The 7 Must-Try Dishes At Nelson's Pizza House Oxford NC: A Deep Dive Into Granville County's Best NY-Style Pie

For anyone searching for the definitive slice of New York-style pizza in the heart of North Carolina, Nelson's Pizza House in Oxford, NC, remains the undisputed local champion. As of December 2025, this beloved Granville County eatery continues to serve up a fresh, hand-tossed experience that goes far beyond the standard takeout fare, establishing itself as a cornerstone of the local dining scene. Located conveniently at 1011 Lewis St, Ste 105, Nelson's is a must-visit destination for residents and travelers craving authentic Italian-American cuisine and a truly exceptional pie.

The mission at Nelson's Pizza House is simple yet profound: "to delight our customers with exceptional pizza, crafted with passion, where every slice brings a smile." This commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in their menu, which features classic specialties, hearty subs, and a range of traditional Italian dishes, all prepared with fresh ingredients and a dedication to the craft of pizza-making.

Nelson's Pizza House: Location, Atmosphere, and Culinary Philosophy

Nestled in a cozy spot on Lewis Street, Nelson's Pizza House offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements its home-style cooking. It's the kind of local establishment where the staff knows the regulars and the aroma of baking crust and simmering marinara sauce greets you at the door. The restaurant prides itself on its authentic approach to pizza, specifically focusing on the renowned New York (NY) style. This means a thin, hand-tossed crust that is perfectly baked—crisp on the outside, yet foldable, a true hallmark of quality pizza.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

The culinary philosophy here is centered on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, from the rich, tangy tomato sauce to the generous portions of mozzarella and other specialty cheeses. While the focus is pizza, the menu is a comprehensive Italian-American offering, ensuring there is something for every craving, whether you're in the mood for a classic sub, a pasta bowl, or a gourmet specialty pizza.

The Definitive Nelson's Pizza House Menu Guide: 7 Essential Dishes

While the entire menu is worth exploring, certain items have achieved legendary status among Oxford locals. These signature dishes showcase the best of what Nelson's Pizza House has to offer, from their specialty pies to their comforting pasta dishes and appetizers.

1. The Iconic Nelson's Special Pizza

This is the signature pie that every first-time visitor must try. The Nelson's Special is a masterful combination of savory meats and fresh vegetables, featuring generous layers of ham, crispy bacon, fresh onion, and bright, fresh tomato. What truly sets it apart is the subtle, aromatic addition of cracked pepper, which gives the entire pizza a layer of complex, earthy spice that elevates the flavor profile beyond a standard supreme. It’s a classic pie that perfectly balances salty, sweet, and savory notes.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

2. The All-American Nelson's Supreme Pizza

For those who believe more is more, the Nelson's Supreme Pizza is a feast for the senses. This pie is loaded with a powerful lineup of classic toppings, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, and ham, complemented by fresh mushrooms, sweet bell peppers, onions, and black olives. It’s a hearty, fully-loaded option that satisfies the biggest appetite and is perfect for sharing with family or friends.

3. Authentic NY-Style Calzones and Strombolis

Beyond the flat pies, Nelson's excels at its folded Italian specialties. The Calzone is a pocket of pure comfort, stuffed with creamy ricotta cheese, rich mozzarella, and your choice of one topping, served with a side of house-made marinara sauce for dipping. The Stromboli offers a more robust, rolled-up experience, typically packed with mozzarella, zesty Italian sausage, and pepperoni, making it a delicious, portable alternative to a full pizza.

4. The Gourmet Ranch Chicken Bacon Pizza

Appealing to modern tastes, the Ranch Chicken Bacon Pizza is a decadent specialty pie. It swaps the traditional tomato base for a creamy ranch sauce, topped with tender pieces of chicken and savory bacon. This white pizza is a popular choice for those looking for a richer, more indulgent flavor profile that’s a step away from the classic red sauce pizzas.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

5. Comforting Baked Italian Classics

Nelson's Pizza House isn't just a pizza joint; it’s a full-service Italian-American restaurant. Their baked pasta dishes are a testament to this breadth of cuisine. The Lasagna is a perennial favorite, layered with meat sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella, baked to a bubbly, golden-brown perfection. Similarly, the Chicken Parmesan—a crispy, breaded chicken cutlet topped with marinara and melted cheese, served over pasta—is a must-order dish that showcases the kitchen's skill with non-pizza entrees.

6. The Unexpected Star: Buffalo Chicken Dip

A surprising yet highly-rated appetizer is the Buffalo Chicken Dip. This creamy, spicy dip is served with a side of house chips, carrots, and celery, making it an ideal starter for a group. It’s a testament to the menu's versatility, blending classic pub fare with the Italian-American focus, and is often cited in reviews as a standout item.

7. The Nelson's Club Sandwich

For a quick, satisfying lunch, the extensive sub and sandwich menu offers great value. The Nelson's Club Sandwich provides a massive, multi-layered option, perfect for a filling midday meal. Like their pizzas, the subs are made with quality deli meats and fresh vegetables, all piled high on soft bread.

Nelson's Pizza and the Oxford NC Community

Nelson's Pizza House holds a special place in the Oxford, NC community, extending its reach beyond its address at 1011 Lewis St. It serves as a reliable, family-friendly dining option in Granville County, catering to local events and family dinners alike. Its consistent quality has earned it a reputation as one of the best pizza establishments in the area, often competing with larger chains by focusing on superior ingredients and a personal touch.

The restaurant is also highly accessible, offering multiple convenient ways to enjoy their food. Customers can choose to dine in for the cozy atmosphere, utilize their efficient takeout service, or opt for delivery through popular platforms like DoorDash and Toast. This flexibility ensures that whether you're a student at a nearby school, a business professional on lunch break, or a family enjoying a night in, a hot, fresh meal from Nelson's is always within reach.

A Note on Operating Hours and Ordering

While the business maintains a strong online presence for ordering, specific daily hours can sometimes fluctuate, particularly on weekends or during holiday seasons. To ensure the most current information regarding their hours of operation, especially for late-night ordering or on a specific day of the week, it is always recommended to check the official Nelson's Pizza House website or call the restaurant directly. This proactive step ensures you can plan your visit perfectly to enjoy their hand-tossed NY-style pizzas, rich lasagna, and famous calzones.

In a town that cherishes its local businesses, Nelson's Pizza House stands out. It's more than just a place to grab a quick slice; it’s a local institution that delivers on its promise of joy, one delicious, perfectly baked slice at a time. The next time you are in Oxford, NC, looking for an authentic and satisfying meal, make the pilgrimage to Lewis Street and taste the difference that passion and quality ingredients make.