The Four Horsemen: Where Is The Cast Of Now You See Me Now? (2025 Update)

The magic is set to return in 2025, with the long-awaited third installment of the thrilling heist franchise, *Now You See Me: Now You Don’t*, confirmed for release. As anticipation builds for the return of the world's most charismatic illusionists, fans are eager to know what the ensemble of A-list actors—The Four Horsemen and their FBI handler—have been up to since their last cinematic performance. This comprehensive update, current as of December 2025, reveals the freshest career moves, new film projects, and personal developments for the core cast, proving that their careers are anything but an illusion.

The original films, *Now You See Me* (2013) and *Now You See Me 2* (2016), captivated audiences with their blend of high-stakes heists, intricate plot twists, and dazzling stage magic. Now, with the third film on the horizon, the stars are busier than ever, moving from grand illusions to major new dramas, comedies, and even directorial debuts. Get ready to pull back the curtain on the current lives and upcoming projects of the exceptional cast.

The Returning Four Horsemen and Key Players: A 2025 Career Profile

The ensemble cast of the *Now You See Me* franchise is a powerhouse of Oscar-nominated and award-winning talent. The film's success is largely attributed to the chemistry between these core actors, many of whom are returning for the 2025 sequel, *Now You See Me: Now You Don't*.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

• Jesse Eisenberg (J. Daniel "Danny" Atlas): The Horseman known as The Lover, a talented, arrogant street magician and leader of the group.
• Woody Harrelson (Merritt McKinney): The Horseman known as The Hermit, a mentalist and hypnotist with a dry wit and sharp mind.
• Isla Fisher (Henley Reeves): The Horseman known as The High Priestess, an escapist and stage magician who was Danny Atlas’s former assistant. She returns for the third film after being absent from the second.
• Dave Franco (Jack Wilder): The Horseman known as Death, a street magician, sleight-of-hand expert, and jack-of-all-trades.
• Lizzy Caplan (Lula May): The Horseman who replaced Henley Reeves in the second film, known as The Fool, a quirky and inventive illusionist.
• Mark Ruffalo (Dylan Rhodes): The FBI agent initially tasked with capturing the Horsemen who is secretly a member of The Eye and the son of the deceased illusionist Lionel Shrike.
• Morgan Freeman (Thaddeus Bradley): The former magician and magic debunker who serves as the film's enigmatic narrator and, eventually, a key ally to The Eye.
• Michael Caine (Arthur Tressler): The wealthy insurance magnate and the first film’s primary antagonist, often funding the Horsemen's rivals.

Jesse Eisenberg and Woody Harrelson: From Illusions to Accolades

The two most prominent male Horsemen, J. Daniel Atlas and Merritt McKinney, have spent 2025 focusing on critically acclaimed and high-profile projects, proving their versatility beyond the world of cinematic magic. The dynamic duo is confirmed to be part of the returning cast for the highly anticipated *Now You See Me: Now You Don't*, promising more of their signature banter and showmanship.

Jesse Eisenberg's Golden Globe Buzz and Directorial Focus

Jesse Eisenberg’s career continues to evolve, with the actor-turned-filmmaker making significant waves in the industry in 2025. His film, *A Real Pain*, where he serves as writer, director, and star, has garnered substantial buzz, securing four nominations at the 2025 Golden Globe Awards. The film, which is slated for release in early 2025, showcases Eisenberg's depth as a multihyphenate talent.

Further cementing his status behind the camera, Eisenberg is also developing a new, untitled comedy project with A24, the studio behind many recent critical hits. Looking ahead, his third directorial effort is already in the works—a musical based on his original script, which is expected to hit theaters in 2026. These projects highlight a shift in his focus towards independent filmmaking and screenwriting, a departure from his big-budget roles like Atlas.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Woody Harrelson's Thrilling 2025 Film Slate

Woody Harrelson, known for his laid-back yet intense performances as Merritt McKinney, has a major thriller scheduled for a 2025 release. His deep-sea diver film, *Last Breath*, is set to premiere on February 28, 2025. This high-stakes drama will see Harrelson in a tense, survival-focused role, a stark contrast to the comedic hypnotist he portrays in the *Now You See Me* series. In addition to his return as Merritt, Harrelson’s continued work across genres demonstrates his enduring status as one of Hollywood's most reliable and engaging character actors.

Mark Ruffalo, Isla Fisher, and Lizzy Caplan: TV Dramas and Comedies

The supporting cast, which includes the franchise's secret mastermind and the two female Horsemen, have also been incredibly busy, with 2025 bringing them major roles in prestige television and feature films. The fresh news around these actors provides a great topical authority for the article.

Mark Ruffalo’s Return to HBO with *Task*

Mark Ruffalo, who plays the pivotal role of FBI Agent Dylan Rhodes, has transitioned back to prestige television following his Oscar-nominated work. He is set to star as a determined FBI leader in the new HBO crime drama series titled *Task*. This highly anticipated project, from the creator of *Mare of Easttown*, is slated for a September 8, 2025 release. Ruffalo’s character, a man wrestling with his own moral compromises, echoes the complex dual nature of Dylan Rhodes, the agent who is secretly a master magician.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

Isla Fisher's Major Comeback and Personal News

Isla Fisher, returning as the original Horseman Henley Reeves in *Now You See Me 3*, is having a busy 2025. The actress is currently filming a new comedy project, *Spa Weekend*, in Australia. Her upcoming film slate for 2025 is packed, including roles in *Playdate*, the highly anticipated sequel *Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy*, and the animated film *Dog Man*. Personally, Fisher made headlines in 2024 with the announcement of her divorce from comedian Sacha Baron Cohen, though the separation occurred in 2023. Her return to the franchise, after missing the second film, is one of the most exciting aspects of the 2025 sequel.

Lizzy Caplan's High-Stakes Netflix Dramas

Lizzy Caplan, who joined the team as Lula May in *Now You See Me 2*, is another cast member making a significant impact on streaming television. In 2025, she took on a main role in the high-stakes tech drama miniseries *Zero Day* on Netflix, which premiered in February. Furthermore, she is attached to an A24 crisis PR drama series that was acquired by Netflix in March 2025, showcasing her continued partnership with major streaming platforms and her knack for sharp, complex dramatic roles.

The Masterminds and Mentors: Freeman, Caine, and Franco Updates

The veteran actors who provide the gravitas and narrative backbone, alongside the youngest Horseman, continue their prolific careers.

Morgan Freeman: Action and Thrillers in 2025

Morgan Freeman, the voice of the franchise as the enigmatic Thaddeus Bradley, remains one of the most in-demand actors in the industry. For 2025, his upcoming film projects include the action thriller *Night Has Fallen*, starring alongside Gerard Butler and Eva Green. He is also slated to appear in *The Last Tomb* with Jason Statham, further demonstrating his commitment to the action and thriller genres. His return in the third *Now You See Me* film is essential to unraveling the mysteries of The Eye.

Dave Franco's Sundance Success and Horror Debut

Dave Franco's career is marked by his collaborative work with his wife, Alison Brie. In 2025, their latest project, a horror film titled *Together*, premiered at the Sundance Film Festival. The film, which explores the dynamics of a married couple facing a terrifying situation, has received critical praise. Franco's ability to balance indie projects, like his directorial debut *The Rental*, with major franchise roles like Jack Wilder, highlights his diverse career trajectory.

Michael Caine and the Retirement Question

Sir Michael Caine, who plays the wealthy and vengeful Arthur Tressler, has been the subject of ongoing retirement speculation. In 2025, the 92-year-old actor made a high-profile appearance at the Red Sea International Film Festival. He has openly discussed his possible retirement from acting, a conversation he has engaged in several times over the last decade. While his last confirmed feature film was 2023's *The Great Escaper*, his presence and influence in the industry, and his role in the original *Now You See Me* trilogy, remain legendary.

The Big Reveal: Now You See Me 3—Now You Don't (2025)

The most exciting update for fans is the official status of the sequel. The third film, officially titled *Now You See Me: Now You Don’t*, is scheduled to be released in theaters on November 14, 2025.

The returning cast includes the core players: Jesse Eisenberg, Woody Harrelson, Dave Franco, Isla Fisher, Lizzy Caplan, Mark Ruffalo, Morgan Freeman, and Michael Caine. The film, directed by Ruben Fleischer (*Venom*, *Zombieland*), will also introduce a new generation of magicians and actors to the franchise.

New Cast Members Joining The Eye:

• Ariana Greenblatt
• Justice Smith
• Dominic Sessa

This mix of veteran talent and fresh faces suggests that the film will bridge the gap between the original Horsemen and a new set of illusionists, potentially expanding the mysterious organization known as The Eye. The film promises to deliver the same high-energy, twist-filled spectacle that made the first two films global successes. The stage is set for the biggest heist yet, and the cast is more than ready to pull off their next impossible trick.