The 5 Most Shocking Catfish: The TV Show Season 3 Episodes And Where The Cast Is Now

The third season of MTV's *Catfish: The TV Show*, which originally aired in 2014, remains one of the series' most iconic and explosive runs. Known for its unforgettable twists, celebrity appearances, and the introduction of some of the most notorious "catfishers" in the show's history, Season 3 set a new standard for online dating drama. As of today, December 13, 2025, fans are still looking back at the season's landmark episodes, eager to know what happened to the participants after the cameras stopped rolling and the reveals went viral.

This deep dive into *Catfish* Season 3 goes beyond the initial reveal to uncover the current status of the most memorable cast members, from the infamous Kidd Cole's criminal troubles to the surprising truth behind the show's most emotional and controversial episodes. Host Nev Schulman and former co-host Max Joseph certainly had their hands full with this dramatic season.

Catfish Season 3: Episode Guide and Cast Updates

Season 3 featured a total of 12 episodes, each bringing a unique and often unbelievable story of deception and hope in the world of online dating. The season is widely considered a turning point for the MTV reality show, showcasing increasingly elaborate and high-stakes catfishing scenarios.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Here are the five most talked-about episodes from *Catfish: The TV Show* Season 3 and the latest updates on the people involved.

1. Antwane & Tony: The Iconic Neighbor Twist

Episode Details: "Antwane & Tony" is arguably the most famous episode of Season 3, and a strong contender for the most iconic *Catfish* episode of all time. Antwane, a man from Washington D.C., was in a three-year online relationship with a man named "Tony." The relationship was plagued by drama, with "Tony" constantly demanding money and causing Antwane emotional distress. The tension peaked when "Tony" sent Antwane a shocking, derogatory text message.

The Reveal: In a twist no one saw coming, "Tony" was revealed to be Carmen, Antwane's neighbor and former childhood friend. Carmen admitted that she catfished Antwane out of revenge for a past slight and to get attention. The reveal, which took place just a few blocks from Antwane's home, led to the famous line, "You got me messed up!"

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

Where Are They Now?

• Antwane: Following the episode, Antwane was celebrated by fans for his emotional reaction and his resilience. While he has largely stayed out of the public eye, he has appeared in retrospective *Catfish* specials, confirming that he has moved on from the painful experience.
• Carmen (The Catfisher): Carmen received significant backlash but later expressed remorse for her actions. The two were reportedly trying to mend their friendship during the initial "Where Are They Now" follow-ups, though the long-term status of their relationship is unknown. This episode remains a cautionary tale about seeking revenge through online deception.

2. Lucille & Kidd Cole: The Catfisher Who Couldn't Stop Scamming

Episode Details: The "Lucille & Kidd Cole" episode is famous not just for the catfishing itself, but for the unprecedented level of arrogance displayed by the catfisher, and a rare moment of anger from host Nev Schulman. Lucille was dating a supposed music producer named "Kidd Cole," who claimed to work with major artists and promised her a career in the industry. He constantly demanded money for travel and other expenses, leaving Lucille financially and emotionally drained.

The Reveal: "Kidd Cole" was revealed to be Jerez Nehemiah Stone-Coleman, a serial scammer. His deception was so brazen that he even tried to manipulate Nev and Max, demanding a production assistant's help and acting like a celebrity. The episode's climax occurred when Nev, fed up with Kidd Cole’s behavior, famously grabbed and threw his phone into the water—a moment of justified frustration that became a legendary *Catfish* meme.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

The Shocking Post-Show Update (2025):

• Jerez Nehemiah Stone-Coleman (Kidd Cole): His story took a very dark turn after the show. Stone-Coleman was later arrested and charged with making terroristic threats. He was accused of calling in false bomb threats and other hoaxes against the Washington D.C. Metro transit system, often using his "Kidd Cole" persona to demand special treatment. He was sentenced to 21 months in prison for these crimes, confirming that his pattern of manipulation and scamming extended far beyond the MTV reality show.
• Lucille: Lucille was able to move on from the experience, relieved to have the truth and to stop the financial bleeding caused by Kidd Cole's scams.

3. Tracie & Sammie: The Celebrity Connection

Episode Details: "Tracie & Sammie" stood out because the person seeking help was actress Tracie Thoms, known for her roles in *Rent* and *Death Proof*. Tracie was concerned about one of her biggest online fans, a young woman named "Sammie," who claimed to have lost a friend and then vanished herself. Tracie, along with co-guest host Melissa von Bleicken (*The Glee Project*), enlisted Nev and Max's help to find her.

The Reveal: The person behind "Sammie" was revealed to be Tracie's cousin, Melissa. Melissa had created the "Sammie" persona to connect with her famous cousin and to cope with her own personal issues, including a difficult relationship with her mother. The episode ended on a more hopeful, if complicated, note, with Tracie and Melissa trying to repair their family bond.

Where Are They Now?

• Tracie Thoms: Thoms' career continued to flourish, and she remains a well-known actress. Her involvement brought a unique perspective to the online dating scams explored by the show.
• Melissa (The Catfisher): Melissa later spoke about her experience, expressing that she felt misunderstood by the production at times, but was ultimately grateful for the opportunity to reconnect with her cousin.

4. Artis & Jess: The Catfish Avenger

Episode Details: This episode, "Artis & Jess," is remembered for its strange, almost scripted feel, which led many viewers to question its authenticity. Artis was in a relationship with "Jess," but the red flags were everywhere. When Nev and Max finally tracked down "Jess," they found a man named Justin, who claimed he was acting as a "Catfish Avenger." Justin's motive was to expose Artis for being a cheater, claiming Artis was using "Jess" to cheat on his real-life girlfriend, Jess. The situation was highly confrontational and confusing.

The Controversy: The "Catfish Avenger" concept and Justin's theatrical performance were so over-the-top that many fans and critics speculated that the entire episode was staged, with Justin potentially being a struggling actor hired to create drama.

Where Are They Now?

• Artis and Justin: The relationship between Artis and his real-life girlfriend, Jess, was heavily strained by the episode. Justin, the "Catfish Avenger," has largely faded from the public eye, though the episode remains a hot topic in online forums for its bizarre and suspicious nature.

5. Craig & Zoe: The Friendship That Fizzled

Episode Details: "Craig & Zoe" was the Season 3 premiere, setting the stage for the dramatic season to come. Craig was in a long-distance relationship with "Zoe," a woman he had never met. The investigation revealed that "Zoe" was actually Cassandra from New York. Cassandra was using "Zoe's" persona to escape her own life struggles and find a friend.

The Reveal: The confrontation was tearful, and Cassandra apologized, explaining that she was dealing with a difficult home life. Unlike many episodes, Craig chose to forgive Cassandra, and the two agreed to try and build a real-life friendship.

Where Are They Now?

• Craig and Cassandra: A follow-up special revealed that the friendship between Craig and Cassandra did not last. Craig eventually severed all contact with Cassandra, who had been trying to rebuild her life after the episode aired. This outcome highlights the difficulty of turning a relationship built on lies into a genuine connection.

The Enduring Legacy of Catfish Season 3

Season 3 of *Catfish* cemented the show's place in reality television history by showcasing the escalating complexity of online deception. The season provided a deep dive into the psychological reasons behind catfishing, ranging from revenge (Carmen/Antwane) and financial exploitation (Kidd Cole) to a desperate need for connection (Cassandra/Craig, Melissa/Tracie).

The season also featured some of the most memorable moments involving hosts Nev Schulman and Max Joseph, particularly Nev's dramatic phone toss in the Kidd Cole episode. The topical authority of the series continues to grow, as the lessons learned from these early episodes about online safety, digital footprints, and emotional manipulation are more relevant than ever in today's increasingly digital world. The legacy of *Catfish* Season 3 is a testament to the fact that sometimes, the most shocking truths are found right in your own neighborhood or, in the case of Kidd Cole, in the headlines years later.