5 Shocking Facts About Sharon Weiss, The Marie Callender’s Burnt Pie Legend, And Her Viral Legacy

Every year, as the holiday season approaches, a new generation of internet users discovers the legendary tale of Sharon Weiss and her infamous Marie Callender’s pie. This is not a story about a corporate executive or a celebrity chef; instead, it's the deeply relatable, and utterly hilarious, saga of a Georgia grandmother whose Thanksgiving dessert fail in 2021 became one of the most enduring and annually recurring holiday memes on the internet. As of December 14, 2025, the burnt pie remains a symbol of holiday cooking stress, a cautionary tale for home bakers, and a testament to the power of a single viral Facebook post.

The incident transcended a simple kitchen mishap, transforming Sharon Weiss into an accidental internet icon, forever synonymous with a charred pumpkin pie. Her single, bitter Facebook post blaming the frozen food giant sparked a global conversation about oven settings, holiday expectations, and the difference between Celsius and Fahrenheit. Here is a deep dive into the true story, the resolution, and the lasting legacy of the woman who "ruined" her own Thanksgiving.

Sharon Weiss: Biography of an Accidental Internet Icon

Sharon Weiss is a private citizen whose life was unexpectedly thrust into the public spotlight due to a single, memorable event. Unlike traditional biographies, her fame stems entirely from a moment of candid frustration shared on social media.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

• Full Name: Sharon Weiss
• Role in Viral Event: Home Cook / Grandmother
• Location (at time of event): Georgia, USA
• Date of Viral Post: Thanksgiving Day, November 25, 2021
• Product Involved: Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie (Frozen)
• Viral Quote: “Thanks Marie Calendar for ruining thanksgiving dessert.”
• Cause of Failure: Mistakenly setting the oven to Celsius instead of Fahrenheit.
• Current Status: Believed to be enjoying private life, celebrated annually as a Thanksgiving meme legend.

The Anatomy of a Viral Disaster: Celsius, Fahrenheit, and the Charred Crust

The core of the Sharon Weiss story is a simple, yet devastating, technical error that millions of home cooks have likely feared. The moment the photo of the pie—a black, shriveled, and completely inedible disc—hit the Marie Callender’s Facebook page, the internet exploded.

1. The Infamous Facebook Post and Immediate Backlash

The original post, shared on Thanksgiving Day 2021, showed the pie and the caption that directly blamed the frozen food brand for the failure. The pie was cooked so severely that it was almost unrecognizable. While Sharon Weiss intended to express her frustration with a product she felt had failed her, the internet quickly identified the true culprit: user error.

Commenters immediately pointed out the key detail: the pie looked like it had been cooked at an extremely high, incorrect temperature. The common theory, which was later confirmed, was that Sharon Weiss had set her oven to the temperature indicated on the box, but in Celsius (C) rather than Fahrenheit (F). For example, a recipe calling for 350°F would be nearly 177°C, but setting an oven to 350°C would be a scorching 662°F—more than enough to turn a frozen pie into a lump of coal.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

2. The Oven Setting Revelation: Celsius vs. Fahrenheit

The difference between the two temperature scales became an instant, educational meme. The intense heat from the Celsius setting was the real reason for the "ruined" dessert. This small, critical detail transformed the story from a product complaint into a universal, cautionary tale about checking your oven settings, especially when dealing with new appliances or international recipes. The incident highlighted the widespread confusion over temperature units, making the story even more relatable to a global audience.

The Resolution and Sharon Weiss's Lasting Legacy

Unlike many online shaming incidents, the story of Sharon Weiss had a positive and heartwarming conclusion. The company, Marie Callender’s, handled the situation with exceptional grace and good humor, turning a potential PR crisis into a moment of viral marketing success.

3. A Sweet Reconciliation with Marie Callender’s

Following the massive viral attention, Sharon Weiss and Marie Callender's connected. The company reportedly sent her a replacement pie and other items, officially making up for the Thanksgiving disaster. More importantly, the company helped her understand the technical error, confirming that her oven had indeed been set to Celsius.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Sharon Weiss publicly stated that she had reconciled with the brand and confirmed she would be attempting to bake again, this time ensuring her oven was correctly set to Fahrenheit.

4. The Annual Recurrence of the "Burnt Pie" Meme

The most current and enduring aspect of the Sharon Weiss story is its annual resurgence. Every November, as Thanksgiving approaches, the photo of the burnt pie and the "Thanks Marie Calendar" quote are shared across social media platforms like Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and Reddit.

The meme has become a holiday tradition, an unofficial signal that the Thanksgiving cooking season has begun. It serves as a lighthearted reminder to check the oven, set a timer, and keep a sense of humor when things inevitably go wrong in the kitchen. The legacy is no longer about the failure itself, but about the resilience and humor in the face of a holiday mishap.

5. Sharon Weiss: A Symbol of Kitchen Chaos and Topical Authority

Sharon Weiss has inadvertently cemented her place in internet history as a symbol of the stress and occasional chaos of holiday cooking. Her story provides topical authority for a host of related entities, including:

• Oven Calibration and Settings: Highlighting the importance of correct temperature units.
• Frozen Desserts and Prepared Foods: Drawing attention to the instructions on popular holiday products.
• Viral Marketing and PR: Serving as a case study in how a brand (Marie Callender’s) can positively engage with a negative social media post.
• The Power of Memes: Demonstrating how a simple photo and caption can become an enduring cultural touchstone, recognized annually by millions.
• Georgia Grandmother Archetype: Representing the everyday person who can achieve unexpected viral fame.

While Sharon Weiss herself has returned to a private life, her burnt pie continues to circulate, ensuring that the legend of the Celsius-set oven and the charred Marie Callender's pumpkin pie remains a celebrated part of Thanksgiving folklore for years to come. Her story serves as a perennial, humorous warning: always double-check your temperature settings.