Are Cara Maria And Paulie Still Together? The 5 Most Shocking Updates On The Challenge’s Most Tumultuous Couple In 2025

The question of whether Cara Maria Sorbello and Paulie Calafiore are still together is one of the most enduring mysteries in reality television, and as of December 12, 2025, the answer remains as complicated as their love story. Despite persistent rumors of a split that frequently surface on social media, the couple has consistently affirmed that their relationship is ongoing, celebrating major milestones and even discussing their future plans. Their partnership, forged on the cutthroat battlegrounds of MTV's The Challenge, has proven to be far more resilient—or perhaps just more dramatic—than most fans initially predicted.

This deep dive will cut through the noise to provide the most current information on the reality TV power couple, exploring their recent five-year anniversary, the truth behind the constant breakup rumors, and their highly-anticipated return to the franchise that brought them together. Their journey is a masterclass in reality TV relationship dynamics: a blend of high-stakes competition, public scrutiny, and a unique, often private, bond.

Cara Maria Sorbello and Paulie Calafiore: The Definitive Biography

Cara Maria Sorbello and Paulie Calafiore are two of the most recognizable and polarizing figures from the world of reality competition shows. Their individual careers laid the groundwork for their explosive partnership.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

Cara Maria Sorbello: Biography & Profile

• Full Name: Cara Maria Sorbello
• Born: May 12, 1986, in Methuen, Massachusetts
• Age (as of 2025): 39
• Debut Show: The Challenge: Fresh Meat II (2010)
• Championship Wins: Battle of the Bloodlines, Champs vs. Pros, and Vendettas
• Signature Persona: A fierce, determined competitor known for her dramatic evolution from underdog to champion.
• Relationship History on The Challenge: Notable relationships with Abram Boise and Kyle Christie before Paulie.

Paulie Calafiore: Biography & Profile

• Full Name: Paulie Calafiore
• Born: November 13, 1988, in Howell, New Jersey
• Age (as of 2025): 37
• Debut Show: Big Brother 18 (2016)
• Other Shows: Ex on the Beach (Season 1)
• Key Challenge Seasons: Final Reckoning, War of the Worlds, War of the Worlds 2, and The Challenge: USA
• Signature Persona: A strategic, often villainous, competitor known for his athleticism and controversial relationships.
• Relationship History: Involved with Danielle Maltby and others before Cara Maria.

The Current Status: Are Cara Maria and Paulie Calafiore Still a Couple in 2025?

The short answer, based on the most recent public statements and social media activity, is Yes, Cara Maria Sorbello and Paulie Calafiore are still together.

Their relationship, which began on The Challenge: Final Reckoning in 2018, has been a rollercoaster of public drama, private reconciliation, and continuous speculation. Despite the constant cycle of rumors, the couple has been vocal about their commitment to each other, even if their definition of a "normal" relationship differs greatly from the public's expectation.

One of the most concrete pieces of evidence confirming their status came from their recent celebration of a significant milestone. Paulie and Cara Maria marked their five-year anniversary, a testament to the longevity of their partnership despite the intense media scrutiny.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

This commitment extends to their future. In recent interviews, the couple has openly discussed their desire to have children together, signaling a long-term plan that goes far beyond their time on reality television.

The Truth Behind the Tumultuous Timeline and 'Split' Rumors

No couple in The Challenge history has faced more frequent or intense breakup rumors than Cara Maria and Paulie. This is largely due to their on-screen drama, their public social media breaks, and the candid nature of their relationship dynamic.

The 'Unfollow' Drama and Paulie's Response

In late 2024, rumors of a definitive split flared up after fans noticed Cara Maria had unfollowed Paulie on Instagram and removed his photos from her profile. This social media scrubbing is often the first sign of a celebrity breakup, leading the public to assume the worst.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

However, Paulie Calafiore was quick to address the speculation, stating that "Anything on social media wasn't real" and implying that the public drama does not reflect the reality of their private life. This pattern of public drama followed by a private affirmation of their bond has become a hallmark of their relationship.

The 'Open Relationship' Entity

A key element that complicates the public's understanding of their status is the discussion around their relationship's structure. At various points, the couple has alluded to having an "open relationship," which provides a different context for any perceived distance or social media drama. While the specifics are private, this non-traditional arrangement means the usual signs of a breakup (like an unfollow) may not carry the same weight as they would for a conventional couple.

Their relationship, therefore, is not so much "on-again, off-again" as it is a deeply personal partnership that they choose to manage outside of the conventional, public-facing norms of celebrity couples.

What's Next: The Challenge Return and Future Plans

The couple's current status is also tied to their professional lives, particularly their involvement with The Challenge franchise.

The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras

After a significant hiatus, both Cara Maria and Paulie have made highly-anticipated returns to the show. Cara Maria's return, in particular, was met with excitement from fans, with some reports noting that she is "enjoying being the face of the Challenge again." Paulie's recent appearances, including his participation in The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras, have put their relationship back in the spotlight and confirmed their joint involvement in the reality TV world.

Their presence on the show, often together or in the same season, serves as a continuous public confirmation of their bond, as they navigate the strategic and personal challenges of the game as a united front, even if they are not always paired together.

Topical Authority Entities & LSI Keywords:

• MTV
• Reality TV
• The Challenge
• Big Brother
• Ex on the Beach
• Final Reckoning
• War of the Worlds
• Vendettas
• Battle of the Bloodlines
• Total Madness
• The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras
• Kyle Christie
• Abram Boise
• Danielle Maltby
• Challenge Mania
• Golden Derby
• Split Rumors
• Open Relationship
• Five-Year Anniversary
• Social Media Drama
• Competitive Nature
• Massachusetts
• New Jersey
• Couples on The Challenge
• Controversial Cast Members
• Long-Distance Relationship (when filming)