The New Class Of Westerberg: Unmasking The Heathers Off-Broadway 2025 Cast And Future Plans

The buzz around Westerberg High is louder than ever, with the highly-anticipated New York revival of Heathers: The Musical dominating the theater scene. As of December 13, 2025, while a full-scale Broadway transfer remains a dream for many fans, the smash-hit production at New World Stages has been extended, cementing its status as the must-see theatrical event of the season. This article cuts through the rumors to bring you the definitive, most current cast list and all the crucial updates for the show that is "so very" right now.

The revival, which has seen its run extended well into early 2026, continues to captivate audiences with its dark humor and killer pop-rock score. The production has recently welcomed new talent into its principal roles, ensuring the energy and excitement of the cult classic remain fresh and electrifying for both new and returning fans. This is the definitive breakdown of the stars currently stepping into the iconic roles of Veronica Sawyer, J.D., and the titular Heathers.

The New Class of Westerberg High: Principal Cast List & Bios (2025–2026)

The latest casting news confirms a dynamic, talent-rich ensemble taking the stage at New World Stages. These performers are tasked with bringing the darkly comedic and complex characters from the 1988 film, written by Daniel Waters, to life for a new generation. The following is the current principal cast list for the extended Off-Broadway run:

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

• Veronica Sawyer: Kuhoo Verma

  A major casting update saw the talented Kuhoo Verma step into the lead role of Veronica Sawyer in late 2025, taking over from Lorna Courtney. Verma is an acclaimed actress known for her breakout role in the film Plan B, bringing a fresh, nuanced take to the character who navigates the brutal social hierarchy of Westerberg High. Her performance of "Dead Girl Walking" is eagerly awaited by fans.

• Jason “J.D.” Dean: Casey Likes

  Casey Likes continues his critically praised run as the enigmatic and dangerous Jason "J.D." Dean. Likes, a Broadway veteran known for his role in *Almost Famous*, perfectly embodies the complex blend of charm and darkness required for the character, particularly in numbers like "Freeze Your Brain."

• Heather Chandler: McKenzie Kurtz / Jodie Steele

  The queen bee, the mythical "Heather" who rules Westerberg, is primarily played by McKenzie Kurtz. Kurtz brings the necessary powerful vocals and intimidating presence to lead the Heathers in songs like "Candy Store." Notably, West End star Jodie Steele, who originated the role in the UK production, has also stepped in for limited engagements, creating a transatlantic buzz and offering fans a chance to see a different, yet equally iconic, portrayal of the character.

  • The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662
• Heather Duke: Jackera Davis / Kiara Michelle Lee

  Jackera Davis holds the principal role of Heather Duke, the second-in-command who is secretly plotting her ascent to the top. Davis captures the character's simmering ambition. Ensemble member Kiara Michelle Lee has also been announced to cover and perform the role during various periods, showcasing the depth of talent in the company.

• Heather McNamara: Elizabeth Teeter

  Elizabeth Teeter, a veteran of the New York stage, rounds out the trio as the sensitive and often overlooked Heather McNamara. Teeter’s portrayal beautifully captures the character's vulnerability, especially during her poignant solo, "Lifeboat."

• Ms. Fleming / Veronica's Mom: Kerry Butler

  Tony Award nominee Kerry Butler, a beloved figure in the Broadway community with credits like *Hairspray* and *Mean Girls*, continues to anchor the adult roles. Her dual performance as the well-meaning but misguided guidance counselor, Ms. Fleming, and Veronica’s Mom adds significant star power and gravitas to the production.

  • The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

From Off-Broadway Hit to Global Phenomenon: The Show's Journey

The constant confusion about the "Heathers Broadway 2025 cast" stems from the show's overwhelming international success and its long-running status in New York. While the current production is a massive hit, it is officially an Off-Broadway revival at New World Stages, not a traditional Broadway show.

The musical, with music, lyrics, and book by Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy, first premiered in Los Angeles in 2013 before its original Off-Broadway run in 2014.

Its journey to a global cult phenomenon was cemented by its wildly popular and long-running West End production in London. The UK success, coupled with the show's immense popularity on social media platforms like TikTok, fueled the demand for a permanent New York presence.

The current New World Stages revival, which opened in 2025, serves as a testament to this enduring popularity. The show's producers have strategically chosen the Off-Broadway venue, known for nurturing successful musicals, to keep the momentum high. The continuous extensions, now through January 25, 2026, indicate that a future Broadway transfer is not out of the question, but for now, New World Stages is where the magic (and mayhem) happens.

Key Entities and The Creative Team Behind the Cult Classic

The enduring success of Heathers: The Musical is a credit to the talented individuals who adapted the dark source material for the stage. Understanding these key entities provides crucial topical authority for any fan of the show:

• Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy: The creative powerhouse behind the musical's infectious score and sharp book. O'Keefe is also known for his work on *Legally Blonde: The Musical*, while Murphy is a seasoned writer and producer. Their collaboration perfectly captures the satirical, yet emotionally resonant, tone of the original film.
• Andy Fickman: The director of the current revival, Fickman has a long history with the show, having directed the original Los Angeles and New York productions. His consistent vision has helped maintain the show's unique aesthetic and energy.
• The 1988 Film: Directed by Michael Lehmann and starring Winona Ryder as Veronica Sawyer and Christian Slater as J.D., the source film remains a touchstone of dark comedy. The musical pays homage to the film's iconic lines and themes of teen angst, social pressure, and murder.
• New World Stages: The current home of the revival, this Off-Broadway complex has hosted numerous successful and long-running shows, including *Avenue Q* and *Jersey Boys*. It is a key venue in the New York theater landscape.

The show’s enduring themes of bullying, mental health, and the toxic nature of high school cliques continue to resonate deeply with modern audiences, making the musical a powerful piece of social commentary disguised as a catchy pop-rock score. The continuous casting updates, such as the introduction of Kuhoo Verma, keep the production vibrant and relevant, ensuring that the legacy of Westerberg High remains a powerful force in New York theater.

Whether you're a "Corn Nuts" devotee or a newcomer to the world of Veronica and J.D., the current New York revival offers a fresh opportunity to experience this phenomenon. With the cast locked in for an extended run through January 2026, now is the perfect time to grab your scrunchie and join the most popular, and most dangerous, clique in town.