7 Reasons Why Old Mates Pub Is The Hottest Australian Clubhouse In New York City Right Now

As of December 2025, the search for an authentic "true blue" Australian experience in the heart of Manhattan ends at Old Mates Pub. This sprawling, three-story venue, tucked inside a historic 19th-century building in the Financial District, has quickly cemented its status as the city's premier Aussie clubhouse, offering a genuine taste of Down Under hospitality that New Yorkers and expats alike have been craving.

Since its highly-anticipated opening in early 2024, Old Mates has become more than just a bar; it's a cultural hub. It successfully filled the void left by beloved Australian institutions that closed during the COVID-19 pandemic, bringing back the essential mix of pints, parmis, and sports viewing that defines the quintessential Australian pub experience.

The True Blue Story: Why Old Mates is NYC's Hottest Aussie Clubhouse

Old Mates Pub is located at 170 John St., right in the historic heart of Downtown Manhattan's Financial District. The venue's immediate success is a testament to the dedication of its founders, who aimed to create a space that felt genuinely Australian without resorting to clichés. It’s an authentic Australian pub that doesn't try too hard to be one, making it instantly welcoming.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

The establishment's size is one of its most surprising features. It’s much bigger than many expect, boasting three distinct levels of distilled Australiana. This multi-level setup allows the pub to cater to different moods, whether you're after a quiet pint or a lively session watching the footy.

The concept took root during the challenging times of COVID-19, when many Australian bars in New York had to shut their doors. The arrival of Old Mates was a much-needed revival for the Aussie community in the Big Apple, providing a new home for expats and a unique cultural experience for locals.

7 Essential Reasons for Old Mates' Explosive Popularity

• 1. Filling a Cultural Void: The pub successfully replaced the beloved "The Australian," which closed in 2020, offering a genuine, no-fuss Aussie pub experience that had been missing in NYC.
• 2. Three Levels of Charm: Tucked into a 19th-century building, its sprawling, three-story layout provides ample space, atmosphere, and different vibes across its floors, making it feel like a massive, welcoming "clubhouse."
• 3. Celebrity Backing: The venture is backed by a mix of high-profile Australian A-listers, including the likes of Hugh Jackman, Andy Lee, and Hamish Blake, lending it significant star power and buzz.
• 4. Authentic Pub Grub: The menu is decidedly Australian, focusing on traditional, hearty pub meals executed perfectly, from meat pies to parmis.
• 5. No Bookings, No Worries: Embracing the laid-back Aussie attitude, the pub operates on a walk-in basis, making it accessible and true to the casual pub spirit.
• 6. The Sports Hub: It serves as a crucial venue for watching major Australian sports, including the NRL, the AFL, and for cheering on the Matildas, fostering a strong sense of community.
• 7. Prime Downtown Location: Its placement in the Financial District (FiDi) makes it a popular after-work destination for professionals and a draw for tourists exploring Downtown Manhattan.

A Culinary Trip Down Under: Must-Try Dishes and Drinks

The food menu at Old Mates Pub is a delicious homage to traditional Australian pub fare, designed to transport diners straight to a local watering hole back home. The focus is on quality, comfort, and authenticity, ensuring every dish is a "true blue" experience.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

The undisputed star of the show is the classic Meat Pie. Whether you opt for the traditional filling or the Spiced Veggie option, these hand-held pastries are a staple of the menu. Another essential pub favourite is the Sausage Roll, perfect for a quick bite with a pint.

For a heartier meal, the Parmigiana (or "parmi") is a must-try. This chicken schnitzel topped with tomato sauce and melted cheese is a pub classic. You can also find other staples like a proper Burger with the Lot, perfectly cooked Fish and Chips, and tender Lamb Chops.

Beyond the main courses, Old Mates offers upscale pub starters. The Oysters Kilpatrick, cooked with bacon, onion, and Worcestershire sauce, and the refined Kingfish Tartare with a Potato Cake show a modern twist on the pub food tradition. And, of course, no Australian meal is complete without a sweet finish. The menu features the iconic Pavlova for dessert, a light and fruity meringue-based treat.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

The Sports Hub and Celebrity Backing: More Than Just a Bar

Old Mates Pub is more than just a place to eat and drink; it’s a vital community focal point, particularly for the Australian diaspora in New York. The atmosphere is deliberately crafted to be welcoming, feeling exactly like a pub back home, which is a rare and valued commodity in the Big Apple.

The pub has become the unofficial home for watching Australian sports. It’s the place to be for major games, ensuring fans don't miss a beat of the action. Whether you are a dedicated follower of the National Rugby League (NRL), the Australian Football League (AFL), or want to cheer on the women's national soccer team, the Matildas, Old Mates provides the perfect, high-energy environment.

The pub's profile was significantly boosted by its high-wattage Australian investors. The involvement of personalities like actor Hugh Jackman and comedians Andy Lee and Hamish Blake generated massive buzz and media attention upon its opening. This celebrity endorsement has helped solidify its status as a must-visit destination in Downtown Manhattan.

Spearheaded by industry figures like Eddy Buckingham, the team behind Old Mates went to great lengths to ensure the authenticity of the offering. From the selection of beers to the specific pub aesthetic, every detail was considered to deliver a genuine slice of "Down Under" hospitality to the bustling New York City scene.

Final Verdict: Why You Should Say 'G'day' to Old Mates

In a city saturated with bars and restaurants, Old Mates Pub stands out by delivering a truly unique and authentic international experience. It is a vibrant, multi-level venue that successfully blends the laid-back charm of a classic Australian pub with the energy of a Downtown Manhattan hotspot. Whether you are looking for a comforting meal of meat pies and parmigiana, a cold pint, or a lively spot to watch the footy, Old Mates offers a warm welcome. It’s the perfect spot to feel a little bit of home in New York, proving that Aussie hospitality is a global winner.