5 Shocking Times Scott Cawthon Commented On MatPat's Theories (Including The Final Farewell)

The relationship between Scott Cawthon and Matthew "MatPat" Patrick has been one of the most iconic and entertaining feuds in gaming history, a friendly, decade-long battle over the convoluted lore of the Five Nights at Freddy's (FNAF) universe. As of December 17, 2025, the most significant and recent "comment" from the creator of FNAF came not in a cryptic Reddit post or a Steam comment, but as a shocking, on-screen cameo in MatPat's final episode of The Game Theorists, solidifying their unique bond as the ultimate conclusion to the "lore war."

This final, emotional appearance served as the ultimate sign-off from the game developer to the theorist who built a career on dissecting his work. Beyond this recent, high-profile moment, Scott Cawthon has a history of engaging with MatPat's theories, sometimes confirming, often refuting, and always adding a layer of mystery to the FNAF narrative. We dive into the most notable instances where the creator broke his silence to address the King of Lore.

Scott Cawthon & Matthew Patrick: Creator and Theorist Profile

To understand the depth of their interaction, it is essential to first know the key figures involved in this legendary rivalry.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

Scott Cawthon (The Creator)

• Full Name: Scott Braden Cawthon
• Born: June 4, 1978 (Age 47 as of 2025)
• Birthplace: Bell County, Texas, USA
• Known For: Creating the highly popular indie horror game series, Five Nights at Freddy's (FNAF).
• Role: Video game developer, animator, writer, and producer.
• Online Alias: "Animdude" on platforms like Steam.
• Career Highlight: Developed FNAF in 2014 after his previous family-friendly games were criticized for having characters that looked like animatronics, which ironically inspired the horror concept.

Matthew "MatPat" Patrick (The Theorist)

• Full Name: Matthew Robert Patrick
• Born: November 15, 1986 (Age 39 as of 2025)
• Birthplace: Medina, Ohio, USA
• Known For: Creating and hosting the YouTube channel The Game Theorists, which analyzes video game lore, science, and history.
• Role: Internet personality, former YouTuber, political advisor, and actor.
• Career Highlight: MatPat's FNAF theories were instrumental in the early success and explosive growth of both his channel and the Five Nights at Freddy's franchise, turning the lore into a global phenomenon.

The Ultimate Farewell: Scott Cawthon's Cameo in MatPat’s Final Theory

The most recent and definitive interaction between the two titans of FNAF lore occurred during the emotional finale of MatPat's run as the host of The Game Theorists. MatPat announced his retirement in early 2024, and the final episode of his flagship channel was a monumental event for the community.

The Scene and the Cryptic Line

In the episode, which focused on a final, all-encompassing theory, MatPat is seen walking into an office, seemingly to discuss the lore with a mysterious figure. The figure is revealed to be Scott Cawthon himself, making a rare and highly public on-screen appearance.

Scott’s dialogue was short but perfectly encapsulated their long-running, playful dynamic. He simply says: "Come in. We have much to discuss."

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

The Meaning of the Appearance

This cameo, which took place in MatPat’s final theory video, was widely interpreted as the creator finally inviting the theorist behind the curtain. For years, MatPat chased the elusive FNAF lore, often getting close but rarely getting full confirmation from Scott. The scene symbolizes a passing of the torch and a final, private lore reveal, suggesting that now that MatPat is retired, Scott can finally tell him the truth about the entire FNAF timeline without fear of a new theory video dropping the next day.

The community reaction was overwhelmingly positive, viewing it as the perfect, respectful, and humorous conclusion to the "raging FNAF war" between the two.

Historical Comments: The Lore Rivalry That Defined a Franchise

Before the final cameo, Scott Cawthon's comments on MatPat's theories were typically text-based, often appearing on Steam or Reddit, and were famous for their cryptic nature, which only fueled the lore hunters. These interactions established the friendly "rivalry" that became central to the FNAF community.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

1. The FNAF 4 "Got It All Wrong" Comment (The Infamous Refutation)

One of the most famous early comments came after MatPat released a theory on Five Nights at Freddy's 4. Scott, using his Animdude account, posted a comment that suggested MatPat was close, but fundamentally wrong about a core element of the lore.

This single comment sparked massive debate, leading to the community scrutinizing every detail of the theory and the game. The comment was so significant that it was initially rumored to have been deleted, though this was later proven false.

2. The "Final Timeline" Confirmation (The Rare Green Light)

On at least one occasion, after MatPat presented a comprehensive, multi-part "final timeline" theory, Scott commented to confirm that the theorist had finally gotten three major lore points correct.

This was a rare instance of direct confirmation from the creator, giving MatPat a moment of triumph in the complex world of FNAF lore. It validated the deep dive and critical analysis that The Game Theorists channel was known for, providing a temporary "truth" for the community to rally around until the next game was released.

3. The "Almost There" Teases (The Cryptic Encouragement)

Scott often employed vague, encouraging comments after a MatPat theory dropped, suggesting he was "close" or "on the right track" but still missing a crucial piece of the puzzle. These comments were less about refuting and more about gently guiding the community while preserving the mystery. This technique kept the FNAF lore machine churning, ensuring that the theoretical discussion remained a vital part of the franchise's ecosystem.

The Legacy of the Scott Cawthon and MatPat Dynamic

The dynamic between Scott Cawthon and MatPat is arguably one of the most successful examples of creator-fan interaction in gaming history. It was a symbiotic relationship: MatPat’s theories drove massive traffic and interest to the FNAF games, while Scott’s cryptic comments and lore additions provided endless content for MatPat and the entire theory community.

The two entities, the game developer and the internet personality, fostered a community focused on deep analysis, turning the hunt for the truth into a shared, global activity. MatPat’s final cameo from Scott Cawthon was the perfect emotional capstone, confirming that their decade-long "lore war" was built on mutual respect and a shared love for a deeply complex horror narrative. It was the creator's way of saying "Thank you" for everything the theorist did to elevate the franchise.

The retirement of MatPat marks the end of an era, but the numerous references, subtle nods, and direct comments from Scott Cawthon—culminating in the final, on-screen farewell—ensure that their legendary theoretical partnership will be remembered as a cornerstone of the Five Nights at Freddy's legacy.