The Ultimate 'Survivor: Redemption Island' Cast Update (Season 22): Where Are They Now In 2024?

For fans of classic reality television, *Survivor: Redemption Island* (Season 22) remains one of the most polarizing and memorable seasons in the show's history. Airing in 2011, the season introduced the controversial "Redemption Island" twist, which gave eliminated players a chance to duel their way back into the game, all while pitting two of the series' biggest legends, "Boston Rob" Mariano and Russell Hantz, against each other. This current date, December 11, 2025, marks over a decade since the season aired, and the lives of the 18 contestants have changed dramatically, with some becoming actors, others podcast hosts, and one even launching a new business venture in 2024. The season was defined by "Boston Rob's" masterful strategic control over the Ometepe tribe and the dramatic, often hilarious, antics of his primary ally, Phillip Sheppard. While the season is often criticized for its predictable outcome, the journey of the new players, especially those fighting for survival on Redemption Island, provided unforgettable moments and launched several *Survivor* careers. Below is the definitive, up-to-date look at the entire *Survivor: Redemption Island* cast and what they have been doing since their time on the beaches of San Juan del Sur, Nicaragua.

Complete Survivor: Redemption Island (Season 22) Cast List and Biography

The Survivor: Redemption Island cast featured 16 new contestants and two returning players, Rob Mariano and Russell Hantz, who were placed on opposing tribes, Ometepe and Zapatera, respectively. This list details the full cast, their original tribe, and their finishing position.

• Francesca Hogi: Ometepe, 1st Voted Out (Day 3)
• Russell Hantz: Zapatera, 2nd Voted Out (Day 6)
• Kristina Kell: Ometepe, 3rd Voted Out (Day 9)
• Stephanie Valencia: Zapatera, 4th Voted Out (Day 12)
• Krista Klumpp: Zapatera, 5th Voted Out (Day 15)
• Matt Elrod: Ometepe, 6th Voted Out (Day 18) / 10th Place
• Sarita White: Zapatera, 7th Voted Out (Day 21)
• David Murphy: Zapatera, 8th Voted Out (Day 24)
• Julie Wolfe: Zapatera, 9th Voted Out (Day 27)
• Ralph Kiser: Zapatera, 10th Voted Out (Day 30)
• Mike Chiesl: Zapatera, 11th Voted Out (Day 33)
• Grant Mattos: Ometepe, 8th Place
• Andrea Boehlke: Ometepe, 7th Place
• Ashley Underwood: Ometepe, 6th Place
• Steve Wright: Zapatera, 5th Place
• Natalie Tenerelli: Ometepe, 4th Place
• Matt Elrod: Ometepe, 10th Place (Re-entered game on Day 19)
• Phillip Sheppard: Ometepe, Runner-Up
• Rob Mariano: Ometepe, Sole Survivor (Winner)

The Ometepe Alliance: Where are Rob, Phillip, and Natalie Now?

The season’s central storyline revolved around the Ometepe tribe, which was completely dominated by "Boston Rob's" strategic genius. His ability to cultivate loyalty and manage the personalities of his alliance members—Phillip Sheppard, Natalie Tenerelli, and Ashley Underwood—is considered one of the most effective strategic plays in *Survivor* history. This core group made it to the final four, ensuring Rob's long-awaited victory.

"Boston Rob" Mariano: The Sole Survivor

Rob Mariano, the ultimate winner of *Redemption Island*, finally secured his $1 million prize on his fourth attempt. Since his win, Rob Mariano has remained an integral part of the *Survivor* universe. He returned to the show for a fifth time in *Winners at War* (Season 40) alongside his wife, Amber Brkich Mariano, further cementing his legacy as a *Survivor* icon. Beyond the show, Rob has hosted a travel show called *Rob and Amber: Marriage Boot Camp* and has been involved in several other reality television projects. He is highly active on social media, often sharing updates about his family life with Amber and their four daughters. His victory in Season 22 is still widely studied as a masterclass in social and strategic control, especially how he neutralized the threat of Russell Hantz early in the game.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Phillip Sheppard: The Stealth R Us Founder

Phillip Sheppard, the eccentric former federal agent, was the season’s unforgettable runner-up. His dramatic rivalry with Francesca Hogi and his self-proclaimed "Stealth R Us" alliance provided much of the season's entertainment. In recent years, Phillip has been candid about his experience on the show. In a 2024 update, he discussed feeling "traumatized" by how he was treated and portrayed in the edit of *Redemption Island*. This perspective sheds new light on the pressure and psychological toll the game can take on contestants, especially those with a polarizing edit. He has also reportedly written several biographies about himself.

Natalie Tenerelli and Ashley Underwood

Natalie Tenerelli, the youngest contestant at the time, and Ashley Underwood were key components of Rob's final alliance. Natalie finished third, while Ashley was voted out just before the Final Tribal Council. Both women have largely stepped away from the reality TV spotlight. Natalie, a professional dancer and ballet instructor, focuses on her career in the arts. Ashley, a nurse practitioner, has also focused on her professional life, but both occasionally reflect on their time as members of the dominant Ometepe tribe.

The Redemption Island Fighters: New Careers and Recent Ventures

The Redemption Island twist was a brutal gauntlet that tested the physical and mental fortitude of the eliminated players. Two contestants, in particular, stood out for their resilience and have since gone on to fascinating post-show careers.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Matt Elrod: From Missionary to Hollywood Actor

Matt Elrod is perhaps the most tragic figure of the season, voted out early but winning an incredible seven duels to return to the game, only to be immediately betrayed by Rob and voted out again. Matt’s journey, which included a remarkable run of duel wins, is a testament to his fighting spirit. In a major career pivot, Matt is now a successful actor, operating under the stage name Wyatt Nash. He has landed significant roles in television, appearing in series like *Pretty Little Liars* and *Dear White People*, a massive transition from his original occupation as a missionary. His story highlights how *Survivor* can be a launchpad for unexpected career paths.

Andrea Boehlke: The Media Personality

Andrea Boehlke was a strong strategic player and a major threat in the game, eventually returning to play two more times (*Caramoan* and *Game Changers*). Since her time on the show, Andrea has built a successful career in media. She is now a host for People Magazine's podcast and has been a prominent voice in *Survivor* and pop culture commentary, often interviewing current and former contestants. Her continued presence in the media landscape keeps her closely connected to the reality television world that launched her career.

The Zapatera Tribe and First Boots: 2024 Updates

The Zapatera tribe, led by a less-effective Russell Hantz, struggled to gain footing against Rob's dominance. The season also featured the infamous first boot, who has since found success in a completely different field.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

Francesca Hogi: The Love Coach and Entrepreneur

Francesca Hogi holds the unfortunate distinction of being the first person voted out of *Survivor* twice (Season 22 and Season 26: *Caramoan*). Her initial elimination was marked by a memorable argument with Phillip Sheppard. However, Francesca has completely reinvented her career. In a significant 2024 update, she is now a highly respected Love and Life Coach, hosting the "Dear Franny" podcast and co-founding a new company with Felicity Fellows. She has used her reality TV experience as a lesson in overcoming public criticism and not internalizing others' opinions, turning her notoriety into a platform for positive change.

Ralph Kiser: The Farmer

Ralph Kiser, the farmer from Virginia, was a memorable member of the Zapatera tribe known for his eccentric personality and ability to find the Hidden Immunity Idol. Ralph sadly passed away in 2022 at the age of 56. His passing was a moment of reflection for the *Survivor* community, who remembered his humor and genuine nature. Other key members of the Zapatera tribe, such as Mike Chiesl and David Murphy, have returned to their professional careers, with Mike working as a police officer and David as a lawyer, largely remaining out of the public eye.

The Lasting Legacy of Survivor: Redemption Island

*Survivor: Redemption Island* is a season that continues to spark debate among fans and critics. While the Redemption Island twist itself was divisive, the season served as the triumphant culmination of "Boston Rob's" long *Survivor* journey, a narrative that had been building since *Marquesas* (Season 4). The season's success, however, relied heavily on the compelling and often chaotic new cast, who were forced to navigate a game designed for a veteran to win. The individual stories of survival—Matt Elrod's record-breaking duel streak, Francesca Hogi's resilience, and Phillip Sheppard's theatrical performance—are what truly give the season its topical authority and enduring interest. The current updates from 2024 show that for many of the contestants, the experience was a pivotal, life-altering event that shaped their career paths and personal philosophies for years to come.