The Iconic Catfish Twist: Where Are Antwane And "Tony" Now In 2025?

Few episodes of MTV’s Catfish: The TV Show have achieved the legendary status of the "Antwane & Tony" saga. Airing back in 2014 as the second episode of Season 3, this story delivered one of the most shocking and personal twists in the show’s history, leaving viewers stunned and launching an iconic catchphrase into internet culture. As of December 2025, the story of Antwane, his three-year-long phone romance with "Tony," and the unbelievable revelation behind the profile continues to be one of the most discussed segments, proving its enduring impact on the reality TV landscape.

The episode’s significance lies not just in the deception itself, but in the deeply personal motive behind the lie, which turned a classic online romance investigation into a raw, family drama. While new episodes of Catfish continue to air, fans frequently revisit this classic tale, always wondering about the current status of the two central figures, Antwane and his cousin, Carmen, the person behind the "Tony" persona.

The Shocking Biography: Antwane, Tony, and Carmen

The "Antwane & Tony" episode is unique because it features three main participants whose roles were dramatically redefined by the final reveal. No official full biographies are publicly available, as the participants are non-celebrities, but their roles in the show are well-documented.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

• Antwane: The Catfish-ee. Resides in Cincinnati, Ohio. He was in a three-year-long, voice-only relationship with "Tony," whom he met on a late-night phone chat line, a detail that immediately set the episode apart from typical social media catfishing cases. Antwane was described as living a "pre-digital age existence" by his cousin, Carmen.
• "Tony": The Fake Persona. Supposedly a man living in Atlanta, Georgia. The persona was maintained through phone calls, with the number sometimes showing a Cincinnati area code, which sparked Antwane's initial suspicion. Antwane had never seen a photo of Tony and didn't know his last name, relying entirely on voice and emotional connection.
• Carmen: The Catfish. Antwane's cousin and self-proclaimed best friend, also residing in Cincinnati, Ohio. Carmen was the one who initially contacted Nev Schulman and Max Joseph, claiming to be worried about Antwane's relationship. The shocking reveal was that Carmen had been "Tony" for three years, a twist that remains a top-tier moment in the series.

The Infamous 'Fat Ass Kelly Price' Catfish Twist

The investigation into "Tony" began when Antwane’s cousin, Carmen, reached out to Nev and Max. She expressed concern that Antwane, who was not tech-savvy, was being emotionally manipulated by a man he had never met. The investigation by the hosts, Nev Schulman and Max Joseph, quickly uncovered inconsistencies, such as the Cincinnati phone number and the lack of a digital footprint for "Tony."

The tension peaked when Nev and Max traced the number to an address in Cincinnati, leading them to a house where Carmen was waiting. The revelation that Carmen was "Tony" was a profound shock to Antwane, turning his search for love into a devastating betrayal by his own family member. The moment is often cited as one of the most personal and cruel catfishes in the show's history because it involved a close relative.

The reason for the three-year deception was even more shocking than the twist itself. Carmen revealed that she had created the persona to get revenge on Antwane. The motive? Antwane had once called her a "fat ass Kelly Price" during an argument. This moment, where Carmen passionately defends her actions by exclaiming, "You should’ve never called me a fat ass Kelly Price!" is the source of the episode's enduring fame and is one of the most quoted lines in Catfish history. The sheer pettiness and dedication to a three-year revenge plot made the episode instantly iconic.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

Where Are Antwane and Carmen Now? The 2025 Update

For fans who remember the raw emotion and anger following the reveal, the ultimate question remains: did Antwane and Carmen ever truly reconcile? The immediate aftermath was volatile, but a follow-up segment provided the most concrete update on their relationship, which remains the latest public information on the cousins as of December 2025.

The Reconciliation: Burying the Hatchet

The "Catfish: The TV Show" producers often check in with past participants in "Where Are They Now?" segments, and the update on Antwane and Carmen was a crucial one. Following the explosive confrontation, the two cousins did not speak to each other for approximately two years. The betrayal was too deep, and Antwane needed time to process the emotional manipulation by someone he considered family and a best friend.

However, the update revealed that the cousins eventually "buried the hatchet." Carmen expressed deep regret for her catfishing practice and the pain she caused. The follow-up showed that they were back on speaking terms, though their relationship was understandably changed. This reconciliation was a positive development, showing that even the deepest family rifts caused by online deception can sometimes heal over time.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

Antwane and Carmen's Current Status (2025)

Since the official "Catfish" catch-up segment, both Antwane and Carmen have largely retreated from the public spotlight. Unlike some other memorable participants who have leveraged their fame for social media careers, Antwane and Carmen appear to have returned to their private lives in Cincinnati, Ohio.

• Antwane: There are no recent, verifiable public updates regarding Antwane's relationship status or career as of late 2025. Given his initial discomfort with technology and social media, it is highly likely he maintains a very private life away from the internet.
• Carmen: The "Where Are They Now?" segment indicated that Carmen had quit her habit of catfishing. Her current professional and personal life is private. The most significant update is the confirmation that she and Antwane have repaired their family bond, which is a major win considering the circumstances of their episode.

The enduring legacy of the episode is a testament to the fact that the most shocking lies often come from the people closest to us. The "Antwane & Tony" episode serves as a powerful cautionary tale about the damage revenge and petty arguments can inflict on family relationships.

The Legacy of a Catfish Hall of Fame Episode

The "Antwane & Tony" episode is a staple in any discussion of the best Catfish episodes. It successfully flipped the script, making the person who called for help (Carmen) the actual catfish, a narrative device that has rarely been matched in the series' long run. The episode is frequently featured in lists of the show's wildest twists, cementing its place in pop culture.

The iconic quote, "You should’ve never called me a fat ass Kelly Price," continues to be a meme and a shorthand reference for over-the-top, personal revenge plots. The episode’s success is also credited to the initial premise: a three-year relationship sustained entirely through a phone chat line, a throwback to pre-internet dating that added another layer of intrigue.

Ultimately, while the current day-to-day lives of Antwane and Carmen remain private in December 2025, their story is a permanent fixture in the Catfish universe. It is a powerful reminder that while Nev and Max are searching for a mysterious online lover, the real drama can often be found in the complex, messy relationships of the people sitting right next to them.