The Nacho Breakup: Are Cely Vazquez And Johnny Middlebrooks Still Together In 2025?

The short and definitive answer to the question "Are Cely and Johnny still together?" is no, they are not. The fan-favorite runners-up from Love Island USA Season 2 officially ended their relationship in January 2021, just a few months after leaving the Las Vegas villa. Their split was messy, public, and, as of , it remains one of the most talked-about breakups in the show's history, especially after their explosive reunion on the spin-off series, Love Island Games, which provided new, dramatic context to their separation.

The relationship between Cely Vazquez and Johnny Middlebrooks, which began under the bright lights of reality television, captivated audiences with its high highs and dramatic lows. While they ultimately finished in second place, their journey outside the villa was short-lived, culminating in an infamous incident that involved a trip to a casual dining chain and a plate of nachos, a story that continues to define the legacy of their romance.

Cely Vazquez and Johnny Middlebrooks: A Complete Biographical Profile

To fully appreciate the context of their relationship and subsequent breakup, it is important to know the key details about the two reality television personalities.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Cely Vazquez Biography

• Full Name: Cely Vazquez
• Hometown: Sacramento, California
• Original Occupation: Legal Secretary
• Reality TV Appearances: Love Island USA Season 2 (Runner-Up), Love Island Games Season 1
• Age (Approximate): 27 (as of late 2024/2025)
• Education: Graduated from East Union High School (2014), where she played soccer.
• Current Career Focus: Media personality, social media influencer, known for her vibrant personality and singing voice.

Johnny Middlebrooks Biography

• Full Name: Johnny Lee Middlebrooks
• Hometown: Chesapeake, Virginia
• Original Occupation: Student and Media Personality
• Reality TV Appearances: Love Island USA Season 2 (Runner-Up), Love Island Games Season 1, Love Island Games Season 2 (Returning Bombshell)
• Date of Birth: June 20, 1998
• Age (Approximate): 27 (as of late 2024/2025)
• Education/Athletics: Attended the University of Mount Olive, where he competed in Track and Field. Played football for Hickory High School.
• Current Career Focus: Media personality, model, and reality TV star, continuing his presence in the Love Island franchise.

The Love Island USA Journey: From Villa Romance to Real-World Split

Cely and Johnny's relationship was a focal point of Love Island USA Season 2. They coupled up relatively early, and despite a significant challenge during the Casa Amor segment—where Johnny explored a connection with another Islander, Mercades Schell—they reunited and ultimately finished the season as the second-place couple, losing out to Cely's best friend, Justine Ndiba, and her partner, Caleb Corprew.

The couple left the Las Vegas villa together, committed to making their long-distance relationship work. However, the transition to the outside world, away from the controlled environment of the show, proved difficult. On January 9, 2021, Cely announced on social media that she and Johnny had mutually decided to break up. At the time, she did not provide a specific reason, only stating, "Johnny and I are no longer together."

Their breakup came as a surprise to many fans who had invested heavily in the couple's journey, making them one of the most high-profile splits from the US version of the show.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

The Infamous 'Nacho' Breakup and Love Island Games Showdown

For years, the exact details of the split remained vague, but a new, dramatic chapter was written when both Cely and Johnny appeared on the inaugural season of Love Island Games in late 2023.

During a candid moment on Love Island Games, Cely finally revealed the surprising—and somewhat comical—catalyst for the final argument that led to their breakup: a disagreement over food. Cely explained that they were at a Cheesecake Factory, and an argument ensued when Johnny refused to pay for her nachos.

This "nacho breakup" detail instantly went viral, becoming a legendary piece of Love Island lore. The incident, while seeming trivial, highlighted the underlying tension and lack of support Cely felt in the relationship outside of the reality TV bubble.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Johnny's Side of the Story

Johnny Middlebrooks, who returned as a bombshell for Love Island Games Season 2, addressed the "nachos" story on the show, attempting to clear his name. While he confirmed the argument at the Cheesecake Factory, he strongly denied that the nachos were the *reason* for the breakup. He stated that "if anyone thinks that two people that love each other would break up over nachos, you got another thing coming," suggesting the issue was a symptom of deeper, unresolved problems in their post-villa relationship.

Their confrontation on Love Island Games Season 1 was highly charged, with Cely calling out Johnny for his behavior both during their relationship and after their split. Despite the intense drama, both parties ultimately moved on with their individual journeys on the show. Cely found a new connection with another Islander, while Johnny went on to couple up with Gabby Allen, an Islander from the UK franchise.

Where Are Cely and Johnny Now? (2025 Update)

As of , both Cely Vazquez and Johnny Middlebrooks are focused on their individual careers and love lives, with no indication of a reconciliation.

Cely Vazquez has maintained a strong presence on social media and continues to be a popular personality in the reality TV sphere, with her appearance on Love Island Games solidifying her status as a fan favorite. She uses her platform to share her life, music, and fashion.

Johnny Middlebrooks has fully embraced the reality television circuit. After his time on Love Island Games Season 1, he returned for Season 2, proving he is a recurring fixture in the Love Island universe. His focus remains on his media career and building new connections within the reality TV community.

The saga of Cely and Johnny serves as a classic example of the challenges faced by reality TV couples. While their romance was a highlight of Love Island USA Season 2, the pressures of the real world—and perhaps a disagreement over late-night snacks—ultimately proved too much for the relationship to survive. They are no longer together, but their dramatic history, from the villa to the Cheesecake Factory, ensures they will remain linked in the minds of fans for years to come.