The Definitive Truth: Why The Jeffrey Dahmer Movie Zac Efron Rumor Won't Die

As of December 12, 2025, there is no confirmed or rumored project where actor Zac Efron is set to play the infamous serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. This persistent speculation is a classic case of true crime conflation, stemming from Efron's critically divisive portrayal of Ted Bundy in the 2019 film *Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile*. The definitive, high-profile portrayal of Jeffrey Dahmer in recent memory belongs to Evan Peters in the massively successful 2022 Netflix limited series, *Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story*. This article will break down the facts, explore the origin of the rumor, and detail the various actors who have actually taken on the role of the "Milwaukee Cannibal." The confusion surrounding Zac Efron and Jeffrey Dahmer highlights a significant trend in the modern true crime genre: the casting of former teen heartthrobs in sinister, real-life serial killer roles. The success of both Efron's Ted Bundy film and Evan Peters' Dahmer series has cemented this controversial casting strategy, leading the public to frequently merge the two actors and their roles, especially given the continuous production of new serial killer biopics and docuseries by streaming giants like Netflix.

The Definitive Biographies of the Killers and Their Portrayers

To fully understand the source of the "Zac Efron as Dahmer" confusion, it is essential to separate the distinct figures and their respective cinematic portrayals. The two serial killers, Jeffrey Dahmer and Ted Bundy, were active during different decades and had different methods, but their recent on-screen representation shares a common thread: casting attractive, well-known actors.

• Jeffrey Dahmer (The Milwaukee Cannibal)
  • Crimes: Murdered 17 young men and boys between 1978 and 1991. His crimes involved sexual assault, dismemberment, and cannibalism.
  • Death: Beaten to death by fellow inmate Christopher Scarver at the Columbia Correctional Institution in 1994.
  • Primary Portrayer (Netflix): Evan Peters (*Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story*, 2022).
  • Other Portrayers: Ross Lynch (*My Friend Dahmer*, 2017), Jeremy Renner (*Dahmer*, 2002), and Carl Crew (*The Secret Life: Jeffrey Dahmer*, 1993).
• Ted Bundy (The Campus Killer)
  • Crimes: Confessed to 30 homicides of young women across seven states in the 1970s, though the true number is unknown. He was known for his charm and ability to manipulate victims.
  • Death: Executed by the electric chair in Florida in 1989.
  • Primary Portrayer (Netflix Film): Zac Efron (*Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile*, 2019).

The 'Hot Serial Killer' Trope: Why Efron and Peters Are Constantly Linked

The persistent inquiry about a "Jeffrey Dahmer movie Zac Efron" is not accidental; it is a direct consequence of a deliberate and often criticized casting trend in the true crime genre. When Zac Efron, a star known for family-friendly roles like *High School Musical* and comedies like *Neighbors*, was cast as the charming, yet brutal, Ted Bundy, it generated massive buzz and controversy. The film was criticized for potentially glamorizing Bundy's image, a debate which was reignited when Evan Peters, another beloved actor from *American Horror Story*, was cast as Jeffrey Dahmer. The core connection is the deliberate use of the actors' existing "heartthrob" status to highlight the deceptive nature of the killers they portray.

• Zac Efron's Bundy: Efron’s portrayal in *Extremely Wicked* focused heavily on Bundy's charisma and how he was able to fool his long-time girlfriend, Liz Kendall, and the public. The film was largely told from Kendall's perspective, emphasizing the manipulation and charm.
• Evan Peters' Dahmer: While Peters’ performance was lauded for its nuanced, disturbing depth, his casting still drew attention to the physical transformation of a conventionally attractive actor into a deeply unsettling figure. The series, however, focused more on the victims and the systemic failures of the police.

The public’s tendency to search for "Zac Efron Dahmer" is a natural extension of this phenomenon. It’s a desire to see the actor who masterfully portrayed one charming killer take on another infamous figure, even though the definitive role has already been filled by Evan Peters. This conflation is further fueled by the sheer volume of true crime content, making it difficult for audiences to keep the various biopics, docuseries, and actors straight.

The Monster Franchise and Future True Crime Projects

The most up-to-date information confirms that the future of high-profile serial killer narratives on Netflix lies with the continuation of the *Monster* anthology series, created by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan. This is the franchise that brought Evan Peters' Dahmer story to the screen, and it is highly unlikely that a new, separate Jeffrey Dahmer project starring Zac Efron would be greenlit so soon after the series' monumental success. The *Monster* series is set to continue with two additional installments, focusing on other notorious figures in American true crime history.

1. Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story: The second season is confirmed to focus on the Menendez brothers, who were convicted of the 1989 murder of their parents.
2. Future Installments: While a third subject has not been officially confirmed, there is constant speculation about which high-profile serial killer or notorious criminal case will be tackled next. Figures like Ed Gein or the Zodiac Killer are frequently mentioned in fan discussions.

Given Zac Efron's proven ability to deliver a compelling, if controversial, performance as a serial killer, it is not outside the realm of possibility that he could be considered for a role in a future *Monster* season, perhaps even reprising his role as Ted Bundy if the series decided to cover his story. However, his involvement in a new Jeffrey Dahmer project is definitively ruled out by the critical success and recent release of the Evan Peters series.

Conclusion: Separating Fact from True Crime Fiction

The idea of a "Jeffrey Dahmer movie Zac Efron" is a compelling piece of true crime curiosity, but it remains a rumor born from the conflation of two separate, high-profile projects. Zac Efron successfully portrayed Ted Bundy, while Evan Peters delivered the definitive recent performance as Jeffrey Dahmer. The intense public interest underscores the ongoing fascination with serial killer narratives and the debate over the ethics of casting attractive actors in such roles. For now, fans of Zac Efron's darker side should look forward to his future dramatic roles, while the legacy of Jeffrey Dahmer on screen rests firmly with Evan Peters and the continued success of the Netflix *Monster* franchise.