The Shocking Truth: What Happened To Jenelle Evans’ Dog Nugget And The New 2024 Animal Cruelty Allegations

The controversy surrounding former *Teen Mom 2* star Jenelle Evans and the death of her family’s French bulldog, Nugget, remains one of the most defining and shocking incidents in the history of reality television. This high-profile animal cruelty case, which unfolded in 2019, led to Evans’ firing from MTV, a temporary loss of custody of her children, and a permanent stain on her public image. As of December 2025, the narrative has become even darker with new, explosive accusations of a second dog's death emerging from court documents filed in 2024. The events surrounding the dog named Nugget are complex, involving conflicting public statements, police investigations, and intense media scrutiny, all centered on her estranged husband, David Eason. The recent 2024 allegations, detailed in a domestic violence protection order petition, suggest a disturbing pattern of animal abuse that continues to haunt the reality star's life and her relationship with Eason.

Jenelle Evans: Profile and Biography

Jenelle Lauren Evans is an American reality television personality who rose to fame for her tumultuous life chronicled on MTV. She has been a consistent figure in the media for nearly a decade, primarily due to her legal troubles, relationship dramas, and custody battles.

• Full Name: Jenelle Lauren Evans (formerly Rogers, Eason)
• Date of Birth: December 19, 1991
• Place of Birth: Oak Island, North Carolina, U.S.
• Main TV Appearances: *16 and Pregnant* (2010), *Teen Mom 2* (2011–2019), *Teen Mom: The Next Chapter* (brief appearance in 2022)
• Spouses/Partners: Andrew Lewis (relationship), Courtland Rogers (m. 2012–2014), Nathan Griffith (relationship), David Eason (m. 2017–present, with multiple separations)
• Children: Jace Evans (with Andrew Lewis), Kaiser Griffith (with Nathan Griffith), Ensley Eason (with David Eason)
• Career Status: Fired from *Teen Mom 2* in 2019 following the dog incident; currently active as a social media influencer and content creator.
• Residence: "The Land" in North Carolina.

The 2019 Incident: What Really Happened to Nugget the French Bulldog

The infamous incident involving Jenelle Evans' French bulldog, Nugget, first made headlines in May 2019, triggering a massive public outcry and professional consequences that Evans is still dealing with years later. The initial reports were horrifying and quickly went viral across all social media platforms.

The Alleged Shooting and David Eason’s Admission

The controversy began when Jenelle Evans publicly claimed that her husband, David Eason, had brutally shot and killed their family dog, Nugget.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

According to Evans' initial statements, Eason became enraged after the small French bulldog nipped at their daughter, Ensley Eason, who was two years old at the time.

Eason did not deny the allegations, instead taking to social media to defend his actions. In a now-deleted Instagram post, he claimed he had the right to protect his child and that the dog was aggressive.

He stated, "I dont give a damn what animal bites my baby," appearing to confirm that he was responsible for the dog's death.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Police Investigation and Conflicting Reports

Following the public revelations and a police investigation, the narrative took a strange and conflicting turn. The Columbus County Sheriff’s Office closed its investigation, concluding that there was no sufficient evidence of animal cruelty.

Shockingly, the police report alleged that Jenelle Evans had admitted to investigators that she had made up the entire story about Eason shooting the dog for publicity.

Evans later denied this, claiming she never told the police that Eason shot Nugget, further muddying the waters of the truth.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Regardless of the conflicting accounts, the public and MTV largely sided with the initial report of animal cruelty.

The Immediate Fallout: MTV Firing and Custody Loss

The Nugget incident had immediate and severe consequences for both Jenelle Evans and David Eason. MTV, the network behind *Teen Mom 2*, officially fired Evans, stating they had ceased filming with her indefinitely due to the controversy.

Furthermore, the North Carolina Department of Social Services (DSS) launched an investigation into the family’s home environment. This led to a temporary court order removing all of the couple's children—Jace, Kaiser Griffith, and Ensley Eason—from their care.

While Evans and Eason eventually regained custody of their children, the event marked the end of her lucrative career with MTV and cemented the family’s reputation for instability and controversy.

The Continuing Pattern: New 2024 Allegations of a Second Puppy’s Death

Years after the Nugget scandal, the topic of animal welfare in the Evans-Eason household resurfaced with alarming new details. In 2024, during a period of separation and a filing for a domestic violence protection order (DVPO), Jenelle Evans made a second, equally disturbing allegation of animal abuse against David Eason.

Accusation of a Puppy Killed by Vehicle

In her 2024 DVPO petition, Evans accused David Eason of killing a second family dog—a small puppy—by allegedly running it over with his vehicle.

She claimed the horrifying incident took place in February 2024 and occurred in front of their children.

This accusation was part of a broader set of allegations of abuse and volatile behavior cited by Evans as reasons for seeking protection for herself and her children.

The revelation of a potential second dog death reignited public concern and media coverage, suggesting the 2019 Nugget incident was not an isolated event but part of a deeper issue of animal cruelty on "The Land."

The Replacement Dogs and Public Scrutiny

In the months following the Nugget controversy, Jenelle Evans and David Eason acquired two new dogs: two Anatolian Shepherds named Buddy and Junior.

The decision to get new pets so quickly after the death of Nugget was met with significant backlash from the public and animal welfare organizations like PETA, who urged Evans to re-home all her dogs.

The ongoing cycle of acquiring new pets despite the history of alleged animal abuse and neglect has kept the topic of "Jenelle Evans' dogs" a perennial subject of intense scrutiny and concern among her followers and critics alike, highlighting a troubling pattern that the 2024 puppy incident has tragically reinforced.