The 2025 Guide To Third & Hollywood: Why This Columbus Gem Earned A Spot On The Top 100 Romantic Restaurants List

As of December 2025, the intersection of culinary excellence and classic American charm remains firmly rooted in Grandview Heights, Columbus, Ohio, at the celebrated bistro, Third & Hollywood. Named for its literal street corners—West Third Avenue and Hollywood Place—this establishment has transcended its physical location to become a cornerstone of the Columbus dining scene. Since its opening in 2009, it has consistently delivered a blend of casual elegance and sophisticated, locally-sourced cuisine, cementing its reputation as a must-visit destination for both local patrons and visitors seeking an authentic, upscale American experience.

The enduring popularity of Third & Hollywood is not just based on nostalgia; it is continually validated by recent accolades and a commitment to quality that keeps the experience fresh and relevant. The restaurant's intimate atmosphere and impeccable service were highlighted by its significant achievement in 2024, when it was recognized as one of the "Top 100 Romantic Restaurants" in the United States, a major nod to its ability to create memorable, intimate dining moments. This recent honor underscores why, over a decade later, this New American bistro remains at the forefront of Ohio's culinary landscape.

The Visionaries and The Origin Story: A Grandview Heights Institution

Third & Hollywood is more than just a restaurant; it is the realization of a specific vision for a classic American Bistro with a modern, upscale sensibility. The concept was meticulously crafted to feel both lavish and approachable, a balance that is notoriously difficult to strike in the competitive fine dining market. The restaurant’s name is a direct, charming reference to its location at 1433 West Third Ave, where the main thoroughfare meets the subtle alleyway of Hollywood Place.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

Key Figures and Founding Philosophy

• Location: 1433 West Third Ave, Grandview Heights, Columbus, OH 43212.
• Opening Year: 2009.
• Cuisine Style: Classic American Bistro / New American Cuisine.
• Key Figure: Kevin Malhame, a partner in the restaurant, has been instrumental in shaping its foundational philosophy of "casual elegance."
• Core Principle: The establishment operates on an open kitchen concept, emphasizing transparency and the use of only the finest local ingredients to create healthy, delicious meals.

Kevin Malhame has spoken about the challenge of maintaining a high-quality, consistent experience, emphasizing that the restaurant business is fundamentally a "people business." This focus on genuine hospitality and a warm, inviting atmosphere is a direct contributor to the restaurant's longevity and its recent recognition as a truly romantic dining destination. The commitment to sourcing local ingredients reflects a broader dedication to the community and the quality of the food served.

The Culinary Cornerstones: Must-Try Dishes and Menu Philosophy

The menu at Third & Hollywood is a thoughtful curation of American classics, elevated through sophisticated technique and premium sourcing. While the offerings evolve seasonally, the core identity revolves around comfort food reimagined with a touch of luxury. The commitment to fresh, healthy, and delicious food is evident in every dish, from appetizers to entrees.

Signature Dishes That Define the Experience

Two menu items, in particular, have achieved legendary status and are essential to the Third & Hollywood experience:

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

1. The Hollywood Burger: This is not your average burger. It features Niman Ranch brisket and chuck, ground in-house daily, and is topped with high-quality cheddar. Served with a side of perfectly crisp french fries, it exemplifies the restaurant's approach: taking a simple classic and executing it with unparalleled attention to detail and superior ingredients. The in-house grinding ensures maximum freshness and flavor, setting it apart from standard fare.
2. Cheddar Herb Biscuits: Arguably the most famous item on the menu, these biscuits are a non-negotiable part of the dining experience. They are so popular that they are offered complimentary during the weekday Happy Hour (4:30–6:00 PM) with a purchase of a drink or appetizer. For those who can't get enough, they are available as a full skillet or a smaller portion of three biscuits, offering a buttery, savory, and deeply satisfying start to any meal.

Beyond these staples, the menu consistently features fresh seafood, perfectly cooked steaks, and seasonal vegetable preparations that showcase the kitchen's technical prowess. The diverse menu ensures that whether you are looking for a hearty meal or a lighter, health-conscious option, the culinary team can deliver.

The Atmosphere, Service, and 2024 Romantic Recognition

The true magic of Third & Hollywood lies in its atmosphere—a careful blend of a warm, inviting neighborhood spot and a sophisticated, high-end establishment. The interior is often described as intimate with a lavish ambience, making it ideal for everything from a business lunch to a special celebratory dinner. The design choices, from the lighting to the seating arrangements, contribute to a feeling of "casual elegance."

A Place for Romance and Community

The restaurant’s dedication to a superior overall experience was formally recognized in 2024 when it was named one of the "Top 100 Romantic Restaurants" in the nation. This prestigious award is based on thousands of diner reviews and highlights establishments that excel at creating an atmosphere perfect for date nights, anniversaries, and intimate gatherings. The combination of dimly lit tables, attentive service, and high-quality food makes it a sanctuary for couples in the Columbus metropolitan area.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

The lively atmosphere is further enhanced by special events, such as the popular Sunday Jazz Brunch, which adds a layer of cultural richness to the dining experience. Furthermore, the restaurant remains deeply connected to its local community. Even a small 2024 anecdote in local news, where staff were able to laugh off a "dine-and-dasher" incident, speaks volumes about the team's resilience and commitment to maintaining a positive, professional environment despite minor setbacks.

Topical Authority Entities & Dining Experience

The comprehensive experience at Third & Hollywood can be broken down into several key entities that define its topical authority:

• Ambiance: Lavish Ambience, Intimate Setting, Casual Elegance.
• Special Features: Open Kitchen Concept, Sunday Jazz Brunch, Weekday Happy Hour.
• Service: Attentive, Professional, Warm, and Inviting.
• Accolades: Top 100 Romantic Restaurants (2024), Consistently High Ratings in Columbus Dining.

The happy hour, which offers $3 off all drinks and appetizers, is a particularly popular time for patrons to enjoy the sophisticated bar area and sample starters while receiving the complimentary Cheddar Herb Biscuits. This focus on value and quality across all dining times contributes to its status as a reliable favorite in the competitive Grandview Heights dining scene.

Conclusion: The Enduring Allure of Third & Hollywood

Third & Hollywood stands as a testament to the power of a well-executed concept. It successfully bridges the gap between a neighborhood gem and a destination for upscale dining, drawing patrons from across Columbus, OH, and beyond. Its longevity, dating back to 2009, is a direct result of the consistent quality of its New American cuisine, the warmth of its service, and the commitment of figures like Kevin Malhame to a philosophy of genuine hospitality.

The recent 2024 recognition as a top romantic spot only solidifies its place in the heart of the city's culture. Whether you are craving the legendary Hollywood Burger, indulging in the comforting Cheddar Herb Biscuits, or simply seeking a beautifully intimate setting for a special occasion, Third & Hollywood in Grandview Heights continues to set the standard for American bistro excellence. It is a true Ohio Eatery that promises a dining experience that is both familiar and unexpectedly refined, making it a timeless fixture on West Third Avenue.