The AHS Roanoke Cast: Where Are The Stars Of Season 6 Now (2025 Update)

American Horror Story: Roanoke, Season 6 of the groundbreaking anthology series, remains one of the most divisive and unique entries in the *AHS* canon, shocking fans with its documentary-style format and mid-season twist. As of December 2025, the core cast members—who brilliantly played double and sometimes triple roles as the 'real' people, the re-enactment actors, and themselves—have gone on to secure major, high-profile projects, from Broadway wins to reuniting with Ryan Murphy on new FX series.

The season’s central mystery, inspired by the true-life disappearance of the Roanoke Colony in the 16th century, was only surpassed by the sheer talent of its ensemble. From the terrifying Butcher to the resilient Lee Harris, here is the ultimate, up-to-date look at the main cast of *AHS: Roanoke* and the jaw-dropping projects they are working on right now.

The Main Cast of American Horror Story: Roanoke (Season 6)

The unique premise of *Roanoke* required its actors to portray three versions of their characters: the 'real-life' survivors in the documentary *My Roanoke Nightmare*, the actors who played them in the re-enactment, and their chaotic return in the reality show *Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell*. This list details the primary actors and their most significant recent work.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

• Sarah Paulson: Played Audrey Tindall (Re-enactment Actress), Shelby Miller (Real Survivor, voice-over), and briefly reprised her *Asylum* role as Lana Winters.
• Evan Peters: Played Rory Monahan (Re-enactment Actor) and Edward Philipe Mott (Original Owner/Ghost).
• Kathy Bates: Played Agnes Mary Winstead (Re-enactment Actress) and Thomasin White, aka The Butcher (Colony Leader/Ghost).
• Cuba Gooding Jr.: Played Dominic Banks (Re-enactment Actor) and Matt Miller (Real Survivor, voice-over).
• Adina Porter: Played Lee Harris (Real Survivor) and Flora Harris (Re-enactment Actress).
• Lily Rabe: Played Shelby Miller (Real Survivor).
• André Holland: Played Matt Miller (Real Survivor).
• Denis O'Hare: Played William Van Henderson (Re-enactment Actor) and Dr. Elias Cunningham (Paranormal Investigator).

The AHS Alums: Where Are They Now? (2025 Career Update)

The powerhouse ensemble from *Roanoke* has continued to dominate film and television, with several actors earning major awards and starring in highly anticipated projects scheduled for 2025 and beyond.

Sarah Paulson: From Audrey Tindall to Tony Award Winner

Sarah Paulson’s turn as the frantic, British re-enactment actress Audrey Tindall—who famously married Rory Monahan—was a fan favorite, showcasing her comedic timing before the inevitable horror set in. Her character's terror in the *Return to Roanoke* reality show was palpable, solidifying her status as an *AHS* icon.

Current Status: Paulson is enjoying a massive career peak. In 2024, she won the prestigious Tony Award for Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play for her critically acclaimed work in the Broadway production *Appropriate*. She also received a 2024 Emmy nomination for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Drama Series for her role in the Amazon Prime Video spy series *Mr. & Mrs. Smith*. Fans can look forward to her upcoming movie, the thriller *Hold Your Breath* (2024).

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Evan Peters: Reuniting with Ryan Murphy and Sci-Fi Blockbusters

Evan Peters played two memorable roles: the ill-fated re-enactment actor Rory Monahan, who was the first to be killed by the vengeful Butcher ghost, and the eccentric, inbred ancestor Edward Philipe Mott.

Current Status: Following his Emmy-winning role in *Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story*, Peters is once again collaborating with creator Ryan Murphy. He is set to star in the new FX series The Beauty, a raunchy crime story that marks a significant reunion for the pair. Furthermore, Peters is slated for a major blockbuster role, starring in the highly anticipated Disney sci-fi film Tron: Ares, scheduled for release in 2025.

Kathy Bates: From The Butcher to Legal Drama Lead

Kathy Bates delivered a terrifying performance as the dual-role antagonist: the colonial ghost Thomasin White (The Butcher) and the unhinged, Oscar-nominated actress Agnes Mary Winstead, who became obsessed with her role as The Butcher. Her performance provided much of the season's core horror.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

Current Status: Bates has transitioned to a leading role in network television. She stars as the title character in the new CBS legal drama series Matlock (2024– ), playing a 75-year-old lawyer who returns to her career after decades away. She also has several films slated for 2024, including the comedies *A Family Affair* and *Summer Camp*.

Adina Porter: The Survivor’s Journey Continues

Adina Porter’s portrayal of the 'real' survivor Lee Harris was arguably the emotional core of the season, a woman accused of murder who returned to the cursed farmhouse. Her raw, Emmy-nominated performance was a standout, especially as she was initially listed as a guest star despite her pivotal role.

Current Status: Porter remains a fixture in prestige television. While she has been active on recent shows like *The Changeling* and *Paper Girls*, she was seen attending the Hulu's *Only Murders In The Building* Season 4 Premiere in August 2024. She is also part of the star-studded cast for the upcoming Apple TV+ limited series The Savant, which is expected to premiere in 2025.

Cuba Gooding Jr.: From Matt Miller to The Firing Squad

Cuba Gooding Jr. played the re-enactment actor Dominic Banks and provided the voice-over for the 'real' survivor Matt Miller. His character was instrumental in the season's twist, as Dominic was the only person to return to the house solely for fame and money, not survival.

Current Status: Gooding Jr. continues his film career. He is starring in the upcoming movie The Firing Squad, a faith-based action-thriller, which was released in August 2024.

The Deepest Secrets and LSI Entities of Roanoke

The success of *Roanoke* lies in its dense mythology and deliberate confusion between the documentary and reality show formats. The season is a treasure trove of topical authority and hidden entities.

The Show-Within-A-Show Twist

The biggest, most talked-about secret of Season 6 was the monumental shift in Episode 6. The first five episodes were presented as a standard paranormal documentary called My Roanoke Nightmare, featuring the 'real' survivors (Lee, Matt, Shelby) and the 're-enactment' actors (Audrey, Rory, Agnes). The twist was the introduction of the reality show Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell, orchestrated by producer Sidney James (played by Cheyenne Jackson). This new show brought the actors and the real survivors back to the cursed farmhouse during the Blood Moon, where the ghosts' power is strongest, turning the production into a hidden-camera slaughterhouse.

The Terrifying Entities

The season is packed with memorable, terrifying entities that are key to its topical authority:

• The Butcher (Thomasin White): The vicious, colonial leader of the Lost Colony of Roanoke, whose spirit demands a blood sacrifice every Blood Moon. The re-enactment version was played by the unhinged Agnes Mary Winstead.
• The Polk Family: A cannibalistic, inbred family living in the woods who torture and murder victims. The actor who played the family's son, Jether Polk (Finn Wittrock), confirmed that the real Piggy Man killer was inspired by the Butcher's original Piggy Man.
• The Piggy Man: A recurring, terrifying figure wearing a pig's head. The original Piggy Man was a traitor punished by The Butcher. A later, modern killer was inspired by this entity, connecting the real-life and supernatural horrors.
• Scathach: The ancient, powerful, feral witch (played by Lady Gaga) who grants The Butcher her power and is implied to be the original Supreme.
• Edward Philipe Mott: The original, eccentric builder of the farmhouse, whose ghost is one of the many trapped on the grounds. He is an ancestor of the infamous Mott family from *AHS: Freak Show*.

By constantly blurring the lines between the documented and the real, *American Horror Story: Roanoke* utilized its brilliant cast to deliver a self-aware, meta-horror experience that continues to inspire curiosity years later. The cast's current success in 2025 proves that their talent was anything but a nightmare.