The Real Conjuring House: 7 Shocking Updates On The Perron Haunting, Bathsheba's True Story, And The New Owner Drama

The true story behind The Conjuring movie franchise is far more complex and dramatic than Hollywood ever revealed. As of December 10, 2025, the infamous Arnold Estate in Harrisville, Rhode Island—the setting for the terrifying 1971 Perron family haunting—has been at the center of a new wave of controversy, legal battles, and shocking historical re-evaluations. The core narrative of the haunting, involving the Perron family and the spirit of Bathsheba Sherman, continues to be a subject of intense paranormal investigation and historical research, with new information constantly emerging.

The original case, investigated by renowned demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren, cemented its place in paranormal lore. However, recent events, including a controversial auction and a definitive re-examination of the alleged witch's history, prove that the story of "the real Conjuring" is still being written, with updates that challenge everything fans thought they knew.

The Perron Family and The Arnold Estate Haunting: A Full Biography

The haunting that inspired The Conjuring centers on the experiences of the Perron family, who lived in the rural Harrisville, Rhode Island farmhouse from 1971 to 1980. Their decade-long ordeal forms the basis of the movie's terrifying plot.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

• Family Members: Roger Perron (Father), Carolyn Perron (Mother), and their five daughters: Andrea Perron (Eldest), Nancy Perron, Christine Perron, Cindy Perron, and April Perron.
• Location: The Old Arnold Estate (also known as the "Perron Farmhouse") in Harrisville, Rhode Island.
• Duration of Haunting: 1971–1980 (The family lived in the house for 10 years, not the short period depicted in the film).
• Key Incidents: Alleged physical assaults on Carolyn Perron, levitation, spectral apparitions, foul odors, and objects moving on their own.
• Paranormal Investigators: Ed and Lorraine Warren were called in to investigate the escalating phenomena.
• Family Legacy: Andrea Perron, the eldest daughter, has become the family's most vocal chronicler, detailing their experiences in her book series, House of Darkness, House of Light.

7 Major Updates on The Real Conjuring Story (2025)

The narrative of the Harrisville haunting is not static. New research, legal drama, and the ongoing work of paranormal investigators ensure that the story remains fresh and continuously updated.

1. The Shocking Drama of The Conjuring House's Ownership

The Arnold Estate has seen more drama in the last few years than in the previous century. The house, purchased for $1.5 million in 2022 by paranormal investigator and entrepreneur Jacqueline Nuñez (Bale Fire, LLC), was transformed into a popular tourist attraction offering tours and overnight stays.

The situation took a sharp turn in late 2024. Nuñez reportedly defaulted on her commercial loan and was arrested on DUI charges in October 2024.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

The property was subsequently set for a foreclosure auction on Halloween, October 31.

In a surprising twist, popular YouTuber Elton Castee announced he had assumed the underlying mortgage on the farmhouse. This move, alongside a fundraising effort by fellow paranormal investigator Jason Hawes, has created a complex and highly publicized battle for control of one of America's most famous haunted houses.

2. The Definitive Truth About Bathsheba Sherman

Perhaps the most significant update is the historical re-evaluation of the woman at the center of the movie's terror: Bathsheba Sherman. The film portrays her as a Satan-worshipping witch who murdered her child and cursed the land before dying by suicide.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

The Historical Correction: Modern research, and even statements from Andrea Perron, confirm that the movie's portrayal is largely false.

• Bathsheba Sherman (1812–1885) was a real person who lived on the property in the mid-19th century.
• There is absolutely no historical evidence that she was a witch, murdered anyone, or died by suicide.
• She died of natural causes at the age of 73 in 1885.
• In a move to correct the historical record, a new headstone was placed at her grave, reflecting the true facts of her life and death, and challenging the "witch" narrative.

This critical update suggests that while the Perron family was genuinely tormented by a demonic or malevolent entity, the spirit was likely not the historical Bathsheba Sherman, but another presence that had attached itself to the land.

3. The Perron Family’s Continued Involvement

Decades after moving out, the Perron daughters remain deeply connected to the case. Andrea Perron, in particular, has continued to share her family's story through books and documentaries, ensuring the narrative is preserved from their first-hand perspective.

The family's accounts emphasize that the haunting was a long, slow burn over ten years, not the rapid-fire horror depicted on screen. They also support the historical findings that exonerate Bathsheba Sherman, focusing instead on the malevolent entity that targeted their mother, Carolyn Perron.

4. The Conjuring Universe Moves to The Smurl Haunting

The success of the franchise ensures that the legacy of Ed and Lorraine Warren continues to grow. The next film in the main series, titled The Conjuring: Last Rites, will focus on a completely different, yet equally famous, case from the Warrens' files: The Smurl Haunting.

This case involves Jack and Janet Smurl of West Pittston, Pennsylvania, who claimed a demon terrorized their family from 1973 to 1987. The Smurl case is notorious for its claims of physical assault, levitation, and demonic possession, which the Warrens investigated and deemed authentic. This shift provides fresh topical authority, moving beyond the Harrisville house while keeping the Warrens’ legacy central.

5. The Warrens’ Legacy: Controversy and Documentation

While the films celebrate Ed and Lorraine Warren as heroic paranormal investigators and demonologists, their work continues to face scrutiny. Skeptics often point to a lack of scientific evidence in their most famous cases, including Amityville and the Annabelle Doll case, suggesting the Warrens were effective storytellers rather than scientists.

However, the Warrens' documentation, including the famous Occult Museum (now closed but with artifacts in storage), remains a powerful entity in the world of demonology, influencing a generation of paranormal research.

6. The Unseen Entities of The Arnold Estate

Beyond Bathsheba, the Perron family accounts mention numerous other spirits (entities) inhabiting the Arnold Estate, suggesting a complex, multi-layered haunting. These include:

• The Young Girl: Described as a friendly spirit who often interacted with the children.
• The Man in the Doorway: A more imposing, male presence.
• Maurice Theriault: A farmer who previously lived on the land and was the subject of a famous exorcism case that the Warrens were involved in, suggesting a connection between the land and other demonic activity.

7. The House is Still Active and Open to the Public

Despite the legal and ownership drama in 2024 and 2025, the Arnold Estate remains a functional, if controversial, paranormal tourist destination. The house's new owners, whoever they may ultimately be, continue the tradition of hosting paranormal events, overnight stays, and livestreams for those seeking to experience the real-life haunting firsthand.

This ongoing public access ensures that the house itself remains a living entity in the Conjuring narrative, constantly generating new, unverified claims of paranormal activity from visitors and investigators.

Topical Authority: Key Entities and Locations

Understanding the full scope of "the real Conjuring" requires familiarity with the key people and locations that shaped the true story and the cinematic universe it spawned.

The Perron Case Entities

• Roger Perron: Father of the family, initially skeptical but eventually convinced of the haunting.
• Carolyn Perron: The mother, who was the primary target of the most malevolent entity.
• Bathsheba Sherman: The historically exonerated woman whose spirit was incorrectly blamed for the haunting.
• Harrisville, Rhode Island: The small, rural town where the Arnold Estate is located.

The Warrens’ Legacy Entities

• Ed Warren (1926–2006): Self-taught demonologist and author.
• Lorraine Warren (1927–2019): Clairvoyant and light trance medium who worked alongside her husband.
• Annabelle Doll: Another famous Warren case, involving a Raggedy Ann doll allegedly possessed by a demon.
• Amityville Horror: The Warrens were involved in the investigation of the infamous 1975 DeFeo/Lutz case in Amityville, New York.

The real story of The Conjuring is a fascinating blend of documented history, personal testimony, and paranormal investigation. The 2025 updates—particularly the ownership saga and the exoneration of Bathsheba Sherman—demonstrate that this iconic haunting is far from a closed case, continuing to evolve and surprise those who dare to look deeper.