5 Definitive Reasons Why Florence Pugh And Andrew Garfield Are NOT Dating In 2025

The irresistible on-screen chemistry between Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield has fueled a continuous wildfire of dating rumors since their collaboration on the romantic drama We Live in Time. As of December 2025, the short answer is a definitive no: Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield are not a couple, nor have they ever been. The intense speculation is a testament to their incredible acting and undeniable professional bond, which translated into a deeply convincing on-screen romance that blurred the lines for fans and media alike.

The fervor surrounding the two Oscar-nominated stars reached a fever pitch during the film’s promotional cycle, where their playful banter and mutual admiration were constantly on display. This article dives into the current, confirmed relationship status of both actors, the true source of the dating speculation, and the separate, high-profile partners they are currently linked to in 2025.

Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield: A Complete Profile and Filmography

The foundation of the dating rumors lies in the significant star power and critical acclaim of both actors. To understand the magnitude of their pairing, here is a breakdown of their professional profiles.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

Florence Pugh Profile

• Full Name: Florence Rose C.M. Pugh
• Born: January 3, 1996 (Age 29 as of late 2025)
• Birthplace: Oxford, Oxfordshire, England
• Key Films & Roles: Midsommar (Dani Ardor), Little Women (Amy March), Black Widow (Yelena Belova), Oppenheimer (Jean Tatlock), Don't Worry Darling (Alice Chambers)
• Major Accolades: Academy Award Nomination (for Little Women), three BAFTA Nominations, British Independent Film Award

Andrew Garfield Profile

• Full Name: Andrew Russell Garfield
• Born: August 20, 1983 (Age 42 as of late 2025)
• Birthplace: Los Angeles, California, U.S. (Raised in Epsom, England)
• Key Films & Roles: The Amazing Spider-Man (Peter Parker/Spider-Man), Hacksaw Ridge (Desmond Doss), tick, tick...BOOM! (Jonathan Larson), The Social Network (Eduardo Saverin)
• Major Accolades: Tony Award (for Angels in America), BAFTA TV Award, two Academy Award Nominations (for Hacksaw Ridge and tick, tick...BOOM!)

The True Source of the Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield Dating Rumors

The speculation that Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield were dating did not come from paparazzi photos or cryptic social media posts. Instead, it was a direct result of their professional collaboration on the highly anticipated 2024 film, We Live in Time, directed by John Crowley.

1. The "We Live in Time" Chemistry

In the film, the two star as a couple navigating a long-term relationship, facing life’s biggest challenges, including a cancer diagnosis. Critics and audiences universally praised their "amazing chemistry" and "significant star power," which made their on-screen romance incredibly believable and emotionally potent. The film required them to portray a full gamut of a relationship—from falling in love to facing devastating loss—which naturally led to a strong bond and deep respect between the actors.

2. The Press Tour Dynamic

During the promotional press tour for We Live in Time, their mutual admiration was constantly highlighted. Andrew Garfield even admitted to being "shy" when he first met Pugh, but they quickly bonded over her playful personality. Their comfort and easy banter in joint interviews, such as the popular "Web's Most Searched Questions" segment, convinced many fans that a real-life romance was brewing beneath the surface. However, as Florence Pugh herself has stated regarding their work, "they are at acting".

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

The Confirmed Relationship Statuses of Both Stars in 2025

Despite the persistent fan fiction and hopeful headlines, both Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield are currently involved in separate, high-profile relationships as of late 2025. This definitive separation of their personal lives completely debunks the dating rumors.

Florence Pugh's Current Relationship Status: Finn Cole

Florence Pugh has been extremely private about her love life since her amicable split from actor and filmmaker Zach Braff in 2022. However, she has been consistently linked to fellow British actor Finn Cole, best known for his role in the series Peaky Blinders.

• The Rumors: Pugh told British Vogue that she was in a relationship but chose not to reveal the identity of her partner.
• The Evidence: Multiple outlets and paparazzi have spotted Pugh and Cole together, with speculation intensifying in early 2025. The couple sparked renewed buzz after attending the London premiere of Marvel's Thunderbolts together in April 2025, and there are even rumors of a secret engagement.

Andrew Garfield's Current Relationship Status: Monica Barbaro

Andrew Garfield’s romantic life has also been a subject of intense media scrutiny. Following a brief romance with spiritual healer Dr. Kate Tomas, which ended in a confirmed split in October 2024, the actor has moved on.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

• The New Partner: Andrew Garfield is currently linked to American actress Monica Barbaro.
• The Timeline: The pair were first linked in early 2025 after being spotted attending a play together and were later seen looking cozy at major events like Wimbledon. Barbaro is known for her roles in Top Gun: Maverick and is set to star in the Bob Dylan biopic A Complete Unknown.

Why the Rumors Persist: The Power of On-Screen Magic

The Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield dating rumors are a perfect case study in how on-screen magic can translate into real-life speculation. The intense, decades-spanning love story they portrayed in We Live in Time required a level of vulnerability and trust that is rare, and their ability to sell the romance was perhaps too convincing.

While fans may dream of a Hollywood power couple, both actors are happily pursuing their separate lives and careers. They remain close friends and professional collaborators, with both expressing a desire to work together again in the future, a testament to the strong bond they formed while making the film. For now, the only place to see their relationship is on the screen, where their chemistry is truly unmatched.