The Ultimate Recap: Who Won Love Island All Stars Season 2 And The 5 Biggest Finale Shocks

The highly anticipated second series of *Love Island: All Stars* delivered on its promise of explosive drama, surprising connections, and a truly unforgettable finale. Airing on ITV2 in the UK and streaming on Peacock in the US, this season brought back some of the most iconic and controversial Islanders from the show’s decade-long history, all vying for a second chance at love and the £50,000 prize. As of today, December 12, 2025, the results are in, and the winning couple has been crowned, cementing their place as the ultimate All-Stars.

The season, which premiered on January 13, 2025, and concluded with a dramatic final on February 17, 2025, in the South African villa, was a whirlwind of *recouplings*, *dumpings*, and heated confrontations. This comprehensive recap breaks down the full episode guide, the definitive final ranking, and the incredible cast that made it all happen.

The Iconic Love Island All Stars Season 2 Cast & Biography

The premise of *Love Island: All Stars* is simple: bring back fan-favorite Islanders who either narrowly missed out on love or caused the most memorable drama. Season 2 did not disappoint, featuring a mix of OGs and recent stars. The show was once again hosted by the brilliant Maya Jama, who guided the Islanders through their journey. Here is a look at the key Islanders who entered the villa, including the initial line-up and significant bombshells:

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

• Gabby Allen (Season 3): A true *Love Island* veteran known for her bubbly personality and strong connections. She entered on Day 1.
• Casey O’Gorman (Season 9): Known for his charming yet tumultuous time in the villa, Casey was a late entry who quickly made a splash.
• Luca Bish (Season 8): Famous for his intense relationship with Gemma Owen in his original season, Luca returned looking for a fresh start.
• Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu (Season 8 Winner): The iconic winner of her original season, Ekin-Su’s return was the biggest bombshell, promising high-stakes drama.
• Curtis Pritchard (Season 5): The ballroom dancer returned to the villa, known for his polite demeanor and surprising recoupling choices.
• Olivia Hawkins (Season 9): A controversial figure from her season, Olivia was involved in several major confrontations and returned as a central source of drama.
• Marcel Somerville (Season 3): An original member of the Blazin' Squad, Marcel was one of the most beloved Islanders, returning to find a lasting connection.
• Grace Jackson (Season 5): Known for her brief but memorable time as a bombshell, Grace returned with a clear focus on finding her match.
• Scott Thomas (Season 2): An OG Islander from the show’s early days, Scott’s return was a nod to the show's history.
• India Reynolds (Season 5): A former finalist, India returned as a stunning bombshell, ready to turn heads and test existing couples.

Other notable Islanders who entered the South Africa villa included Catherine Agbaje (Season 10), Elom Ahlijah-Wilson (Season 10), and Tina Stinnes (Season 2), ensuring a dynamic mix of personalities and former flames.

The Explosive Season 2 Final: Winners and Full Final Ranking

After 36 days of intense coupling, emotional farewells, and countless dramatic moments, the second season of *Love Island: All Stars* concluded with a live final on February 17, 2025. Host Maya Jama announced the results, which were based entirely on the public vote. The final was a close call, but ultimately, one couple stood above the rest, proving that a second chance at love can pay off.

The winning couple, securing the £50,000 prize, was Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

Here is the definitive final ranking of the couples in *Love Island: All Stars* Season 2:

1. Winners: Gabby Allen & Casey O'Gorman (Season 3 & Season 9)
2. Second Place: Grace Jackson & Luca Bish (Season 5 & Season 8)
3. Third Place: Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu & Curtis Pritchard (Season 8 & Season 5)
4. Fourth Place: Catherine Agbaje & Elom Ahlijah-Wilson (Season 10 & Season 10)
5. Fifth Place: Olivia Hawkins & Marcel Somerville (Season 9 & Season 3)

The victory of Gabby and Casey, a couple who formed a strong connection later in the series, surprised many viewers, especially given the popularity of Luca and Grace, who had been a solid couple for a long period.

Key Episode Highlights: No Casa Amor and Major Drama

Unlike the main series of *Love Island*, the *All Stars* spin-off maintains a shorter run time, and a key element was missing from the episode guide: Casa Amor. The producers opted to keep the focus squarely on the dynamics of the returning Islanders in the main villa, leading to a constant, intense environment that fueled non-stop drama.

• 5 Shocking Facts About Anna Congdon Penn State Sweetheart To Nfl Fiances Social Media Firestorm Cc90e

The Ekin-Su and Curtis Rollercoaster

The pairing of Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu and Curtis Pritchard was arguably the biggest talking point of the season. The unexpected match between the fiery actress and the professional dancer created a fascinating dynamic. Their journey was full of dramatic tension, including several near-breakups and intense conversations about the future of their relationship. Despite the turbulence, they managed to secure a third-place finish, a testament to their individual popularity and the public's investment in their chaotic love story. Their final dates and emotional declarations were episode highlights that trended globally.

The Luca and Grace Connection

Many fans considered Luca Bish and Grace Jackson to be the frontrunners for the entire series. Luca, known for his possessiveness in Season 8, showed a more mature and dedicated side, while Grace was a breath of fresh air. Their stable and genuine connection was a welcome contrast to the constant *drama* elsewhere. Their second-place finish was a shock to many, proving that a solid relationship doesn't always guarantee a win in the public vote.

Olivia Hawkins and the Villain Edit

Olivia Hawkins returned to the villa and quickly became entangled in the season's biggest feuds. Her interactions with several Islanders, particularly Ekin-Su, were central to the early episodes. Many viewers felt Olivia was trying to play the 'villain' role, leading to intense social media discussion and high ratings for her confrontation episodes. Her eventual departure, alongside Marcel Somerville, marked a major shift in the villa's atmosphere.

The Winning Journey of Gabby and Casey

The winners, Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman, had a slow-burn journey that resonated with the voting public. Both Islanders were initially coupled with others—Gabby with Marcel and Casey with another bombshell. It was their genuine friendship that blossomed into a deep, loving relationship, proving the power of a natural connection over a dramatic one. Their final week of episodes, filled with heartfelt discussions and a beautiful final date, swung the public vote decisively in their favor, leading to their surprising victory.

The success of *Love Island: All Stars* Season 2, with its fresh format, unpredictable couplings, and the absence of traditional elements like Casa Amor, has cemented its place as a must-watch spin-off. Fans are already clamoring for confirmation of a Season 3, eager to see which other iconic Islanders will return to the *Love Island* villa for their shot at love and redemption.