5 Shocking Details About Natalie Eva Marie’s Quiet Divorce From Jonathan Coyle

The news of Natalie Eva Marie’s divorce from Jonathan Coyle sent ripples through the wrestling and reality TV communities, not just because of the split itself, but because of how long she managed to keep it a secret. For fans who followed their relationship closely on the E! reality show *Total Divas*, the end of their decade-long marriage marks a profound shift for the “All Red Everything” star. The filing, which became public in late 2024, revealed a timeline that shows the couple had been separated for over a year before the legal paperwork was submitted, confirming that this was a quiet and deliberate decision by the former WWE Superstar.

The entire process highlights a new chapter for Natalie Eva Marie, who has since relocated and candidly discussed the emotional weight of moving on. As of today, December 15, 2025, the divorce proceedings have been finalized, with the star embracing her entrepreneurial and acting career while finding "peace in the middle of the storm," a clear indication of her focus on a fresh start away from the public scrutiny that once defined her relationship.

The Complete Profile: Natalie Eva Marie & Jonathan Coyle

The relationship between Natalie Eva Marie and Jonathan Coyle was a cornerstone of the early seasons of *Total Divas*, showcasing everything from their passionate chemistry to their intense conflicts. Understanding their individual backgrounds provides essential context for the end of their highly public marriage.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Natalie Eva Marie (Natalie Eva Marie Nelson)

• Full Name: Natalie Eva Marie Nelson (formerly Coyle)
• Date of Birth: September 19, 1984
• Place of Birth: Walnut Creek, California, USA
• Primary Careers: Media Personality, Professional Wrestler, Model, Actress, Businesswoman.
• Notable Work: WWE (two stints, 2013-2017 and 2021), E!’s *Total Divas*, CBS’s *Celebrity Big Brother*.
• Education: Graduated from California State University-Fullerton (played soccer).
• Public Persona: Known as "All Red Everything," she is a major fitness and entrepreneurial figure in the post-WWE phase of her career, focusing heavily on her fashion and fitness brand, *NEM Fashion*.

Jonathan Coyle

• Full Name: Jonathan Coyle
• Primary Careers: Fitness & Nutrition Specialist, Technical Specialist, Forensics Analyst.
• Education: Holds a Bachelor’s degree in Business Management (or History, sources vary) from California Polytechnic State Institute and an MBA from Hope International University.
• Notable Work: Featured heavily on *Total Divas* as Eva Marie’s husband and confidant. He is also a certified fitness expert and model.
• Professional Focus: Beyond his reality TV appearances, Coyle has a strong background in forensics analysis, often working as a technical specialist and expert witness in legal cases.

The Shocking Timeline: Separation, Filing, and Irreconcilable Differences

The official court documents provided a clear, yet surprising, timeline of the couple's separation. While the public learned of the divorce in late 2024, the reality of their split began much earlier, indicating a long period of quiet, private negotiation.

The October 2023 Separation

The most revealing detail in the divorce filing was the official date of separation: October 2023. This means that Natalie Eva Marie and Jonathan Coyle had already been living separate lives for over a year before the formal divorce papers were filed in December 2024. This lengthy separation period allowed the couple to manage the logistics of the split—including property and finances—away from the prying eyes of the media and the public, which is a stark contrast to their highly public relationship on *Total Divas*.

The Official Filing in Late 2024

Natalie Eva Marie, whose legal name is Natalie Eva Marie Nelson, filed for divorce after ten years of marriage, citing the standard legal grounds of "irreconcilable differences." The use of irreconcilable differences, which simply means the marriage cannot be saved, is common in celebrity divorces and suggests that no single, dramatic event was the cause, but rather a fundamental breakdown of the relationship over time.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

The couple, who married in October 2014, had their relationship chronicled on television, which often put their personal conflicts and chemistry under a microscope. The decision to keep the separation quiet for so long before the filing suggests a mutual desire to handle the delicate process with dignity and privacy.

Eva Marie Breaks Her Silence: Finding Peace and a New Chapter

In November 2025, nearly a year after the divorce filing became public, Natalie Eva Marie opened up about the experience, shedding light on the emotional toll and the reasons for her initial silence. Her candid revelations came during an appearance on a podcast, marking the first time she publicly addressed the major life change.

The Decision to Keep It Quiet

During her interview on the "Unwrapped with Sonya" podcast (hosted by WWE's Sonya Deville and Toni Storm), Eva Marie explained her decision to initially tell no one about the separation. For someone whose life was once broadcast on a major reality show, this level of silence was a deliberate, protective choice. She needed time to process the significant life change—the end of a ten-year marriage—without the immediate burden of public opinion and speculation.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

Relocation and a Fresh Start

Eva Marie also revealed that the divorce was accompanied by a major geographical change: she relocated from Texas back to her home state of California. This move symbolizes a new chapter, both personally and professionally. She framed the entire period not as a painful setback, but as a time of personal growth and finding "peace in the middle of the storm." This positive spin on a difficult situation is consistent with her entrepreneurial and motivational brand.

The Post-Divorce Trajectory: Career and Future Focus

With the divorce finalized, Natalie Eva Marie has fully pivoted her focus to her burgeoning career outside of the wrestling ring. The end of her marriage coincides with a period of intense professional activity, solidifying her status as a multi-hyphenate media personality.

The Entrepreneurial and Acting Focus

Eva Marie has successfully transitioned from her WWE persona into a serious businesswoman and actress. She has been heavily involved in multiple acting projects, brand endorsements, and the expansion of her lifestyle and fitness empire. The divorce appears to have fueled, rather than hindered, her professional ambition, allowing her to channel her energy into her various ventures.

Topical Entities and LSI Keywords:

The story of the split is inextricably linked to several key entities and search terms that provide topical authority:

• Total Divas: The reality show that introduced the couple and chronicled their relationship's highs and lows.
• Irreconcilable Differences: The official legal reason for the divorce filing.
• WWE Superstar: Her professional identity, which always drew attention to her personal life.
• Jonathan Coyle Cheating Rumors: Although the official reason was "irreconcilable differences," online speculation often centers on potential conflicts shown or hinted at during *Total Divas*.
• Relocation to California: A key physical and symbolic move in her new, post-divorce life.
• Sonya Deville Podcast: The platform where she chose to finally break her silence.
• NEM Fashion: Her fitness and fashion brand, which is a major focus of her current business endeavors.

Natalie Eva Marie’s quiet divorce from Jonathan Coyle serves as a powerful reminder that celebrity relationships, even those documented on reality television, often have a private life that is far more complex than what is shown on screen. Her decision to keep the separation private for over a year, followed by her candid discussion about finding personal peace, has set the stage for a compelling new chapter in her career and personal journey.