The Ultimate Taylor Swift Surprise Songs Spreadsheet: A Deep Dive Into The Eras Tour’s Most Obsessive Fan Project (December 2025 Update)

The Taylor Swift surprise songs spreadsheet is more than just a document; it is the single most important, obsessively tracked, and constantly updated fan resource of The Eras Tour. As of December 17, 2025, this digital artifact represents the collective hope and statistical analysis of millions of Swifties, serving as the definitive tracker for the two acoustic performances—one on guitar and one on piano—that change at every single show. This intricate system of tracking has become a sport, a science, and a source of endless debate, all centered around which deep cuts, fan favorites, and vault tracks the global superstar will pluck from her 11-album discography next.

The entire phenomenon began with a simple premise: a unique acoustic set for every city, designed to keep the show fresh and reward the most dedicated fans. However, the initial "no-repeat rule" created a thrilling, finite game, pushing the fan community to create sophisticated spreadsheets and online trackers to document every performance, every mistake, and every special guest appearance. The spreadsheet's data is the key to predicting the "white whale" songs and understanding the evolving dynamics of the most successful concert tour in music history.

The Evolving Rules of The Surprise Song Segment

When The Eras Tour first launched, Taylor Swift established a self-imposed "no-repeat rule" for the surprise songs, meaning once a song was played, it was supposedly off the table for future nights. This rule instantly turned the acoustic set into a high-stakes, once-in-a-lifetime moment for every audience member, creating a global, real-time guessing game. The surprise songs spreadsheet became the primary tool to track the remaining inventory of the artist's vast catalog.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

However, the rules of the game have evolved, a necessary change given the sheer length of the tour, which now spans multiple years and continents. The first exception was made for songs from the Midnights album, which were initially allowed to be repeated due to the album's newness.

The most significant shift came when Swift officially abolished the "no-repeat" rule entirely. She announced that she would now feel free to repeat any song, provided she performed a different version (such as a mashup or a unique arrangement) or simply because she felt like it. This rule change, while initially causing a collective gasp among the statistical Swiftie community, actually opened the door for even more exciting possibilities, allowing her to revisit beloved tracks and incorporate new material from her latest releases, such as The Tortured Poets Department (TTPD).

Key Surprise Song Rules & Exceptions (As of Dec 2025)

• The Core Set: Two songs per night—one on guitar, one on piano—are played acoustically.
• The No-Repeat Rule is Dead: Taylor can now repeat any song she has previously performed.
• The Mashup Exception: Songs played as part of a mashup are considered unique performances and are often a way for her to play tracks multiple times.
• Special Guests: Songs performed with a special guest are often considered an exception, allowing the song to be played again solo.
• Album Inclusion: All 11 "Eras" albums are eligible for the surprise set, including her debut album, Taylor Swift, and her latest, TTPD.

The Spreadsheet’s Impact: Statistics and White Whales

The surprise songs spreadsheet is a testament to the fandom's dedication, meticulously tracking everything from the city and date to the instrument used and any unique commentary provided by Taylor herself. By the end of 2023 alone, she had performed over 125 different songs in the acoustic set.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

The spreadsheet's data allows fans to track the frequency of songs by album, leading to the creation of "surprise song odds" and highly specific predictions. Before the "no-repeat rule" was lifted, the most sought-after songs were the ones that had never been played—the so-called "white whales."

The Most Requested Deep Cuts (The White Whales)

While the rule change means any song is possible, the fan community’s focus has shifted to the songs that remain the least-played or have never been performed live on the tour. These are the tracks that still generate the most excitement when they appear on the tracker:

• From Taylor Swift (Debut): Tracks like "The Outside," "I'd Lie," and "I Heart?" are incredibly rare, with "The Outside" historically having some of the lowest odds of being played.
• From Fearless: The vault track "You All Over Me" is a highly anticipated acoustic performance.
• From Speak Now: Songs like "Dear John" and "Never Grow Up" are deeply emotional fan favorites that cause a frenzy when they appear on the setlist tracker.
• From Red: While many tracks like "State of Grace" and "Treacherous" have been played, fans still clamor for a solo acoustic rendition of "The Last Time."
• From 1989: Despite being a major Era, deep cuts like "All You Had To Do Was Stay," "I Wish You Would," and "This Love" are still considered major gets for the acoustic set.
• From The Tortured Poets Department (TTPD): The newest era presents the biggest mystery. Fans are now tracking which TTPD tracks will make their way into the acoustic rotation, with many expecting songs like "So Long, London" to be played during the London shows.

The Future of Surprise Song Tracking and Fan Theories

The surprise songs spreadsheet has proven to be a vital piece of the fan experience, fueling fan theories and predictions for every stop. The community is not just tracking what she *has* played, but attempting to decode *why* she chose a certain song in a certain city.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

One prevalent fan theory suggests that Taylor uses the surprise songs to drop "Easter eggs" about her future plans. For instance, the heavy rotation of certain country songs, while leaving others like "Picture to Burn" untouched, led to speculation about a dedicated country music show or a specific re-recording announcement.

Another theory revolves around the concept of a "full album" goal. Many Swifties believe she is attempting to perform every single one of her original songs at least once before the tour concludes, a monumental task that keeps the surprise song spreadsheet a relevant, ever-changing document. The recent rule change may be her way of ensuring this goal is achievable, allowing her to circle back to missed tracks while still keeping the show exciting with powerful repeats like "Clean" or "Out Of The Woods."

Ultimately, the Taylor Swift surprise songs spreadsheet is the perfect encapsulation of The Eras Tour's magic. It transforms a simple concert segment into a shared, global, interactive experience. Whether you’re tracking the odds of hearing "Welcome To New York" or hoping for a spontaneous "New Romantics," the spreadsheet remains the definitive scoreboard for the most thrilling two songs of the night.