25 Years Later: Where The American Pie Cast Is Now In 2025—From Jim To Stifler’s Mom

The American Pie cast defined an era of teen comedy when the film first hit theaters in 1999, and as of late 2025, the original gang is still making headlines. The movie, which celebrated its 25th anniversary in 2024, launched the careers of a dozen actors who have since gone on to star in sitcoms, win major awards, and lead their own critically acclaimed series.

The conversation around a potential sequel, *American Pie 5*, is as hot as ever, with star Jason Biggs recently reflecting on the franchise’s legacy and whether the original film’s raunchy humor could even be made in the current cultural climate. From Jim Levenstein’s awkward antics to Stifler’s mom’s legendary status, here is a complete, up-to-the-minute look at the main cast of the American Pie universe and what they are doing now in 2025.

The Main Cast: Full Biography & Latest Projects (2025 Update)

The core ensemble of the original 1999 film have all found remarkable success, though their paths have diverged dramatically. Many are currently involved in major television series, films, and even reality TV, proving the American Pie foundation was just the beginning of their careers.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

Jason Biggs (Jim Levenstein)

• Role: Jim Levenstein, the perpetually awkward protagonist.
• Born: May 12, 1978 (Age 47 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Jenny Mollen (since 2008).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Orange Is the New Black* (Larry Bloom), *Outmatched*, *The Subject*.
• 2025 Update: Biggs continues to be the main voice for the franchise. In a late 2025 interview, he reflected that the original *American Pie* would likely be impossible to make today due to its politically incorrect humor, a sentiment that sparked significant discussion among fans. He also confirmed he remains open to reprising his role for an *American Pie 5* should the script and timing be right.

Alyson Hannigan (Michelle Flaherty)

• Role: Michelle Flaherty, the band camp enthusiast who becomes Jim’s wife.
• Born: March 24, 1974 (Age 51 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Alexis Denisof (since 2003).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Buffy the Vampire Slayer* (Willow Rosenberg), *How I Met Your Mother* (Lily Aldrin), host of *Penn & Teller: Fool Us*.
• 2025 Update: Hannigan has successfully transitioned into a popular television personality. Following her win on *Dancing with the Stars* in 2023, she continues her work as a host and judge. In late 2025, she reunited with her *Buffy* co-star Sarah Michelle Gellar for a new awareness-raising project, keeping her in the public eye.

Seann William Scott (Steve Stifler)

• Role: Steve Stifler, the obnoxious, party-obsessed jock.
• Born: October 3, 1976 (Age 49 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Olivia Korenberg (since 2019).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Dude, Where's My Car?*, *Goon* franchise, *Ice Age* franchise (voice of Crash), *Lethal Weapon* (TV Series).
• 2025 Update: Scott is making a strong return to film. He is slated to star in the 2025 action-comedy *Bad Man*, where he plays a "wild man state cop" tackling a meth epidemic. He is also slated to appear in the 2025 horror film *Dolly*.

Eugene Levy (Noah Levenstein - Jim's Dad)

• Role: Noah Levenstein, Jim’s supportive and well-meaning father.
• Born: December 17, 1946 (Age 78 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Deborah Divine (since 1977).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Schitt's Creek* (Johnny Rose, Emmy winner), *Waiting for Guffman*, *A Mighty Wind*.
• 2025 Update: The beloved actor continues his successful run as a travel host. Season 3 of his acclaimed Apple TV+ travel series, *The Reluctant Traveler with Eugene Levy*, is set to premiere in late 2025. The new season will see him explore eight countries and feature stellar guests, including William, Prince of Wales.

Jennifer Coolidge (Jeanine Stifler - Stifler's Mom)

• Role: Jeanine Stifler, the iconic "MILF" who seduces Finch.
• Born: August 28, 1961 (Age 64 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Single.
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Legally Blonde*, *A Cinderella Story*, *The White Lotus* (Tanya McQuoid, Emmy and Golden Globe winner).
• 2025 Update: Coolidge’s career resurgence, largely due to her award-winning role in *The White Lotus*, continues its momentum. She is starring in the upcoming 2025 film *Riff Raff*, a crime comedy alongside Bill Murray and Pete Davidson. Additionally, she has been cast in the highly anticipated *Minecraft* movie.

The Girls of East Great Falls: What Happened Next?

The actresses who played the love interests and friends of the main group have all had diverse and highly publicized careers since their time in the franchise. Their latest endeavors in 2025 range from major TV hits to passion projects focused on wildlife conservation.

Natasha Lyonne (Jessica)

• Role: Jessica, the quick-witted friend who offers the boys advice.
• Born: April 4, 1979 (Age 46 in 2025)
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Orange Is the New Black* (Nicky Nichols), *Russian Doll* (Nadia Vulvokov, co-creator, writer, director, and star).
• 2025 Update: Lyonne is currently one of the most critically acclaimed actresses in television. She is set to star in the highly anticipated Season 2 of her hit mystery-of-the-week series, *Poker Face*, which is expected to premiere in 2025. She also continues to work as a director and producer.

Mena Suvari (Heather)

• Role: Heather, the popular choir girl who dates Oz.
• Born: February 13, 1979 (Age 46 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Michael Hope (since 2018).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *American Beauty*, *Six Feet Under*, *Chicago Fire*.
• 2025 Update: Suvari remains busy in the film world, particularly in the independent horror and thriller genres. She is slated to star in the 2025 horror-comedy film *Ick* and the upcoming thriller *The Wrecker*.

Tara Reid (Vicky Lathum)

• Role: Vicky Lathum, Kevin’s girlfriend.
• Born: November 8, 1975 (Age 50 in 2025)
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Josie and the Pussycats*, *Sharknado* franchise.
• 2025 Update: Reid continues to take on film roles, with the movie *Dr. Quarantine* among her upcoming 2025 projects. She also made headlines in late 2025 due to a personal incident involving an alleged spiked drink at a hotel bar, which she publicly addressed.

Shannon Elizabeth (Nadia)

• Role: Nadia, the Czech exchange student who is the object of Jim’s affections.
• Born: September 7, 1973 (Age 52 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Divorced from Joseph D. Reitman.
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back*, *Thirteen Ghosts*, professional poker player.
• 2025 Update: Elizabeth has largely shifted her focus from acting to philanthropy. She now dedicates her time to her wildlife conservation efforts, having moved to South Africa to work with her foundation. She still makes occasional appearances at fan conventions, including a joint appearance with Mena Suvari at Steel City Con in 2025.

The Other Guys: Oz, Kevin, and Finch’s Current Status

The remaining members of the East Great Falls High graduating class have also maintained active careers, balancing film, television, and, in one notable case, a major career shift.

Chris Klein (Chris "Oz" Ostreicher)

• Role: The lacrosse player who joins the choir to meet girls.
• Born: March 14, 1979 (Age 46 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Laina Rose Thyfault (since 2015).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *The Flash* (Cicada), *Sweet Magnolias*.
• 2025 Update: Klein continues to take on diverse roles in both film and television. He is set to star in the 2025 movie *Prom Queen*, a thriller, demonstrating his continued work in the industry.

Thomas Ian Nicholas (Kevin Myers)

• Role: Kevin Myers, the group's self-proclaimed relationship expert.
• Born: July 10, 1980 (Age 45 in 2025)
• Marital Status: Married to Colette Marino (since 2007).
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Rookie of the Year*, *Red Band Society*, musician/singer-songwriter.
• 2025 Update: Nicholas balances his acting career with a successful music career. He continues to perform and attend fan events, including an appearance with Tara Reid at the NJ Horror Con & Film Festival in late 2025.

Eddie Kaye Thomas (Paul Finch)

• Role: Paul Finch, the sophisticated, intellectual, and mysterious member of the group.
• Born: October 31, 1980 (Age 45 in 2025)
• Notable Post-Pie Work: *Harold & Kumar* franchise, *’Til Death*, *Scorpion* (Toby Curtis).
• 2025 Update: Thomas has had a steady career in television, most notably starring in the long-running CBS series *Scorpion*. While his most recent major project ended in 2018, he continues to work in voice acting and smaller film roles, keeping a lower public profile than many of his co-stars.

The Future of the Franchise: Will American Pie 5 Happen?

The conversation surrounding a fifth installment in the main series, tentatively titled *American Pie 5*, has been ongoing, especially with the 25th anniversary of the original film in 2024. Fans of the teen comedy series are eager to see the East Great Falls High gang reunite once more, following the success of the 2012 film *American Reunion*.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

Producer Craig Perry has acknowledged that there have been numerous attempts to get another movie off the ground. The main challenge appears to be finding a fresh, relevant story that honors the original characters while reflecting their current stage in life, now well into their 40s. The actors themselves, including Jason Biggs and Seann William Scott, have consistently expressed interest in returning, but only if the script is right. The desire from the cast is there, but as of late 2025, an official, greenlit sequel remains in development limbo.

The enduring popularity of the *American Pie* cast, with their consistent work in major projects like *The White Lotus*, *Poker Face*, and *The Reluctant Traveler*, proves that the franchise’s legacy is built on more than just raunchy teen humor. It’s built on a cast of talented actors who have all found their own unique, highly successful paths in Hollywood.