The Full Timeline: Uncovering Evan Peters' Dating History From AHS Co-Stars To His Current Flame (Updated June 2024)

Evan Peters, the acclaimed actor known for his transformative roles in the American Horror Story anthology and his chilling portrayal in Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, has maintained a notoriously private personal life, especially concerning his romantic relationships. However, the intense curiosity surrounding the star's love life remains a constant buzz in Hollywood, particularly given his high-profile, on-again, off-again engagement and his brief fling with a music superstar.

As of today, December 13, 2025, the most recent and confirmed information points to a new, low-key relationship. We’re diving deep into the complete timeline of Evan Peters' dating history, exploring the confirmed partners, the major relationship milestones, and the latest news on who the celebrated actor is currently dating in 2024/2025.

Evan Peters: Complete Biography and Profile

Before exploring his romantic timeline, here is a quick look at the profile of the man behind the iconic, often dark, characters:

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

• Full Name: Evan Thomas Peters
• Born: January 20, 1987
• Birth Place: St. Louis, Missouri, United States
• Age: 38 (as of December 2025)
• Profession: Actor, Producer
• Notable Works: American Horror Story (Tate Langdon, Kit Walker, Kai Anderson, etc.), X-Men film series (Quicksilver/Peter Maximoff), Mare of Easttown, Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story.
• Awards: Primetime Emmy Award (Mare of Easttown), Golden Globe Award (Monster).
• Height: Approximately 5' 11" (180 cm)

The Early Years: Unconfirmed and Low-Profile Romances

Evan Peters' early career saw a few relationships that were kept largely out of the spotlight, reflecting his preference for privacy even before achieving global fame with *American Horror Story*.

1. Alexandra Breckenridge (2007–2010)

One of Peters' earliest reported relationships was with actress Alexandra Breckenridge. The two were together for a significant period, reportedly from 2007 to 2010. Breckenridge is a well-known actress herself, having appeared in shows like The Walking Dead and This Is Us. This relationship predates his major breakthrough role and was a quiet, stable pairing.

2. Alexia Quinn (2011–2012)

After his relationship with Breckenridge, Peters was linked to actress Alexia Quinn around 2011 to 2012. Like his previous romance, this was a low-key affair that received minimal media attention, further establishing Peters' tendency to keep his romantic life guarded.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

The Defining Relationship: Evan Peters and Emma Roberts

The relationship between Evan Peters and actress Emma Roberts became the most public and tumultuous chapter of his dating history, dominating headlines for nearly seven years.

The Tumultuous Seven-Year Timeline (2012–2019)

Peters and Roberts first met in 2012 on the set of the film Adult World. While the two didn't immediately begin dating, they soon became inseparable. Their chemistry was undeniable, and they quickly became one of Hollywood’s most talked-about young couples.

They became co-stars in the *American Horror Story* anthology series, appearing together in multiple seasons, including Coven, Freak Show, and Cult. Their on-screen appearances only amplified the public's fascination with their off-screen romance.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

The couple got engaged over the Christmas holiday in 2013, with Peters proposing with a custom pink and gold diamond ring.

The On-Again, Off-Again Drama

Despite the engagement, their relationship was notoriously rocky, characterized by several high-profile breakups and reconciliations. They first split in June 2015, only to reconcile shortly after. A second breakup occurred in May 2016, but they were seen together again later that year. This cycle of breaking up and getting back together defined their relationship for years.

The final split came in March 2019, when the engagement was officially called off for good, marking the end of their seven-year journey together.

The Pop Star Romance: Evan Peters and Halsey

Following his final breakup with Roberts, Peters moved on to a brief but highly publicized relationship with singer-songwriter Halsey.

A Short but Intense Fling (2019–2020)

Halsey had previously been vocal about her crush on the American Horror Story actor for years on social media. In a true Hollywood twist, her dream came true when the two were first linked romantically in September 2019.

Their relationship was confirmed when they made their red carpet debut at the *American Horror Story* 100th Episode Celebration in October 2019, dressing up in a memorable Sonny and Cher costume. The two were reportedly living together after only four months of dating, indicating the intensity of their connection.

However, the relationship was short-lived. By March 2020, rumors of a split began to circulate when Halsey deleted all photos of Peters from her Instagram, confirming the end of their romance shortly before the COVID-19 pandemic began.

Rumors and Current Status: Who is Evan Peters Dating Now? (Updated June 2024)

Since the split with Halsey, Evan Peters has returned to his private ways, keeping his dating life extremely guarded while focusing on his career, which included his Emmy-winning role in *Mare of Easttown* and his Golden Globe-winning role as Jeffrey Dahmer.

The Haley Lu Richardson Rumor (2023)

In early 2023, a rumor circulated that Peters had "hooked up" with actress Haley Lu Richardson after the SAG Awards in February. While the rumor gained some traction on celebrity gossip accounts, it was never publicly confirmed by either party and remained speculative, highlighting the intense scrutiny on his single status.

The Confirmed Current Girlfriend: Natalie Engel (2024)

The most recent and confirmed news about Evan Peters' love life is his relationship with Natalie Engel. Engel is a social media manager and is not a celebrity, which aligns with Peters' preference for a low-key partner.

Their relationship was publicly debuted on June 16, 2024, when they made a rare joint appearance at the Prada Menswear Spring/Summer 2025 fashion show in Milan, Italy. The couple was seen holding hands, confirming their status as an item. This public outing was a significant moment for the notoriously private actor, suggesting the seriousness of his connection with Natalie Engel.

Currently, Peters appears to be in a stable, private relationship with Natalie Engel, a welcome change from the high-drama romances of his past. Fans of the actor are hopeful that this new chapter will bring him the peace and privacy he seems to crave.