The 5 Biggest Debates Raging On Reddit's R/SquaredCircle Right Now (December 2025)

Step inside the largest and most influential wrestling discussion forum on the internet. As of December 15, 2025, r/SquaredCircle—the undisputed digital home for pro-wrestling fandom—continues to be the nexus of breaking news, heated arguments, and fantasy booking for over 1.3 million subscribers. The current landscape of professional wrestling, dominated by the major players of WWE, AEW, and TNA, provides fertile ground for non-stop discussion, with the community's collective opinion often influencing the narrative of the wider wrestling world.

The subreddit, often simply referred to as 'Wreddit,' is a sprawling digital colosseum where every match, every promo, and every backstage rumor is dissected with expert-level scrutiny. From the latest developments on WWE Raw and SmackDown to the high-flying action on AEW Dynamite and the resurgence of TNA, this community sets the pace for the industry's online conversation. This is your essential guide to the most burning, fresh, and current controversies dominating the discussion in late 2025.

The Digital Colosseum: A Brief History of r/SquaredCircle

The origin story of r/SquaredCircle is a piece of wrestling folklore itself, forever tied to a moment of seismic change in the industry. The subreddit was founded in 2011, reportedly emerging directly in the wake of CM Punk's infamous "Pipe Bomb" promo. This anti-establishment moment in WWE history created a massive surge of interest and a demand for a dedicated, open forum separate from the existing, more heavily moderated pro-wrestling communities at the time.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Since its inception, r/SquaredCircle has grown exponentially to become Reddit's largest professional wrestling community, boasting over 1.3 million subscribers. It is the primary hub for:

• Live show discussion threads (WWE, AEW, NXT, TNA).
• Breaking news and "dirt sheet" rumor analysis.
• In-depth analysis of wrestling booking decisions and creative direction.
• A platform for independent and international wrestling exposure (e.g., Marigold, APW).

The community's influence is undeniable. A viral post or a universally praised match thread can quickly become a talking point for wrestling journalists, podcasters, and even the promotions themselves, solidifying the subreddit's role as a major barometer for fan sentiment and topical authority.

The Great Promotional War of 2025: WWE vs. AEW vs. TNA

The professional wrestling landscape in late 2025 is defined by a complex, three-way rivalry, and r/SquaredCircle is the primary battleground for debating its nuances. The core of this discussion centers on the competitive strategies of the major promotions and the nature of their alliances.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

The TNA-WWE Working Relationship Debate

One of the most intense and recurring debates focuses on the TNA Wrestling and WWE working relationship. While many fans appreciate the cross-promotional opportunities—such as the appearance of TNA stars and the potential for dream matches—a significant faction of the community argues that the partnership is detrimental to TNA's brand identity.

The sentiment, as seen in the post-Slammiversary and Bound for Glory 2025 discussion threads, is that TNA risks looking like a mere "extension of WWE" rather than a distinct entity. Wrestlers like Moose, who have been vocal about the partnership, are constantly analyzed, with fans debating whether the short-term exposure is worth the long-term risk of losing TNA’s unique appeal that differentiates it from AEW and WWE.

The 'AEW Go Away' Theory and Peak Booking

The competitive tension between WWE and All Elite Wrestling (AEW) remains a constant source of discussion. A prominent theory often cited from wrestling journalists like Dave Meltzer and heavily debated on the subreddit is that "WWE's goal is to make AEW go away." This narrative frames every WWE acquisition, every major show change, and every strategic move as a calculated attempt to stifle the competition.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

AEW fans, conversely, often defend the promotion's style, arguing that it offers a product WWE "cannot and will not" provide, focusing on in-ring action and a different presentation of pro-wrestling. Debate also swirls around AEW’s booking philosophy, particularly the idea that the company is constantly trying "to peak in the PPV," leading to uneven television quality, a common criticism found in the AEW Dynamite discussion threads.

The Most Discussed Entities and Hot-Button Debates in Late 2025

The lifeblood of r/SquaredCircle is its discussion of the performers. In December 2025, the following wrestlers, matches, and concepts are generating the most buzz, providing the core topical authority for the community:

1. The LA Knight "Stone Cold" Trajectory

LA Knight remains one of the most polarizing and heavily discussed figures. Following the latest WWE Raw discussions, the community is split on his current booking. One side argues that he is being deliberately cooled off, while the other believes his current run is a slow-burn setup for an even bigger comeback, potentially positioning him as the "Stone Cold Steve Austin of this era" against the current "Vision" (likely a reference to a top heel). His trajectory is a nightly topic of conversation, with fans constantly fantasy booking his path to a major championship.

2. The Women’s Wrestling Revolution: Marigold and NXT Deadline

The focus on women’s wrestling has never been higher, driven by significant international and domestic matchups. The announcement of the IYO SKY vs. Mayu Iwatani match for Marigold Grand Destiny 2025 generated massive excitement, leading to hundreds of comments and showcasing the community's appetite for high-level Japanese wrestling. Simultaneously, the build-up to the NXT Deadline event, particularly the Women's Iron Survivor Challenge Match, ensures that stars like Sol Ruca, Wren Sinclair, and Kendal Gray are constantly being evaluated by the Wreddit audience.

3. The Kairi Sane and Asuka vs. Bayley Storyline

The ongoing rivalry involving the Damage CTRL split continues to dominate the WWE discussion threads. The heel work of Asuka and Kairi Sane, particularly their cutting promos aimed at Bayley, is a major talking point in the WWE Raw discussion threads. The debate centers on how well the storyline is progressing, who should ultimately emerge as the top champion, and whether the heel faction's dominance is compelling or frustrating the audience.

4. The Rise of Indie and International Talent

Beyond the major promotions, r/SquaredCircle is a crucial platform for independent talent. Discussions about promotions like APW (with personalities like The Toy Man Chris Hill and Jay Kirby) and specific indie matchups (Jude Dawkins vs. KB6, The Rogue vs. Brady Blaze) ensure that the community maintains a broad, global perspective on the industry. This dedication to the wider pro-wrestling world is a key component of the subreddit’s topical authority and its appeal to hardcore fans.

The Wreddit Experience: More Than Just News

r/SquaredCircle is more than just a news aggregator; it's a dynamic, often chaotic, but always passionate community that shapes the way fans consume professional wrestling. It is the definitive modern pro-wrestling community, where the lines between kayfabe and "dirt sheet" shoot information are constantly blurred, creating an unparalleled, immersive experience for the wrestling fandom.

The community's collective opinion, whether it's praising the performance of a rising star like Dragon Lee or debating the long-term booking of established champions like Becky Lynch, provides a valuable, real-time snapshot of the industry's health. For any fan looking to be at the absolute forefront of professional wrestling debates, r/SquaredCircle remains the essential, must-visit digital square.