5 Shocking Revelations About Natalie Martinez From Big Brother 11: Where Is The Runner-Up Now In 2025?

For fans of classic reality television, few seasons spark as much debate as Big Brother 11 (BB11), and at the heart of that chaos was the season’s polarizing runner-up, Natalie Martinez. Despite the season concluding over a decade ago in 2009, interest in Natalie’s strategic, yet often controversial, gameplay and her life since leaving the house remains incredibly high, especially as of December 17, 2025.

From her infamous lie about her age to her surprising run to the Final Two, Natalie Martinez proved to be one of the most memorable contestants of her era. Today, her life looks vastly different from the cutthroat game she played on CBS. We dive deep into her complete biography, her tumultuous journey through the *Big Brother* house, and what the former "Athletes" clique member is focusing on now.

Complete Biography and Profile of Natalie Martinez (Majeran)

Natalie Martinez entered the Big Brother 11 house with a competitive background and a clear plan to deceive her fellow HouseGuests. Her pre-show life was marked by serious athletic achievement, a detail she strategically hid from her competitors.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

• Full Name: Natalie Gloria Majeran (née Martinez)
• Date of Birth: March 3, 1985
• Current Age (2025): 40 years old
• Hometown (BB11): Gilbert, Arizona (also cited as Chino, California)
• Occupation (BB11): Store Manager / Recent College Graduate
• Pre-Show Achievement: World Champion bronze medalist in Tae Kwon Do (Junior Olympic Championships in 2002)
• BB Season: Big Brother 11 (US)
• Final Result: Runner-Up (2nd Place)
• Post-Show Spouse: Jason Majeran
• Children: Three children, including son Christian Scott Majeran (born August 1, 2013)

From Tae Kwon Do Champion to Reality TV Villain: Her Big Brother 11 Game

Natalie’s time in the Big Brother house was defined by her allegiance to the "Athletes" clique and her willingness to employ aggressive, often manipulative, tactics. She quickly aligned herself with the returning player, Jessie Godderz, and Chima Simone, forming a tight-knit group that controlled the early weeks of the game.

The Infamous Age Lie and Strategic Deception

One of Natalie's most memorable strategic moves was lying about her age, claiming to be 18 when she was actually 24 at the time of the show. This deception was a deliberate attempt to appear naive and less threatening to the older HouseGuests, allowing her to fly under the radar during the crucial pre-jury phase. This tactic, combined with hiding her competitive Tae Kwon Do background, demonstrated her commitment to a strategic, if morally questionable, game plan.

Surviving the Coup D'État Twist

The course of Big Brother 11 dramatically shifted with the introduction of the controversial "Coup D'État" power, which was won by Jeff Schroeder. This twist allowed Jeff to overthrow Chima's Head of Household (HOH) nominations, leading directly to the eviction of Natalie’s key ally, Jessie Godderz. Following this event and Chima's subsequent expulsion from the game, Natalie found herself at the absolute bottom of the house, nominated five times throughout the season—the most of any HouseGuest in BB11.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

It was during this low point that Natalie, alongside Kevin Campbell, engineered one of the season's most celebrated strategic moves: convincing Jeff Schroeder to use the Power of Veto (POV) on Russell Kairouz and then evicting him, a move that fractured the opposing side of the house. This demonstrated her scrappy, adaptable nature and her ability to manipulate key players, even when she was a primary target.

Life After the House: Marriage, Motherhood, and Her Current Focus

While the $500,000 grand prize eluded her, Natalie Martinez found a different kind of prize shortly after her time on Big Brother. During a "Pandora’s Box" twist in the game, Natalie received a private date where her long-time boyfriend, Jason Majeran, proposed to her, which she accepted.

The couple has since built a family together, with Natalie now going by Natalie Majeran. They officially married and have welcomed three children. Their first son, Christian Scott Majeran, was born on August 1st, 2013. The former HouseGuest has largely retreated from the public eye, focusing on her role as a wife and mother, a significant shift from the high-stakes, televised drama of her reality TV past. Her social media presence is dedicated primarily to family life and personal updates, rather than a continuation of her reality TV career.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

This focus on family is a common trajectory for former reality stars, but for a player as strategically focused and polarizing as Natalie, the quiet domestic life serves as a stark contrast to the cutthroat game she played. Her current life in Gilbert, Arizona, or surrounding areas, remains private, reinforcing her commitment to her family away from the constant scrutiny of the Big Brother fandom.

The BB11 Jury Controversy: Why Natalie Lost the 5-2 Vote

Natalie’s journey to the Final Two was a testament to her strategic prowess, yet her ultimate loss to Jordan Lloyd highlighted the fatal flaw in her gameplay: jury management. She lost the final vote 5-2, with only Kevin Campbell and Russell Kairouz voting for her to win.

The Cost of Poor Social Play

Despite being widely considered the more strategic player by many fans, Natalie's aggressive lying and perceived "mean girl" attitude alienated the jury members, particularly those she had betrayed. Her final goodbye message to Jessie Godderz, where she revealed she had a boyfriend outside the house and had been "playing" him, sealed his bitter vote against her. Similarly, Lydia Tavera, who had a strong connection with Jessie, was also emotionally swayed against Natalie.

This outcome has led to Natalie Martinez being frequently compared to other great strategic players who failed to win the jury vote, such as Danielle Reyes from *Big Brother 3*. Danielle Reyes herself commented on the matter, suggesting that society often prefers to vote for the "nice girl" (like Jordan Lloyd) over the "mean" strategic woman, a common critique of the *Big Brother* jury system.

The jury’s emotional voting was a major theme of the season’s finale. While Russell and Kevin respected her game moves enough to give her their votes, the remaining five members voted based on personal feelings and bitterness, ultimately awarding the $500,000 prize to the more socially beloved Jordan Lloyd.

Natalie Martinez’s Enduring Legacy on Big Brother History

More than a decade and a half after Big Brother 11 aired, Natalie Martinez remains a fixture in discussions about the show's best non-winners. She is remembered not just for her alliance with Jessie Godderz or her rivalry with Lydia Tavera, but for her sheer determination to survive when the odds were stacked against her.

Her ability to navigate the post-*Coup D'État* landscape, manipulate Jeff Schroeder into a game-changing move, and make it to the Final Two despite being a massive target solidified her status as a scrappy, adaptive player. Her game is often cited in discussions about the importance of social game versus strategic game in the *Big Brother* environment.

While she may not have won the prize money, Natalie's legacy as a controversial, cunning, and resilient competitor ensures that Big Brother 11 will always be defined by her presence. Today, as a dedicated mother of three, Natalie Majeran has traded the drama of the house for the quiet joy of family life, a truly successful "post-game" win.