The Deadly Truth: Why Light As A Feather Season 3 Was Cancelled And What Would Have Happened Next

The search for Light as a Feather Season 3 has continued for years, but the definitive answer is a disappointment for fans of the dark, supernatural thriller. As of late 2025, the Hulu original series was officially cancelled after its second season, leaving the deadly game of "Light as a Feather, Stiff as a Board" forever unresolved. The final episode, which aired back in October 2019, ended on a major cliffhanger, ensuring the show remains a topic of frustrated discussion among its dedicated audience.

The series, based on the popular book trilogy by Zoe Aarsen, captivated viewers with its blend of high school drama, body horror, and a mysterious, life-threatening curse. However, despite its strong premise and dedicated following, the show ultimately did not receive the green light for a third season, cutting short the story of McKenna Brady and the curse that plagued her friends.

The Definitive Status: Why Hulu Never Renewed Light as a Feather

The unfortunate reality is that Light as a Feather was cancelled by Hulu after two seasons, with the final installment of Season 2 (often referred to as Season 2B) debuting on October 4, 2019. This decision left the story hanging, frustrating viewers who were invested in the fates of McKenna, Violet, and the rest of the cursed group.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

While Hulu never released an official, detailed statement on the cancellation, the decision is widely speculated to be a result of a few key factors common in the streaming landscape: declining viewership and a perceived dip in critical reception for the second season.

• Low Viewership vs. Cost: Like many streaming services, Hulu's decision to renew a series often comes down to a cost-benefit analysis. If the viewership for Season 2 did not justify the production cost for a third season, cancellation becomes inevitable.
• Critical Reception: Some sources suggest that while Season 1 was highly praised, Season 2 "failed to rise to the occasion," which may have contributed to the network's decision not to move forward.
• Unresolved Book Trilogy: The show was based on the Light as a Feather trilogy by author Zoe Aarsen. The series was cancelled before it could adapt the third and final book, Silent as the Grave, which would have concluded McKenna's mission to save her friends.

The lack of a Season 3 means the television adaptation never reached the intended conclusion of the source material, a common tragedy for young adult (YA) adaptations.

The Unresolved Cliffhangers: What a Hypothetical Season 3 Plot Would Cover

The Season 2 finale, titled "...Brave as a Lion," left the central mystery of the curse wide open, setting the stage for an explosive third season that will now never be made. The final moments of the season blurred the lines between the cursed and the uncursed, suggesting the deadly game was far from over.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Based on the end of Season 2 and the source material (Zoe Aarsen’s third book), a hypothetical Light as a Feather Season 3 would have likely focused on these major plot threads:

The New Curse Cycle and Violet’s Escape

The season concluded with the shocking reveal that another game of "Light as a Feather, Stiff as a Board" was played, effectively restarting the deadly cycle. This new game would have introduced a fresh batch of victims and potentially a new "seer" or leader of the curse. Furthermore, Violet Simmons (Haley Ramm), who was the original antagonist and victim of the curse, was seen moving to a new school. This suggested that even her escape was temporary, and the curse may have followed her or that she would have been drawn back into the chaos, perhaps as an unwilling ally or a new enemy to McKenna.

McKenna and Jenny's Possession Battle

A major reveal in Season 2 was the possession of McKenna Brady (Liana Liberato) by the spirit of her dead sister, Jenny. This storyline was a central focus, as Jenny was using McKenna's body to live, but also eventually tried to protect her sister from the curse. Season 3 would have had to resolve this internal conflict: Would McKenna finally exorcise Jenny, or would they reach a permanent, uneasy truce? The final book, Silent as the Grave, heavily features McKenna’s mission to break the curse once and for all, implying a final, desperate confrontation with the supernatural entity behind the game.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

The Fate of Alex and Trey

The secondary characters, Alex Portnoy (Brianne Tju) and Trey Emory (Jordan Rodrigues), were integral to the group's survival. Season 2 left them in precarious positions, still grappling with the trauma and lingering effects of the curse. A third season would have seen them either fully commit to helping McKenna break the curse's grip on their lives or succumb to the paranoia and fear that the game instilled. The supernatural thriller elements would have escalated as the group searched for the definitive way to end the dark magic.

Where Are the Cast Members Now? Their Latest Projects (2025 Update)

Despite the show’s cancellation, the talented young cast has gone on to star in numerous high-profile film and television projects. This section provides a look at the main cast's careers as of 2025, proving they have moved on from the chilling curse of the series.

Liana Liberato (McKenna Brady)

The series lead has maintained a very active career in film and streaming. After Light as a Feather, Liana Liberato starred in the horror films Scream VI and Totally Killer, cementing her status in the horror/thriller genre. Most notably, she has received praise for her role as Tory Thompson in the Peacock comedy-thriller series Based on a True Story, which continued into 2024.

Haley Ramm (Violet Simmons)

Haley Ramm, who played the complex and often villainous Violet Simmons, has continued her work in television. While she has appeared in various projects like The Good Doctor, her career has seen her take on diverse roles, building on her earlier work in shows like Chasing Life and The Originals.

Brianne Tju (Alex Portnoy)

Brianne Tju has become a recognizable face in young adult horror and thrillers. Following her role as Alex, she starred in the Amazon Prime Video series I Know What You Did Last Summer. In 2024, she was seen in the Netflix film adaptation of the dystopian YA novel, Uglies, alongside Joey King.

Jordan Rodrigues (Trey Emory)

Jordan Rodrigues, who played McKenna's love interest Trey, has also found success in major streaming projects. He starred as Ethan in the Disney+ series National Treasure: Edge of History, a continuation of the popular film franchise. He is also listed in the cast for the upcoming 2025 film, We're All Gonna Die.

The Legacy of Light as a Feather and Revival Hopes

While the cancellation of Light as a Feather Season 3 is a closed chapter, the series has left a significant legacy as one of Hulu's early attempts at a teen supernatural thriller. It successfully tapped into the market for dark, high-stakes young adult content, paving the way for similar shows on various streaming platforms.

The show’s topical authority is rooted in its exploration of themes like guilt, trauma, and the dark side of teenage friendships, all filtered through a chilling supernatural lens. The use of the classic slumber party game "Light as a Feather, Stiff as a Board" provided a unique, recognizable hook that resonated with its target demographic.

Will a Season 3 Ever Happen?

The chances of a direct Season 3 revival are slim, given the time elapsed since the 2019 finale and the cast's busy schedules. However, in the age of streaming reboots and limited series revivals, a few possibilities remain:

• A Limited Series Conclusion: Hulu could commission a one-off "movie event" or a short, four-episode limited series to finally adapt Zoe Aarsen's third book, Silent as the Grave, providing closure for the fans.
• A Soft Reboot: A new series set in the same universe, focusing on a new group of teens who discover the curse, could be a way to keep the franchise alive without needing to reassemble the original main cast.
• Acquisition by Another Streamer: Though unlikely, a platform with a strong focus on YA content, such as Netflix or Max, could theoretically acquire the rights for a continuation, though this is a rare occurrence for a cancelled series.

For now, fans must find closure in the original Zoe Aarsen book trilogy and celebrate the two seasons of the chilling supernatural thriller that Hulu did provide.