7 Reasons Why Nelson's Pizza House Is Oxford, NC's Must-Try NY-Style Destination

For residents and visitors of Granville County, North Carolina, Nelson's Pizza House has firmly established itself as the go-to destination for authentic, hand-tossed New York-style pizza. Located conveniently on Lewis Street in the heart of Oxford, this local gem is dedicated to delivering an exceptional dining experience, focusing on fresh ingredients and perfectly baked pies that live up to the local claim of being the "BEST Pizza in Town."

As of December 15, 2025, Nelson's Pizza House continues its mission to delight customers one slice at a time, offering a comprehensive menu that goes far beyond the classic cheese pizza. From savory specialty pies to hearty appetizers and paninis, the restaurant provides a cozy, charming atmosphere that makes it a staple of the Oxford, NC, community.

The Nelson's Pizza House Experience: Location, Mission, and Menu Pillars

Nelson's Pizza House is more than just a pizza shop; it is a local institution that embodies the spirit of quality and community in Oxford, North Carolina. The restaurant's core mission is simple: to craft exceptional pizza that brings joy to every customer. This commitment to quality is evident in their signature New York (NY) style approach, where every pizza base is fresh and hand-tossed before being perfectly baked to achieve that desirable crispy crust and chewy interior.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

The physical location at 1011 Lewis Street, Unit 105, Oxford, NC 27565, makes it a central and accessible spot for both quick takeout orders and a relaxed dine-in experience. Customers can easily place orders for carryout or utilize popular delivery services like DoorDash, ensuring that a hot, fresh slice of their favorite pie is never far away.

A Deep Dive into the Menu: Beyond the Classic Cheese Pie

While the foundation of Nelson's reputation rests on their classic 16-inch Large Cheese Pizza Base and 12-inch Small Cheese Pizza Base, the true depth of their culinary offerings lies in their diverse and creative specialty menu. The extensive options ensure there is a perfect meal for every palate, from dedicated meat lovers to committed vegetarians.

The menu is strategically organized into several key categories, providing a complete dining solution:

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

• Pizzas: The main event, featuring build-your-own options and a robust list of signature specialty pizzas.
• Appetizers: Perfect for starting the meal or sharing, including house favorites like Buffalo Chicken Dip.
• Wings: A classic side offering with various flavor options.
• Paninis & Bowls: Hearty, non-pizza alternatives for a satisfying lunch or dinner.
• Salads: Fresh, lighter options to complement a heavy meal.

The 7 Must-Try Menu Entities at Nelson's Pizza House

To truly understand why Nelson’s Pizza House is a local favorite in Oxford, NC, one must explore the distinct items that set their menu apart. These seven entities represent the best of their offerings, combining tradition with unique flavor profiles.

1. The Nelson's Special Pizza: This signature pie is a must-order for first-time visitors looking for a taste of the restaurant's unique flair. It features a savory combination of Ham, Bacon, Onion, Fresh Tomato, and a sprinkle of Cracked Pepper, creating a balanced and flavorful experience that highlights the quality of their fresh toppings.
2. The Ranch Chicken Bacon Pizza: A popular choice in the Specialty Pizzas category, this pie combines the creamy richness of ranch dressing with tender Chicken and crispy Bacon, making it a comfort food masterpiece. This is a perfect example of their creative take on classic American flavors.
3. The Buffalo Chicken Dip: Moving beyond pizza, this appetizer is a highly-rated favorite. Served with house chips, carrots, and celery, the creamy, spicy dip is an ideal starter for a group or a satisfying snack on its own. It's a testament to the quality of their non-pizza offerings.
4. The Classic NY-Style 16" Large Cheese Pizza: The cornerstone of their menu, this large pie is the gold standard for judging the quality of their crust, sauce, and cheese blend. It's the perfect choice for family dinners or game days. The commitment to the hand-tossed NY-style crust is what makes this simple item so exceptional.
5. The White Pizza: For those who prefer a non-traditional sauce base, the White Pizza offers a rich, garlicky alternative. It is a flavorful blend of cheeses and seasonings, providing a lighter yet equally satisfying pizza experience compared to the classic marinara base.
6. The Paninis and Bowls: These items offer substantial alternatives to the pizza menu, catering to a wider audience. The inclusion of Paninis (pressed Italian sandwiches) and customizable Bowls demonstrates Nelson's commitment to offering a full Italian-American dining experience beyond just slices and pies.
7. The Mozzarella Cheese Sticks: A classic appetizer done right. Served hot and gooey with a side of marinara, the Cheese Sticks are a simple but essential part of the menu, perfect for quick bites and sharing.

Why Nelson's Pizza is a Granville County Local Favorite

The success of Nelson's Pizza House in Oxford, NC, is rooted in a combination of factors that resonate deeply with the local community in Granville County. The dedication to quality, the speed of service, and the variety of the menu all contribute to its strong reputation.

The emphasis on fresh, hand-tossed dough for their NY-style pizzas is a major differentiator. This artisanal approach to pizza-making ensures a superior texture and flavor that elevates the dining experience above chain competitors. Furthermore, the commitment to making every slice a source of joy is a reflection of the friendly and welcoming customer service that patrons consistently praise.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

In addition to the dine-in and takeout options, the availability of online ordering through platforms like Toast and DoorDash has modernized the Nelson's experience, making it incredibly convenient for the busy lives of Oxford residents. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch for work or ordering a family meal for delivery, the process is streamlined and efficient.

For anyone in the Oxford, NC area, or passing through Granville County, a stop at Nelson’s Pizza House on Lewis Street is highly recommended. It’s an authentic taste of New York pizza tradition, delivered with Southern hospitality and a commitment to being the very best local eatery. Be sure to try the Nelson’s Special or the Buffalo Chicken Dip for a true taste of what makes this pizza house a local legend.