5 Shocking Reasons Martha Stewart Says Ryan Reynolds Is 'Not So Funny' In Real Life—And His Witty Response

The world of Hollywood and lifestyle collided in a moment of pure, unscripted celebrity shade when Martha Stewart—the undisputed queen of domesticity—made a surprising declaration about her famous neighbor, Ryan Reynolds. As of December 2025, the buzz continues to swirl around a comment Stewart made during a recent public appearance that challenged the very foundation of Reynolds' public persona: his signature sense of humor. The media mogul’s take on the Deadpool star is a must-read for anyone curious about the reality behind the celebrity curtain, especially since the actor's own witty response has now gone viral.

The unexpected celebrity "feud" provides a fascinating look at the real-life dynamic between two massive entertainment and business entrepreneurs. While fans adore Reynolds' constant stream of jokes and self-deprecating humor, Stewart’s assessment paints a picture of a much more "serious" man. This article dives deep into the context of her comments, the surprising history between the two stars, and Reynolds’ perfectly crafted public retort.

The Shocking Biography: Martha Stewart and Ryan Reynolds

The relationship between a lifestyle icon and a Hollywood superstar is complex, especially when they share a postal code. Here is a brief look at the two titans at the center of this viral moment.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Martha Stewart Profile

• Full Name: Martha Helen Stewart (née Kostyra)
• Born: August 3, 1941 (Age 84 as of 2025)
• Occupation: Retail businesswoman, writer, television personality, former model, lifestyle mogul.
• Known For: Founding Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, Martha Stewart Living magazine, numerous cookbooks, television shows (Martha Stewart's Cooking School), and her recent resurgence as a cultural icon and entrepreneur.
• Key Entities: Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, Marquee Brands, Snoop Dogg, Kmart, ImClone stock trading case.
• Current Status: Continues to be a dominant force in the lifestyle and business world, known for her sharp wit and no-nonsense approach.

Ryan Reynolds Profile

• Full Name: Ryan Rodney Reynolds
• Born: October 23, 1976 (Age 49 as of 2025)
• Occupation: Actor, producer, entrepreneur.
• Known For: Films like Deadpool, The Proposal, Free Guy, and his witty, fast-paced comedic style both on-screen and on social media.
• Key Entities: Blake Lively (wife), Maximum Effort (production company and marketing agency), Aviation Gin, Mint Mobile, Wrexham AFC (co-owner), Deadpool 3.
• Current Status: One of Hollywood's highest-paid and most influential stars, balancing a successful acting career with an equally successful portfolio of business ventures.

The Five Key Takeaways from Martha Stewart’s Viral Comments

The drama unfolded during an appearance on Bilt Rewards’ ‘Rent Free’ game show, where Stewart was asked about her famous neighbors. While she spoke fondly of others, her comments on Ryan Reynolds were a surprising deviation, quickly becoming the most talked-about moment of the interview.

1. "He's Not So Funny" in Real Life

This was the core of Stewart’s statement. She explicitly told the host and the audience that the man known globally for his hilarious, quick-witted humor is surprisingly subdued off-camera. She didn't mince words, stating, "He's not so funny in real life." This immediately sent shockwaves across social media, as it directly contradicted the public image Reynolds has meticulously cultivated through his movies, interviews, and marketing campaigns for his various businesses.

2. The "Very Serious" Entrepreneur

Stewart elaborated on her assessment, describing Reynolds as "very serious." This suggests that the actor, who is also a successful entrepreneur with ventures like Aviation Gin and Maximum Effort, reserves his focus for business and family when not performing. The implication is that Reynolds’ real-life demeanor aligns more with a focused CEO than a class clown. It's a testament to the idea that the "Hollywood humor" seen on screen is a professional tool, not an everyday personality trait.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

3. A Compliment to His Acting Skills

While her initial comments sounded like a diss, Stewart quickly qualified them by acknowledging his professional talent. She stated, "He’s a good actor. He can act funny, but..." The caveat here is crucial: she wasn't criticizing his ability to be funny, but rather the frequency of his humor in their personal interactions. This distinction framed the comment as an observation on his personality versus his craft, rather than a full-blown critique of his career.

4. The Surprising Neighborly Connection

The context for the comments is their proximity. Stewart and Reynolds are indeed neighbors, both owning property in the elite communities of Westchester County, New York. This gives Stewart a unique, first-hand perspective that few others in the media possess. However, it's worth noting that a source close to the situation suggested that they have only met "once or twice at events," implying their neighborly interactions are brief and infrequent.

5. The Unspoken Wedding Planning Link

Adding another layer of complexity to their relationship is the fact that Martha Stewart was involved in planning Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively’s wedding. The couple's 2012 nuptials were featured exclusively in Martha Stewart Living magazine. This historical connection makes Stewart's recent comments even more intriguing, as it shows a professional and personal history that goes back over a decade, despite the current claim of limited interaction. This deeper link suggests a level of familiarity that makes her observation carry more weight.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Ryan Reynolds' Perfectly Witty Response and The Aftermath

It was only a matter of time before the master of the comedic retort, Ryan Reynolds, weighed in on the viral shade. His response, delivered with his characteristic blend of self-deprecation and quick wit, proved that his on-screen humor is not entirely absent in real life.

The "Unexpectedly Spry" Comeback

When asked about the viral comments, Reynolds took to his social media (X, formerly Twitter) to respond. He wrote, "I'd disagree with her. But I tried that once. The woman is unexpectedly spry." This single line was a masterclass in deflection. By calling Stewart "unexpectedly spry," he not only returned the playful jab but also highlighted her advanced age and surprising energy, turning the spotlight back onto her with a humorous compliment.

His response confirmed a few things. First, that his feelings were not hurt, as he handled the situation with a lighthearted touch. Second, it showcased the marketing genius of his company, Maximum Effort, which thrives on creating and capitalizing on viral moments. The entire exchange—from Stewart's initial comment to Reynolds' comeback—became a perfect piece of organic, high-profile celebrity content.

Topical Authority: The Business of Celebrity and Humor

This entire exchange is more than just celebrity gossip; it’s a fascinating case study in personal branding and the business of celebrity. Both Martha Stewart and Ryan Reynolds are powerful entrepreneurs who have expertly leveraged their public personas. Stewart’s brand is built on authority, perfection, and a certain candid bluntness, while Reynolds’ brand is centered on relatability, humor, and savvy business acumen.

The comment, whether intentional or not, served both their brands perfectly. Stewart maintained her image as a straight-shooter who tells it like it is, regardless of the celebrity status of the person involved. Reynolds, meanwhile, used the opportunity to demonstrate his signature humor, proving that even when challenged, his comedic timing is impeccable. This kind of organic, high-engagement content is the lifeblood of modern celebrity marketing, offering a glimpse into a world that is always "on."

Ultimately, the "feud" between the two neighbors is less about genuine animosity and more about a playful, high-stakes exchange between two business-minded personalities. While Stewart may find the man next door "very serious," the public—and now the media—have been thoroughly entertained by the unexpected, witty drama unfolding in their exclusive neighborhood.