4 Tragic Love After Lockup Deaths: The Full List Of Cast Members Who Passed Away And Their Causes

The journey to love after incarceration is often fraught with challenges, but for some cast members of WE tv's *Love After Lockup* and its spin-offs, the tragic end came far too soon. As of December 2025, the reality franchise has seen four former participants pass away, with the circumstances surrounding their deaths frequently linked to the very struggles that brought them national attention: addiction, life after prison, and the difficulty of maintaining sobriety and stability on the outside. This article provides the most current and comprehensive details on the lives and confirmed causes of death for the cast members we have lost. The show, which chronicles the complicated relationships between former inmates and their partners, has unfortunately become a spotlight for the harsh realities of post-prison life. The most recent confirmed death occurred in late 2023, and fans continue to mourn the loss of these individuals whose personal battles were publicly documented.

The Deceased Love After Lockup Cast Members: A Complete Biography List

The following list details the four confirmed individuals from the *Love After Lockup* franchise who have passed away, including their biographical information from the show and the confirmed details of their tragic deaths.

1. Tracie Wagaman (Season 2)

• Role on Show: Inmate/Prisoner, famously known as "Goddess" to her partner.
• Partner: Clint Brady.
• Season: Season 2 of *Love After Lockup*.
• Date of Death: July 1, 2021.
• Age at Death: 41.
• Cause of Death: Accidental methamphetamine toxicity (overdose).
• Additional Details: Tracie's death occurred tragically just one week after she had given birth to her second child. She had a long and public battle with substance abuse, which was a central theme of her storyline with Clint Brady.

2. Alla Subbotina (Season 1)

• Role on Show: Inmate/Prisoner.
• Partner: James Cristi.
• Season: Season 1 of *Love After Lockup*.
• Date of Death: August 7, 2021.
• Age at Death: 31.
• Cause of Death: Heroin overdose.
• Additional Details: Alla's death, which occurred just over a month after Tracie Wagaman's passing, was a major shock to the fanbase. She had been open about her struggles with addiction and her attempts to maintain sobriety after her release, a battle she fought "courageously for her entire adult life."

3. Scott Michael Davey (Season 2)

• Role on Show: Penpal/Partner.
• Partner: Lizzie Kommes.
• Season: Season 2 of *Love After Lockup*.
• Date of Death: November 12, 2021.
• Age at Death: 54.
• Cause of Death: Exacerbated chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and bronchopneumonia.
• Additional Details: Scott's relationship with Lizzie was one of the most memorable of Season 2. His death came just a few months after the passings of Tracie and Alla. While initial reports were unclear, a subsequent coroner's court finding provided the official cause, linking his death to long-term health issues.

4. Lacitrus Asonta Gholston (Asonta Gholston) (Love During Lockup)

• Role on Show: Inmate/Prisoner.
• Partner: Gabby Nieves.
• Season: Season 3 of *Love During Lockup* (a spin-off of *Love After Lockup*).
• Date of Death: Early September 2023 (Obituary dated September 1, 2023).
• Age at Death: Not widely reported, but was a young adult.
• Cause of Death: Car accident following a police chase.
• Additional Details: Asonta's passing is the most recent tragedy in the franchise. Reports indicated he was involved in a high-speed car chase with police, which resulted in a fatal accident where his vehicle reportedly hit another car carrying four teenagers. His storyline with Gabby was featured on the spin-off *Love During Lockup*.

The Dark Reality: Addiction and Public Scrutiny

The deaths of Tracie Wagaman and Alla Subbotina in particular cast a harsh light on the dangers of addiction and the intense difficulty of reintegrating into society after a period of incarceration. Both women had significant, well-documented struggles with substance abuse, which ultimately proved fatal. For reality television stars, the pressure of public scrutiny only exacerbates these issues. The constant attention from viewers and the media can make maintaining sobriety an almost impossible task, especially when coupled with the underlying trauma and systemic issues that led to their incarceration in the first place. The show's premise, which centers on high-stakes, emotional relationships, often places these vulnerable individuals under a microscope during their most fragile moments. The reality of life after prison is rarely the fairy tale that some cast members hope for. With limited resources, a criminal record, and often a lack of a stable support system, the return to drug use or involvement in criminal activity—as seen in the tragic circumstances of Asonta Gholston's death—becomes a devastatingly common outcome. These tragic endings serve as a stark reminder of the underlying topical authority of the show: it’s not just about romance, but about the systemic failures and personal battles faced by those leaving the penal system.

Fan Reactions and the Show's Legacy of Loss

Following each death, the *Love After Lockup* fanbase has been vocal, expressing deep sadness and engaging in intense discussions about the ethics of reality television that features individuals battling addiction and trauma. The community often shares heartfelt condolences, remembering the cast members for the moments of humor, hope, and vulnerability they shared on screen. The passing of Scott Davey, who was not an inmate but the partner of one, highlighted that the emotional and physical toll of the "lockup" lifestyle affects everyone involved. His death from health complications unrelated to overdose, though still tragic, broadened the scope of loss felt by the show's viewers. The show, while entertaining, documents the harsh realities of the criminal justice system's revolving door. The struggles of cast members like Tracie, Alla, and Asonta with relapse, legal trouble, and ultimately, premature death, underscore a somber legacy for the popular reality franchise. Their stories, though ending tragically, continue to serve as a cautionary tale about the challenges of post-release life and the pervasive nature of addiction. The franchise, including *Love After Lockup* and *Love During Lockup*, continues to air new seasons, but the memory of these lost cast members remains a poignant part of its history.