Hall And Makayla Temptation Island: The Shocking Truth About Their Relationship Status In 2025

The whirlwind, controversial romance between Hall Toledano and Makayla Halstead became the defining storyline of Temptation Island Season 5, culminating in one of the most dramatic breakups in the show's history. Two years later, as of December 15, 2025, fans are still desperate to know if their 'soulmate' connection was strong enough to withstand the scrutiny of the real world, the significant age gap, and the fallout from Hall's broken engagement.

The couple's journey from a scandalous villa fling to a post-show commitment was fast-paced and polarizing, leaving a massive question mark over their future. While they left the island together and even made plans to move in at the reunion, the lack of recent public updates has fueled intense speculation: Did the pressure of reality television fame and a new life together prove too much for the unexpected couple?

Hall Toledano and Makayla Halstead: Complete Biography and Relationship Timeline

The relationship between Hall and Makayla began in the most dramatic fashion, with Hall walking away from his 8-year relationship and engagement to Kaitlin Tufts to be with the single Makayla Halstead. This move made them the most talked-about couple of Temptation Island Season 5.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

Hall Toledano Profile

• Full Name: Hall Toledano
• Age (as of 2025): Approximately 37 (He was 35 during Season 5 filming in 2023)
• Hometown/City: Charleston, South Carolina
• Occupation: Leather Sales
• Initial Relationship Status: Engaged to Kaitlin Tufts (for 8 years)
• Key Show Moment: Breaking off his engagement with Kaitlin before the Final Bonfire to pursue Makayla.

Makayla Halstead Profile

• Full Name: Makayla Halstead
• Age (as of 2025): Approximately 26 (She was 24 during Season 5 filming in 2023)
• Hometown/City: Albany, Oregon
• Occupation: Marketing and Dance Student (at the University of Oregon)
• Initial Relationship Status: Single (Temptress)
• Key Show Moment: Declaring her "soulmate" connection with Hall after only a few weeks.

The Controversial Relationship Timeline

Hall and Makayla's connection was immediate and intense, quickly moving from flirtation to a serious, committed relationship on the island. Their bond was a central point of drama, especially given the presence of Hall's fiancée, Kaitlin Tufts, who was blindsided by the speed of their romance.

The controversy surrounding the couple was multifaceted. Critics often cited the significant 11-year age gap between Hall and Makayla, Hall's swift abandonment of his 8-year engagement, and Makayla's perceived lack of empathy towards Kaitlin during the reunion.

The Final Bonfire and Reunion: A Shocking Commitment

The defining moment of the season occurred at the Final Bonfire. Despite the show's premise being about testing existing relationships, Hall Toledano chose to make history by ending his engagement with Kaitlin to leave the island hand-in-hand with Makayla Halstead.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

This decision was met with a mix of shock and skepticism from viewers and the show's host, Mark L. Walberg. Hall was adamant that Makayla was his "soulmate" and the person he was meant to be with, dismissing his long-term engagement as a relationship that had simply run its course.

The commitment was solidified at the highly anticipated reunion special, which aired shortly after the season finale. Both Hall and Makayla confirmed they were still together and happy, having successfully navigated the transition from the villa to the real world. In a grand gesture, Hall even asked Makayla to move in with him.

This post-show update gave hope to fans of the new couple, suggesting that their rapid, intense relationship was indeed genuine and not just a product of the exotic island environment. However, the true test of any reality TV romance comes in the months and years following the final camera call.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Are Hall and Makayla Still Together? The Latest 2025 Status

The question on every Temptation Island fan’s mind—did Hall and Makayla’s controversial 'soulmate' connection last? The definitive answer, as of late 2025, is complicated by a significant lack of recent public updates, a common trend for reality stars who choose to step away from the spotlight.

Following the 2023 reunion, which confirmed they were moving in together, the couple maintained a relatively low profile compared to their on-screen drama. While they were confirmed to be together through the end of 2023, there has been no major news story, joint interview, or public announcement in 2024 or 2025 to definitively confirm their current status.

This silence can be interpreted in two ways, both of which are common in the reality television landscape:

Scenario 1: A Quiet Breakup

Many reality TV relationships, especially those formed under intense pressure and with an age gap, do not survive the mundane reality of everyday life. The lack of joint social media activity or public appearances throughout 2024 and 2025 suggests a high probability that the couple may have quietly parted ways. A breakup announcement would likely generate significant media attention, which the couple may have chosen to avoid after the intense scrutiny they faced during Season 5.

Scenario 2: Extreme Privacy

Alternatively, the couple may have decided to take their relationship completely private. After the backlash they received for Hall's treatment of Kaitlin and the controversial nature of their pairing, stepping away from the public eye would be a logical move to protect their relationship. They may still be living together in Charleston or elsewhere, choosing to enjoy their life away from the constant judgment of social media and the entertainment news cycle.

The Legacy of Temptation Island Season 5

Regardless of their current relationship status, Hall and Makayla's story remains one of the most memorable and polarizing in the history of the USANetwork series. Their decision to pursue a new connection at the expense of an 8-year engagement highlighted the true risk of the Temptation Island experiment.

• Kaitlin Tufts' Journey: Hall's ex-fiancée, Kaitlin, has moved on, focusing on her fitness studio business and her own personal healing journey, becoming a fan favorite for her strength and resilience.
• The Age Gap Debate: The 11-year difference between Hall and Makayla fueled a significant amount of online discussion about the dynamics of their instant connection versus the reality of their differing life stages (a student versus a professional in leather sales).
• The 'Soulmate' Trope: The quick declaration of 'soulmate' status became a major talking point, with many viewers questioning the authenticity of a connection formed in just a few weeks.

Ultimately, Hall Toledano and Makayla Halstead are a reminder that the drama of the island often pales in comparison to the long-term challenges of a post-reality TV romance. The most current and fresh update is the silence itself, suggesting that their life together, whether continued or concluded, has been intentionally kept out of the public eye since their explosive reunion. Fans will have to wait for an official announcement to know for sure if their controversial love story got its happily ever after.