The Shocking Truth: Where Is The A League Of Their Own Cast Now After Amazon’s Sudden Cancellation?

The Amazon Prime Video series A League of Their Own (2022) captivated audiences with its fresh, queer-inclusive reimagining of the classic 1992 film, but its journey was cut unexpectedly short. Co-created by and starring Abbi Jacobson, the show was a critical darling that dove deep into the lives of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL) players, specifically the Rockford Peaches, exploring themes of sexuality, race, and identity during World War II. The shocking news of its cancellation in August 2023, after an initial renewal for a shortened second season, left fans and the cast reeling, officially ending the series after just one season.

As of December 2025, the talented ensemble cast has moved on to major new projects across film and television. While the series is over, the actors who brought the Rockford Peaches and the independent Max Chapman to life are busier than ever, proving that even a controversial cancellation can’t stop their momentum. This is the definitive, up-to-date guide on where the main cast members of A League of Their Own are now and what they’re working on.

Complete Biography and Current Projects of the Main Cast

The A League of Their Own cast was celebrated for its diverse and talented lineup, many of whom were already established comedy and drama stars. Here is a look at the key players and their latest career moves following the Amazon series’ abrupt end.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

• Abbi Jacobson as Carson Shaw (Catcher/Co-Creator)
  • Born: February 1, 1984 (Wayne, Pennsylvania)
  • Known For: Co-creating and starring in the hit comedy series Broad City.
  • Post-Series Project: Jacobson continues her successful career as a writer and actor. Most recently, she starred in the Netflix comedy series No Good Deed, which premiered in December 2024, alongside Lisa Kudrow and Ray Romano. She also continues to work in voice acting.
• Chanté Adams as Maxine 'Max' Chapman (Pitcher)
  • Born: December 16, 1994 (Detroit, Michigan)
  • Known For: Her award-winning performance in the biopic Roxanne Roxanne (2017), and roles in The Photograph and A Journal for Jordan.
  • Post-Series Project: Adams is a highly sought-after dramatic actress. While specific new roles are often kept under wraps, she is actively pursuing film work, solidifying her status as a compelling leading lady in Hollywood.
• D'Arcy Carden as Greta Gill (First Basewoman)
  • Born: January 4, 1980 (Danville, California)
  • Known For: Her iconic, Emmy-nominated role as Janet in NBC's The Good Place and her work on the HBO series Barry.
  • Post-Series Project: Carden has joined the main cast of the critically acclaimed Hulu series The Handmaid's Tale for its final season, taking on the role of a new character named Agnes. She is also a prolific voice actor and improviser.
• Gbemisola Ikumelo as Clance Morgan (Max’s Best Friend)
  • Born: Unknown (Nigeria)
  • Known For: Her BAFTA-winning short film Brain in Gear and her role in the TV series Famalam. She is also a writer and comedian.
  • Post-Series Project: Ikumelo is starring in the new comedy series The Paper, where she also serves as a writer, showcasing her multi-hyphenate talent in the UK and US markets.
• Roberta Colindrez as Lupe García (Pitcher)
  • Born: May 28, 1986 (Monterrey, Mexico)
  • Known For: Her roles in the Starz series Vida and the Amazon series I Love Dick. She is a Mexican-American actor known for her boundary-breaking work.
  • Post-Series Project: Colindrez continues to be a powerful presence in independent film and theater, often focusing on projects that highlight queer and Latinx narratives.

The Controversy: Why Was A League of Their Own Canceled?

The cancellation of A League of Their Own remains a sore spot for fans and critics alike, especially since the series was praised for its authentic and diverse storytelling, particularly its focus on queer history and the experiences of Black women in baseball, like Max Chapman. The show’s first season ended with several major cliffhangers, leaving the stories of Carson, Greta, Max, and Lupe unfinished.

The series was initially given a green light for a four-episode "final season" in March 2023, allowing the creators a chance to wrap up the narrative. However, in a stunning reversal just five months later in August 2023, Amazon Prime Video announced it was entirely scrapping the final season.

The official reason given by Amazon was the "ongoing delays caused by the writers and actors strikes" (WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes). This explanation was met with widespread skepticism and anger, including from co-creator Abbi Jacobson, who publicly stated that the strikes were an easy "excuse" for the network to cut a show with a predominantly female and queer cast.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Key Supporting Cast Members and Their Characters

The strength of A League of Their Own was its deep bench of compelling supporting characters, each adding unique layers to the narrative of the Rockford Peaches and the broader AAGPBL. These actors are also continuing to find success in other projects, maintaining the topical authority of the ensemble.

• Kelly McCormack as Jess McCready: McCormack played the tough, Canadian shortstop and was one of the few actors with a real-life baseball background. She has since been seen in the acclaimed series George & Tammy, showcasing her dramatic range.
• Priscilla Delgado as Esti González: Delgado portrayed the youngest player on the team, Esti, a Cuban girl whose journey mirrored the challenges faced by Latinx players in the league.
• Nick Offerman as Casey "Dove" Porter: The former MLB pitcher and team manager brought a comedic and grounded presence. Offerman, famous for Parks and Recreation, continues to take on major roles, including an Emmy-winning turn in The Last of Us.
• Melanie Field as Jo DeLuca: Field played the spirited third basewoman, a loyal friend to Greta Gill. She is known for her roles in Heathers and The Alienist.
• Kate Berlant as Shirley Cohen: Berlant, a renowned comedian, played the anxious but lovable second basewoman, Shirley. She continues her career in stand-up and has appeared in films like Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.

The Legacy of the Rockford Peaches and the Series' Impact

Despite its premature ending, the 2022 series cemented its place as a significant piece of television. It successfully expanded the legacy of the original film by Penny Marshall, moving beyond the well-known story of Dottie Hinson and Kit Keller to tell stories of intersectionality and struggle that were previously marginalized.

The show's focus on the queer romance between Carson Shaw and Greta Gill, and the parallel story of Max Chapman navigating racism and homophobia in her quest to play professional baseball, resonated deeply with modern audiences. It brought the history of the AAGPBL and the experiences of women of color and queer women to the forefront, creating a loyal and passionate fanbase that continues to advocate for its return or a proper conclusion. The series remains a powerful example of how beloved stories can be successfully updated to reflect a more complete historical truth.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

While the dream of a second season for the Rockford Peaches is over, the cast's flourishing careers and the show's lasting cultural impact ensure that their league of their own will continue to inspire new stories for years to come.