyone confirmed and expected to appear in *Now You See Me 3*.

The Confirmed Roster: Returning Horsemen and New Blood

The third movie, *Now You See Me: Now You Don't*, is set to reunite the primary Horsemen, a relief for fans who worried about scheduling conflicts or character changes. The film’s core premise revolves around the original team uniting with a new, younger group of magicians, suggesting a passing of the torch or perhaps a clash of styles.

The Returning Core Cast: The Four Horsemen and The Eye

The foundation of the franchise is the chemistry of its ensemble, and the latest news confirms that almost all major players from the first two films are returning to reprise their iconic roles.

• Jesse Eisenberg as J. Daniel "Danny" Atlas: The arrogant, quick-witted leader and master illusionist of the Horsemen. Eisenberg’s return ensures the continuation of the team’s dynamic.
• Woody Harrelson as Merritt McKinney: The master mentalist and hypnotist. Harrelson’s comedic timing and unique character are essential to the group.
• Dave Franco as Jack Wilder: The street magician and sleight-of-hand expert who was revealed to be an FBI mole in the first film. Franco is back as a key member of the team.
• Isla Fisher as Henley Reeves: The escape artist and one of the original Horsemen from the first film, whose absence in *Now You See Me 2* was keenly felt. Her return is a major win for the sequel.
• Lizzy Caplan as Lula May: The quirky, boundary-pushing illusionist who replaced Henley in the second film. Caplan has confirmed her return, suggesting a powerful, five-person Horsemen team or a new dynamic between her and Henley.
• Morgan Freeman as Thaddeus Bradley: The former magician and magic debunker who spent time in prison. Freeman’s character has been a central figure in the mystery of The Eye, and his return is confirmed.
• Mark Ruffalo as Dylan Rhodes: The former FBI agent and secret leader of The Horsemen who was revealed to be the son of the magician Lionel Shrike. Ruffalo’s return was confirmed despite his absence from early trailers, with his role potentially involving a brief, but crucial, appearance, perhaps even in hologram form.

New High-Profile Cast Members: The Next Generation

The biggest news surrounding *Now You See Me 3* is the addition of several high-profile actors who are set to play the "new generation of illusionists." These additions not only inject fresh energy but also significantly increase the film's star power and topical authority.

1. Rosamund Pike: The Oscar-nominated actress, known for her intense roles in *Gone Girl* and *I Care a Lot*. Her role is currently unknown, but her presence suggests a major new antagonist or a powerful ally.
2. Justice Smith: Known for his roles in *Detective Pikachu* and *Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom*. Smith is confirmed to be one of the new illusionists, likely a key member of the next-gen team.
3. Dominic Sessa: The breakout star from the critically acclaimed film *The Holdovers*. Sessa's casting is a significant nod to current Hollywood buzz, and he is also confirmed as one of the new illusionists.
4. Ariana Greenblatt: A young, rising star who gained major recognition for her role as young Gamora in the MCU and as Sasha in *Barbie*. Greenblatt is the fourth confirmed member of the new illusionist team.
5. Michael Caine as Arthur Tressler: While his return is not explicitly confirmed in the latest announcements, Caine's character, the wealthy insurance magnate and former villain, is a foundational entity in the franchise, and his presence is often rumored or expected.

The Creative Team Behind the Magic

While the cast is the face of the film, the creative team ensures the intricate plot and spectacular illusions come to life. The choice of director and writer is key to maintaining the franchise's unique blend of heist thriller and magic spectacle.

Director and Screenplay

The director for *Now You See Me 3* is Ruben Fleischer, known for successfully blending action and comedy in hits like *Zombieland* and *Venom*. Fleischer replaces Jon M. Chu, who directed the second film, bringing a new visual style and energy to the sequel. The screenplay is credited to Michael Lesslie, who is known for his work on *Macbeth* and *Assassin's Creed*, suggesting a more dramatic and potentially darker edge to the narrative. The combination of Fleischer's action-comedy background and Lesslie's dramatic writing promises a fresh, compelling story.

Production and Filming Locations

The movie, also known by its working title *Now You See Me: Now You Don't*, has a confirmed theatrical release date of November 14, 2025. The production schedule was ambitious, with filming taking place in diverse, international locations:

• New York, United States
• Budapest, Hungary
• Paris, France

This global setting suggests a series of high-stakes, international heists that will challenge the Horsemen like never before, utilizing the unique architecture and landmarks of these major cities for dazzling magic tricks.

Plot Teases and The New Generation's Role

The central mystery of the franchise has always been The Eye, the ancient, secret society of magicians. The new film is set to delve deeper into the organization, but with a new twist: the introduction of a new team. The official synopsis suggests that The Four Horsemen are returning to "unite with a new generation of illusionists" (Justice Smith, Dominic Sessa, and Ariana Greenblatt). This hints at a mentorship dynamic, where Danny Atlas, Merritt McKinney, and Jack Wilder must train or collaborate with younger, perhaps more technologically savvy, magicians. The plot is expected to explore the "evolution" of the magic world itself. The inclusion of Rosamund Pike and the confirmed return of Morgan Freeman's character, Thaddeus Bradley, who operates in a moral gray area, ensures that the film will maintain its complex web of double-crosses and unexpected reveals. The challenge for the Horsemen will likely be a new, formidable opponent who threatens The Eye, or perhaps a mission from The Eye itself that requires both the old guard's experience and the new team's innovative skills. This generational shift is a key topical authority point, promising a fresh take on the classic heist formula.

Why This Cast is a Game-Changer for the Franchise

The casting choices for *Now You See Me 3* are a strategic move to revitalize the franchise after a long hiatus. By bringing back the fan-favorite core (Eisenberg, Harrelson, Franco, Fisher, Caplan, and Freeman) while adding highly relevant, current stars like Rosamund Pike, Justice Smith, and Dominic Sessa, Lionsgate is ensuring the film appeals to both the original fanbase and a new, younger audience. The blend of classic, theatrical magic from the original Horsemen with the potential for modern, digital-age illusions from the new generation, all under the direction of an action veteran like Ruben Fleischer, creates a high-stakes, high-reward proposition. With filming wrapped and a 2025 release date confirmed, the stage is set for a truly spectacular and unexpected cinematic event. Fans should prepare for a new level of misdirection, illusion, and a cast that is ready to steal the show.