The 7 Must-Try Crumbl Thanksgiving Pies Of 2025: Everything You Need To Know About This Year's Menu

Crumbl Cookies is once again redefining the holiday dessert table, but for Thanksgiving 2025, the brand is taking a monumental leap: they are officially selling actual, full-sized pies, not just pie-inspired cookies. This major menu departure has fans buzzing, as the company known for its weekly rotating cookie lineup pivots to offer a limited-time selection of seven distinct pie flavors perfect for your holiday feast. The Thanksgiving 2025 menu, which includes these highly anticipated pies, is set to be available for a very short window, making pre-ordering essential to secure your favorite holiday treats.

The move to offer traditional pies alongside their famous cookies solidifies Crumbl's position as a major player in the dessert industry, especially during the peak holiday season. The 2025 Thanksgiving lineup is designed to balance classic, nostalgic holiday flavors with the playful, innovative twists that Crumbl is famous for, ensuring there is a sweet treat for every guest at your dinner table.

The Complete 2025 Crumbl Thanksgiving Pie Lineup and Release Details

The excitement surrounding the 2025 Crumbl Thanksgiving menu is palpable because it features seven different flavored pies, marking a significant expansion of their holiday offerings. These pies will be available for a limited time, running from approximately Monday, November 24th, through Wednesday, November 26th, 2025, with the stores typically closed on Thanksgiving Day (November 27th) and opening late the following day. This tight window means planning your purchase is key to avoiding disappointment.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

7 Featured Crumbl Thanksgiving Pie Flavors

The menu balances traditional holiday flavors with some of Crumbl’s signature cookie-inspired creations. Here is the breakdown of the seven incredible flavors confirmed for the 2025 Thanksgiving week:

• Pumpkin Cream Pie: A holiday essential, this flavor likely features a smooth, spiced pumpkin filling topped with a generous layer of whipped cream or cream cheese frosting. It’s the perfect alternative to a classic pumpkin pie.
• French Silk Pie: A decadent, classic chocolate dessert. Expect a rich, airy chocolate mousse filling in a crisp crust, often topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
• Cookies & Cream Pie: A direct nod to one of Crumbl’s most popular cookie flavors. This pie typically features a crushed Oreo-style crust and a creamy, vanilla-based filling loaded with cookie pieces.
• Brookie Pie: The ultimate hybrid dessert, combining a brownie and a cookie. This pie is a layer of rich fudge brownie and chewy chocolate chip cookie dough baked into a single, irresistible slice.
• Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie: A beloved combination of sweet and salty. This pie likely features a rich chocolate crust, a creamy peanut butter filling, and a chocolate ganache drizzle.
• Biscoff Pie: Inspired by the famous Biscoff Cookie Butter, this flavor is a returning fan-favorite. It typically boasts a Biscoff cookie crust and a creamy, spiced cookie butter filling.
• A Seventh Rotating Flavor (Likely a Classic or Fan Favorite): While six are consistently mentioned, the menu is confirmed to include seven pies. Past holiday-adjacent pie flavors from Crumbl have included Apple Pie, Key Lime Pie, and Pecan Pie, making one of these a strong candidate to round out the list.

The availability of these pies is a limited-time event. Customers are strongly encouraged to utilize the Crumbl app for pre-ordering to ensure they can secure their desired Thanksgiving desserts before the holiday rush.

From Cookie to Pie: Why Crumbl Made the Big Change

For years, Crumbl's Thanksgiving offering was a lineup of cookies *inspired* by classic pies, such as the Pecan Pie cookie or the Apple Pie cookie. These were highly successful, often featuring a buttery cookie base topped with pie filling, streusel, or a creamy glaze. However, the decision to offer actual, traditional pies—both full-sized and mini pies—demonstrates a strategic move to capture a larger share of the holiday dessert market.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

This shift caters directly to customers who love the convenience and quality of Crumbl but still desire a classic, sliceable pie for their holiday gathering. By offering both traditional flavors like Pumpkin Cream and unique options like Brookie and French Silk, Crumbl positions itself as a one-stop-shop for both the classicist and the adventurous eater.

The Enduring Popularity of Pie-Inspired Cookies

Even with the introduction of full pies, Crumbl's history with pie-inspired cookies remains a core part of its brand identity. These cookies serve as a bridge between the classic dessert and the modern, oversized cookie format. Key past pie-themed cookies that may still appear in the weekly rotation or as mini-pie options include:

• Pecan Pie Cookie: Often praised for its sweet, buttery cookie base that avoids the dryness of a traditional pie crust, topped with a gooey pecan filling.
• Apple Pie Cookie: Featuring an oatmeal-style cookie base, a warm apple filling, and a sweet vanilla glaze or crumble topping.
• Key Lime Pie Cookie: A tart and refreshing option with a graham cracker base and a vibrant key lime filling.

These flavors are crucial LSI entities for the brand, connecting the Crumbl name to the broader dessert landscape and reinforcing their topical authority on holiday treats.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Navigating the 2025 Thanksgiving Pie Pre-Order and Pick-Up

Given the limited availability from November 24th to 26th, 2025, and the high demand for holiday desserts, strategic planning is vital for securing your Crumbl Thanksgiving Pies. Many stores will be closed on Thanksgiving Day, making the day before the holiday the absolute last chance for pick-up.

Tips for a Smooth Crumbl Thanksgiving Experience:

1. Use the App: The Crumbl Cookies app is the most reliable way to place a pre-order for the Thanksgiving pies. Pre-orders allow you to reserve your specific flavors and quantities well in advance.
2. Check Local Store Hours: While the general availability is November 24th–26th, individual store hours can vary, especially the day before Thanksgiving. Confirming your local store's hours is crucial for timely pick-up.
3. Consider Mini Pies: In addition to the full-sized pies, Crumbl often offers a selection of mini pies during the holiday season. These are perfect for smaller gatherings or for sampling a wider variety of flavors.
4. Plan for Early Pick-Up: The day before Thanksgiving is notoriously busy for all bakeries. Picking up your order earlier in the week (Monday or Tuesday) can save you from long lines and potential last-minute stock issues.

The 2025 Crumbl Thanksgiving menu is a game-changer, offering dessert lovers the best of both worlds: the convenience and brand quality of Crumbl, combined with the classic, comforting tradition of a holiday pie. Whether you opt for the familiar Pumpkin Cream or the adventurous Brookie Pie, these limited-time offerings are sure to be a sweet highlight of your holiday season.