The Ultimate Betrayal: 5 Shocking Reasons Sara Rejected Ben On Love Is Blind And Her Explosive New Romance With *Another* Cast Member

The tumultuous journey of Sara Carton and Ben Mezzenga on Love Is Blind Season 8 captivated viewers, but their dramatic split at the altar was only the beginning of a far more explosive post-show narrative that continues to dominate reality TV headlines as of this current date, December 10, 2025. What seemed like a promising match from the Minneapolis pods quickly unraveled into a complex web of political disagreements, personal accusations, and a sensational new relationship that few fans saw coming. The definitive answer to "Are Sara and Ben still together?" is a resounding no, but the story of why and who Sara is dating now is the real stunner.

The couple's televised wedding day rejection set the stage for a dramatic reunion, where Sara revealed the deeper, more personal reasons behind her decision, including a shocking social media exposé on Ben. However, the biggest twist arrived months later when Sara went Instagram official with a different, and very familiar, Season 8 cast member, solidifying her place as one of the most talked-about participants in the show's history.

Full Biography and Profile: Sara Carton and Ben Mezzenga

To understand the depth of their connection and subsequent fallout, here is a complete profile of the couple who failed to make it to "I Do" but succeeded in creating reality TV gold.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

• Full Name (Sara): Sara Carton
• Age (During Filming): 29 years old
• Occupation: Oncology Nurse
• Hometown: St. Cloud, Minnesota area
• Key Relationship Entity: Engaged to Ben Mezzenga in the pods. Currently dating Joey Leveille (Season 8 cast member).

• Full Name (Ben): Ben Mezzenga
• Age (During Filming): 28 years old
• Occupation: Developer / Tech
• Hometown: Shoreview, Minnesota
• Key Relationship Entity: Engaged to Sara Carton. Known for his competitive nature and "avoidant" communication style.

The Pod Connection: From Perfect Match to Political Minefield

Sara and Ben’s journey started with a seemingly strong physical attraction upon meeting, but their pod conversations quickly revealed significant underlying differences that the experiment was designed to ignore. They were part of the "Minneapolis pod squad" of Season 8, and their initial chemistry was undeniable, leading them to become one of the first couples to get engaged.

However, once outside the isolation of the pods and back in the real world of Minneapolis, their contrasting worldviews began to surface. Their differences extended beyond simple personality quirks, touching on fundamental values like religion and, most notably, politics. Sara, an oncology nurse, was vocal about her progressive views, while Ben, a developer, was perceived as more evasive and non-committal on heavy topics. This struggle between their values became a major point of tension, hinting at the instability of their future.

The Real Reason Sara Said "I Can't": Political and Social Stances

The biggest on-screen conflict that led to the failed wedding was Sara's realization that Ben's social and political investment did not align with hers. Standing at the altar, Sara delivered a shocking rejection, stating that she couldn't marry him because she felt he was not invested enough in social issues, particularly those concerning LGBTQ+ rights.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

This rejection was a powerful moment that shifted the narrative of their relationship from simple cold feet to a profound clash of values. Sara later explained that she felt Ben was not the passionate, empathetic partner she needed, especially when it came to advocating for marginalized communities. This thematic focus on political and social compatibility became a key topical authority point for the season.

The Post-Show Fallout: TikTok Drama and Ben’s "Avoidant" Behavior

The drama intensified exponentially after the wedding, particularly during the Love Is Blind Season 8 reunion. During the reunion, Sara Carton dropped a bombshell, revealing that she had "discovered" a mysterious TikTok video about Ben Mezzenga that raised serious concerns about his character and past behavior with women.

The TikTok user allegedly accused Ben of mistreating women in the past. When confronted on the reunion couch, Ben dismissed the allegations, claiming the relationship in question was long ago and that he had since grown. However, Sara was visibly disappointed with his "underwhelming" and "avoidant" response, which further solidified her suspicions that he may have had a "motive" for being on the show.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

Sara later told the press that Ben "dropped me" immediately after the show, making their relationship "rocky" and confirming that they did not continue dating post-filming. This post-reunion fallout cemented their final split, with Sara feeling that Ben's lack of accountability and his seemingly calculated behavior proved her decision at the altar was correct.

• Key Entities in the Drama: Ben Mezzenga’s alleged "avoidant attachment style," the viral "mysterious TikTok," Sara Carton’s confrontation, and Ben's perceived lack of remorse.

The Shocking New Romance: Sara Carton and Joey Leveille

The biggest, freshest, and most unexpected twist in the Sara and Ben narrative involves a completely different cast member from the same season. While viewers were focused on the drama between the original couples, a romance was secretly brewing backstage. On December 3, 2025, Sara Carton and Joey Leveille went Instagram official, confirming they are a couple.

Joey Leveille was also a participant on Love Is Blind Season 8, where he was engaged to Monica Danús. Like Sara and Ben, Joey and Monica's relationship ended, though his departure from the show was less dramatic. This pairing of two individuals who found love outside their original engagements is a massive, unique development for the season and a major win for the "second chances" narrative.

The relationship between Sara and Joey is a testament to the fact that while the pods may not have worked for them initially, the experience of being on the show brought them together. Their public announcement has generated significant buzz, positioning them as the unexpected power couple of the season. This new relationship provides a positive conclusion to Sara’s tumultuous journey, offering a fresh, happy ending that was not found with Ben Mezzenga.

What This Means for the 'Love Is Blind' Universe

The saga of Sara, Ben, and Joey is a powerful case study in the complexities of reality dating. It highlights the importance of shared social values over initial physical attraction and the intense public scrutiny that follows contestants. The ultimate resolution—Sara finding a genuine connection with a peer who understood the unique pressures of the experiment—adds a new layer of topical authority to the show’s lore. It proves that sometimes, the true love story is found not in the first engagement, but in the connections made among the cast members themselves.

Fans are now eagerly awaiting more details on Sara and Joey's relationship, confirming that the drama and the search for authentic love extend far beyond the final episode.