7 Must-Try Dishes And The Latest Menu Prices At Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar (2025 Update)

Step into the heart of authentic Italian-American dining in Youngstown, Ohio, and you'll find Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar, a beloved local institution that goes far beyond your average pizza joint. As of the current date in 2025, this family-owned establishment continues to draw crowds with its commitment to fresh, homemade ingredients—from the hand-tossed pizza dough to the rich, slow-simmered sauces and croutons. The menu is a vibrant tapestry of classic Italian comfort food, ensuring that every visit offers a hearty, flavorful, and memorable experience for families, casual diners, and those looking for a lively full-service bar.

Giangelo's has successfully carved out a niche by offering generous portions of high-quality cuisine at competitive prices, solidifying its reputation as a cornerstone of the Boardman dining scene. This deep dive into the latest menu reveals the signature dishes, current pricing, and the diverse offerings that make this spot a true Mahoning Valley treasure. Whether you're craving a classic specialty pizza or a comforting plate of homemade pasta, this guide will help you navigate the best of what Giangelo's has to offer.

Giangelo's Pizzeria Profile: A Youngstown Family Tradition

Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar is more than just a place to eat; it's a testament to the enduring appeal of traditional, family-run establishments in the Mahoning Valley. Located conveniently at 1315 Boardman-Canfield Rd in Youngstown, Ohio, the restaurant serves as a casual dining hub known for its warm atmosphere and commitment to quality. The "Italian Restaurant & Bar" designation is key, as it highlights the full-service experience, complete with a sports lounge area and a well-stocked bar offering a variety of beer, wine, and spirits to complement the meal.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

• Type of Establishment: Family-Owned Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Full-Service Bar.
• Cuisine Focus: Authentic Italian-American Comfort Food, Pizza, and Classic Pasta Dishes.
• Location: 1315 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Youngstown, OH 44512 (Boardman Area).
• Signature Commitment: Everything made fresh in-house, including dough, sauces, and croutons.
• Atmosphere: Casual, inviting, and family-friendly, with a separate lounge/bar area.
• Key Offerings: Specialty Pizzas, Italian Dinners (Parmesan dishes), Pasta, Sandwiches, Calzones, and Bolis.

The restaurant’s enduring success is built on a foundation of consistency and value. Diners frequently praise the generous portion sizes, ensuring that guests often leave with leftovers. This dedication to providing a high-quality, abundant meal is a hallmark of the Giangelo's experience, making it a reliable choice for both a quick lunch and a hearty family dinner.

The Essential Menu Breakdown: Signature Dishes and Current Pricing

The menu at Giangelo's is extensive, covering all the staples of Italian-American cuisine. To help you plan your visit, here is a breakdown of the must-try items and their approximate current prices, showcasing the diversity from their famous pizzas to their comforting pasta dinners.

1. Specialty Pizzas, Rolls, and Bolis (The Hand-Tossed Favorites)

While classic cheese pizzas are available (a 12-inch is approximately $13.99 and a 16-inch is around $16.99), the true gems of the pizzeria section lie in their specialty pies and unique Italian wraps. These are crafted with their signature hand-tossed dough and fresh ingredients.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

• Must-Try #1: The Vodka Pie. This specialty pizza is one of the most talked-about items. It features a creamy, rich vodka sauce base instead of traditional marinara, offering a unique and indulgent flavor profile. The exact price varies by size, but it's a staple for a reason.
• Must-Try #2: The Giangelo Roll. A customer favorite, this is a distinct take on a stromboli or calzone, packed with meats, cheeses, and their special sauce, priced at approximately $12.99.
• Buffalo Chicken Boli: A popular, savory option featuring chicken tossed in buffalo sauce and cheese, served in their baked dough. Price: Approximately $13.99.
• Meatball and Hot Pepper Pizza: Another highly-rated specialty pie, combining homemade meatballs and local hot peppers for a kick of flavor.

2. Classic Italian Dinners (The Comfort Food Core)

The "Italian Restaurant" side of Giangelo's shines with its traditional dinners, which are often cited in reviews for their perfect balance of flavors and large portions. These dishes come complete and are the heart of a full Italian meal.

• Must-Try #3: Chicken Parmigiana. Widely praised as one of the best items on the menu, the Chicken Parmigiana features a perfectly breaded and cooked chicken cutlet, smothered in rich marinara and melted mozzarella. Price: Approximately $17.99.
• Must-Try #4: Eggplant Parmesan. A vegetarian counterpart to the classic, offering tender eggplant layered with cheese and sauce. Price: Approximately $16.99.
• Pasta & Meatballs: A quintessential Italian comfort dish, featuring your choice of pasta with their homemade sauce and meatballs. Price: Approximately $14.49.

3. Signature Pasta Dishes (The Homemade Difference)

Giangelo's takes pride in its pasta offerings, particularly those featuring local or regional favorites like cavatelli. The homemade sauces and meatballs elevate these simple dishes to a higher level of authentic Italian cuisine.

• Must-Try #5: Cavatelli & Meatballs. Cavatelli is a popular pasta shape in the Youngstown area, and Giangelo's version is a must-try, often praised for its freshness and texture. Price: Approximately $15.29.
• Ravioli & Meatballs: Stuffed pasta pockets served with their signature sauce. Price: Approximately $16.29.

4. Sandwiches, Appetizers, and The Full Bar Experience

Beyond the main courses, the menu is rounded out with hearty sandwiches, paninis, and a full selection of starters and bar service options that cater to a casual, lively crowd.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

• Must-Try #6: Italian Beef Panini. Featuring slow-roasted sliced roast beef with sautéed green peppers and mozzarella cheese, pressed to perfection. This sandwich is a substantial and flavorful option for lunch or a lighter dinner.
• Must-Try #7: The Wings. Giangelo's offers a variety of appetizers, but their wings are a popular choice for bar patrons and families alike, with 12 wings priced around $15.99.
• Appetizers & Salads: The menu includes classic starters and a selection of soups and fresh salads, providing lighter options.
• The Full Bar: The bar and lounge area is a major draw, offering a full selection of beverages, including specialty cocktails, wine, and beer, perfect for catching a game or enjoying a night out.

Why Giangelo's Remains a Youngstown Favorite: Topical Authority and LSI Entities

Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar has achieved a high level of topical authority in the Youngstown and Boardman area by mastering the core elements of Italian-American dining. The restaurant’s success can be attributed to several key factors that reinforce its status as a local landmark:

• Commitment to Freshness: The emphasis on making key components—like the hand-tossed pizza dough, fresh sauces, and even the croutons—in-house is a significant differentiator. This dedication to fresh ingredients ensures a higher quality and more authentic taste in every dish.
• The Power of the Full Menu: Unlike many pizzerias, Giangelo's successfully balances the "Pizzeria" and "Italian Restaurant & Bar" identities. Customers can choose between casual pizza and bolis or more formal, hearty Italian dinners like Chicken Parmesan and Eggplant Parmesan, all under one roof.
• Value and Portion Size: The consistent feedback regarding the generous portions for the price highlights the restaurant’s commitment to providing excellent value, a crucial factor for family dining in Mahoning County.

The natural integration of Local Search Intent (LSI) entities throughout the menu and atmosphere—such as Cavatelli (a regional favorite), Boardman-Canfield Rd (the specific location), Youngstown, Ohio, and the Mahoning Valley—further solidifies its local relevance. Whether you’re a local seeking a reliable family dinner or a visitor looking for authentic Youngstown Italian food, Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar offers a comprehensive and satisfying dining experience.

From the creamy Vodka Pie to the comforting Cavatelli & Meatballs, Giangelo's continues to serve as a beacon of traditional, high-quality Italian cuisine. It's a must-visit destination for anyone exploring the culinary landscape of Northeast Ohio.