5 Shocking Details About Matthew Morrison And Chrishell Stause's Forgotten Engagement

In December 2025, the names Matthew Morrison and Chrishell Stause conjure images of two completely different worlds: the musical theater of Broadway and the high-stakes drama of Los Angeles real estate. Morrison is eternally known as Will Schuester from the hit series *Glee*, while Stause is the undeniable queen of Netflix’s *Selling Sunset*. Yet, a deep dive into celebrity history reveals a connection that shocks even the most dedicated fans: the two stars were once engaged. This forgotten chapter of their lives, which took place long before their respective career-defining roles, has resurfaced as a major talking point thanks to Chrishell's candid revelations. Her memoir shed new light on the relationship, detailing a painful breakup that set the stage for her later, highly public romances and divorces.

Complete Biographical Profiles: Matthew Morrison and Chrishell Stause

To truly appreciate the unexpected nature of this pairing, it is important to understand the professional and personal trajectories of both stars. Their paths, while intersecting briefly, are defined by very different industries and public personas.

Matthew Morrison

• Full Name: Matthew James Morrison
• Born: October 30, 1978 (Fort Ord, California)
• Career Highlights (Entities): Broadway star (*Hairspray*, *The Light in the Piazza*), Television Actor (*Glee* as Will Schuester, *American Horror Story: 1984*), Singer (two studio albums).
• Current Status: Married to actress Renee Puente (now Renee Morrison) since 2014. The couple shares two children.
• Public Persona: Known primarily as a talented singer, dancer, and actor with deep roots in musical theatre.

Chrishell Stause

• Full Name: Terrina Chrishell Stause
• Born: July 21, 1981 (Draffenville, Kentucky)
• Career Highlights (Entities): Soap Opera Actress (*All My Children* as Amanda Dillon, *The Young and the Restless*), Reality TV Star (*Selling Sunset*, *Dancing with the Stars*, *The Traitors*), Author (*Under Construction: Because Living My Best Life Took a Little Work*).
• Current Status: Married to Australian musician G Flip since May 2023.
• Public Persona: Known for her openness, resilience, and navigating highly publicized relationships and a shocking divorce from actor Justin Hartley.

The Shocking Engagement: A 2006-2007 Hollywood Whirlwind

The relationship between Matthew Morrison and Chrishell Stause is a footnote in their respective dating histories, yet it remains one of the most surprising celebrity pairings of the late 2000s. The couple began dating in 2006. At the time, Matthew Morrison was already a recognized Broadway talent, while Chrishell Stause was making her mark in the world of daytime television on *All My Children*. The relationship moved quickly, culminating in an engagement in December 2006. They were together for about a year before Morrison proposed. However, the engagement was short-lived. By December 2007, the relationship had come to an end, just a year after they had announced their plans to marry. The breakup occurred two years before Matthew Morrison would land his iconic role as the beloved Mr. Schue on *Glee*, a role that would catapult him to global fame. The suddenness of the split and the lack of public detail at the time meant the story was largely forgotten by the time both stars achieved massive success in the 2010s.

Chrishell's Memoir Reveals: The 'Under Construction' Details

The most recent and definitive information about their relationship comes directly from Chrishell Stause herself. In 2022, she released her memoir, *Under Construction: Because Living My Best Life Took a Little Work*, published by Simon & Schuster imprint Gallery Books. In the book, Stause dedicated a section to her past high-profile relationships, including both her ex-fiancé Matthew Morrison and her ex-husband Justin Hartley. She opened up about the pain of the breakup, stating, "I’m thankful for where I am, as painful as some of my breakups may have been." While she was diplomatic, the inclusion of the relationship in her tell-all book brought the forgotten engagement back into the spotlight. The key takeaway from the memoir is that the relationship was part of her personal "construction" process—a necessary, albeit painful, experience that shaped the resilient star fans know today.

The Five Shocking Details Fans Forget

The story of the Matthew Morrison and Chrishell Stause engagement is surprising for several reasons that highlight the dramatic shift in their lives since 2007.

1. The Timing: The engagement occurred *before* the show *Glee* even existed. Morrison was a Broadway star, not a global TV icon. Stause was a soap opera actress, not a reality TV mogul.
2. The Speed: They were engaged after dating for only about a year, signifying a whirlwind romance that quickly flamed out.
3. The Memoir Angle: The relationship was significant enough to be included alongside her divorce from Justin Hartley in a major celebrity memoir over a decade later.
4. The 'Bachelorette' Connection (LSI): Stause revealed in her book that she was nearly cast as *The Bachelorette* lead in 2008, a year after her split from Morrison. Her high-profile, recent breakup was a major factor in the show’s interest.
5. The Current Partners: Both stars have moved on to lasting, loving relationships with completely different partners—Morrison with his wife Renee Puente, and Stause with her spouse G Flip—making their past entanglement feel like a lifetime ago.

Divergent Paths: *Glee*, *Selling Sunset*, and Finding Lasting Love

Following their split, both Matthew Morrison and Chrishell Stause went on to achieve massive, defining career success. Matthew Morrison’s life became synonymous with *Glee*, which premiered in 2009. His role as the optimistic choir director Will Schuester made him a household name and cemented his status as a triple-threat performer. He later married Renee Puente in 2014, establishing a stable family life largely out of the tabloid spotlight. Chrishell Stause, after her soap opera career, transitioned to the world of luxury real estate and reality television with *Selling Sunset* in 2019. Her public dating life, including her marriage and subsequent shocking divorce from *This Is Us* star Justin Hartley, became a central storyline, propelling her to new levels of fame. Today, both stars are happily settled. Chrishell Stause’s marriage to Australian musician G Flip is a testament to her journey of self-discovery and finding love on her own terms. Matthew Morrison continues his career in acting and music, enjoying his life as a husband and father. The forgotten engagement between the *Glee* star and the *Selling Sunset* personality remains a fascinating piece of Hollywood history—a reminder that even the most seemingly disparate celebrities often share surprising, formative chapters from their past. Chrishell's willingness to share this detail in her memoir ensures that this unexpected connection will continue to spark curiosity among fans for years to come.