The Unconfirmed Truth: A Timeline Of Jesse Lee Soffer's 3 Most Talked-About Relationships

Few actors have generated as much speculation about their personal lives as Jesse Lee Soffer, the beloved star who spent a decade playing Detective Jay Halstead on NBC’s *Chicago P.D.* As of late 2024 and into 2025, fan curiosity has reached a fever pitch, primarily centered on one key question: Is he secretly dating his former on-screen wife, Tracy Spiridakos?

The actor’s romantic history is famously linked to his professional life, having dated two different co-stars from the sprawling *One Chicago* universe. This deep dive explores the definitive timeline of Jesse Lee Soffer's confirmed relationships and breaks down the most recent, compelling evidence behind the unconfirmed romance that has the entire fandom buzzing.

Jesse Lee Soffer: Complete Biography and Professional Profile

Jesse Lee Soffer is an American actor and television director known for his long-running, critically acclaimed roles in both daytime and primetime television.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

• Full Name: Jesse Lee Soffer
• Born: April 23, 1984
• Birthplace: Ossining, New York, U.S.
• Career Start: Began acting at age six, notably landing a Kix cereal commercial.
• Daytime Fame: Portrayed the troubled youth Will Munson on the CBS soap opera *As the World Turns* (ATWT) from 2004 to 2008 and again in 2010. His work on the show earned him three Daytime Emmy Award nominations.
• Breakout Role: Detective Jay Halstead on *Chicago P.D.*, a role he played for ten seasons (2014–2022). He also appeared across the *One Chicago* franchise, including *Chicago Fire* and *Chicago Med*.
• Other Notable Work: Appeared in films like *In Time* and *Gracie*, and TV series such as *CSI: Miami*, *The Mentalist*, and *Rizzoli & Isles*.
• Chicago P.D. Exit: Soffer left the series midway through Season 10, stating his desire to "grow and expand" his career and avoid signing another multi-year contract, which would have kept him in the role until he was over 40. He has since returned to direct episodes of the show.

The Co-Star Connection: Jesse Lee Soffer’s Confirmed Romances

Jesse Lee Soffer’s love life has been closely followed by fans due to a striking pattern: his confirmed relationships often began with a co-star from the Dick Wolf universe. Both of his major public romances were with actresses who worked alongside him in the interconnected *One Chicago* franchise.

1. Sophia Bush (2014–2015/2016)

The first high-profile romance that caught the attention of the media was with his *Chicago P.D.* co-star, Sophia Bush. Bush played Detective Erin Lindsay, Jay Halstead’s partner and on-screen love interest, creating the fan-favorite ship "Linstead."

The couple began dating in real life in 2014, mirroring their on-screen chemistry.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Their relationship generated significant buzz among fans who were thrilled to see the fictional romance translate into a real-life pairing. However, the private couple kept details to a minimum.

The relationship reportedly ended in 2015, although some sources place the split in 2016.

Despite the breakup, both actors maintained a professional relationship until Bush's departure from the series after Season 4. Their ability to remain friends after dating is a testament to their professionalism on the set of the Intelligence Unit.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

2. Torrey DeVitto (2018–2019)

Jesse Lee Soffer’s second major public relationship was also with a co-star from the *One Chicago* universe, but this time from a different show: *Chicago Med*. Torrey DeVitto played Dr. Natalie Manning on the medical drama.

The couple confirmed their relationship in August 2018, having reportedly dated for about a year prior to the announcement.

This pairing highlighted the close-knit nature of the entire *One Chicago* cast, with actors from *Chicago P.D.*, *Chicago Med*, and *Chicago Fire* often interacting both on and off-screen.

DeVitto and Soffer were open about their contentment at the time, but the relationship ultimately concluded after about eight months of public dating in May 2019.

Since their split, Soffer has been notably private about his dating life, leading to the intense speculation surrounding his current status.

The Unconfirmed Romance: Are Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos Dating in 2025?

The most persistent and recent relationship rumors involving Jesse Lee Soffer concern his other *Chicago P.D.* on-screen wife, Tracy Spiridakos. Spiridakos played Detective Hailey Upton, forming the incredibly popular "Upstead" pairing with Halstead.

While their on-screen marriage ended with Jay Halstead’s Season 10 exit, the actors’ real-life bond appears to have only grown stronger, sparking a wave of renewed speculation in late 2024 and early 2025.

The Evidence Behind the Rumors

Despite neither actor publicly confirming or denying a romance, their consistent social media activity and public appearances have convinced many fans that they are in a relationship.

• Joint International Travel: In the months following Soffer’s exit, and continuing into 2025, the pair have repeatedly shared photos of themselves vacationing together in various international locations.
• European Trips: Photos of the two together in locations like France and Lisbon, Portugal, have been shared on their respective social media accounts, showing them side-by-side and clearly enjoying each other's company.
• The "Upstead" Continuity: The strong on-screen chemistry between Jay Halstead and Hailey Upton was undeniable, and fans are eager for the real-life romance to continue the story of their favorite pairing.
• Post-Show Closeness: Even after Soffer left the show and Spiridakos announced her own exit in 2024, they continued to post about each other, suggesting their bond transcends their professional roles in the Intelligence Unit.

The rumors reignited significantly in March 2025 following a sweet social media post, leaving fans breathless about a potential confirmation.

The Current Status in 2025

As of today, December 12, 2025, the relationship between Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos remains officially unconfirmed by both parties. They appear to be extremely close friends who share a deep personal bond and a love for travel.

The dynamic between the two actors perfectly encapsulates the unique phenomenon of the *One Chicago* franchise, where the lines between co-stars, friends, and romantic partners often seem to blur. Until a formal announcement is made, fans will continue to monitor their social media for the next vacation photo that might finally confirm the real-life Upstead romance.

Jesse Lee Soffer: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Did Jesse Lee Soffer date anyone after Torrey DeVitto?

Jesse Lee Soffer has not publicly confirmed a relationship since his split with Torrey DeVitto in 2019. However, he has been consistently linked to his former *Chicago P.D.* co-star Tracy Spiridakos, with strong dating rumors continuing into 2025 based on their frequent joint travels and social media posts.

Why did Jesse Lee Soffer leave Chicago P.D.?

Soffer left the role of Detective Jay Halstead in Season 10 of *Chicago P.D.* because he felt it was time to "grow and expand" his career and explore new projects. He stated that signing another multi-year contract would have kept him in the role until he was over 40, and he felt he only had "this one trip" to pursue other creative endeavors.

Did Jesse Lee Soffer and Sophia Bush date in real life?

Yes, Jesse Lee Soffer and Sophia Bush dated in real life. They were co-stars on *Chicago P.D.*, where they played the couple Erin Lindsay and Jay Halstead (Linstead). They began dating in 2014 and ended their relationship in 2015 or 2016.