Love Island All Stars Season 2: The Shocking Winners, Full Cast Drama, And Where Are They Now?

The second season of Love Island: All Stars delivered on its promise of explosive comebacks and unexpected couplings, cementing its status as one of the most talked-about reality TV events of the year. Airing its highly-anticipated run in early 2025, the series brought back a roster of fan-favorite Islanders from across the last decade of the show, all eager for a second—or third—shot at finding love in the South Africa villa. The stakes were higher, the exes were more numerous, and the drama was immediate, leading to a truly unforgettable season that concluded on February 17, 2025, with a surprising winning couple.

As of today, December 15, 2025, the dust has settled, but the relationship updates and post-villa gossip continue to dominate headlines. From the return of OG stars like Marcel Somerville and Scott Thomas to the dramatic journey of winners Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman, this deep dive explores everything you need to know about the season, the full confirmed cast, and where the most iconic couples stand now. Hosted once again by the incomparable Maya Jama, the All Stars format proved it has the heat to rival the main series.

The Champions' Journey: Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman

The ultimate goal of the Love Island experience is to find a lasting connection, and for Season 2 of All Stars, that title belonged to Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman. Their victory was a surprise to many viewers, who often focused on the more tumultuous or high-drama couples throughout the series.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

Gabby Allen, originally a contestant on Series 3, and Casey O'Gorman, a fan-favorite from Series 9, entered the villa with clear intentions but little expectation of coupling up with each other. Their journey was characterized by a steady, drama-free progression, which ultimately resonated with the voting public.

Unlike other couples who faced explosive arguments, controversial re-couplings, or dramatic Casa Amor tests (which was a major focal point for other pairs), Gabby and Casey built a relationship based on genuine friendship and mutual respect. This 'slow burn' approach set them apart from the typical Love Island whirlwind romance.

Their victory lap saw them secure the £50,000 prize, and post-villa, they have been busy with media appearances and sharing relationship updates. As of late 2025, they remain a couple, frequently discussing their plans for the future and how the show helped them find a connection they couldn't achieve in their original seasons.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman: Biography and Love Island History

• Gabby Allen:
  • Original Series: Series 3 (2017)
  • Original Partner: Finished in fourth place with Marcel Somerville.
  • All Stars Season 2 Journey: Entered on Day 1. Known for her infectious energy and positive attitude.
  • Current Status (Dec 2025): In a relationship with Casey O'Gorman.
• Casey O'Gorman:
  • Original Series: Series 9 (Winter 2023)
  • Original Partner: Coupled with Claudia Fogarty and Rosie Seabrook.
  • All Stars Season 2 Journey: Entered on Day 2. Quickly coupled with Gabby and maintained a stable relationship.
  • Current Status (Dec 2025): In a relationship with Gabby Allen.

The Full Lineup: Returning All Stars and Their Second Chances

The success of the All Stars format lies in the star power and history of its returning Islanders. The Season 2 cast featured a mix of OGs and recent fan-favorites, ensuring a complex web of past relationships, feuds, and potential new connections. The producers certainly did not hold back, bringing back contestants with the juiciest pasts.

The full confirmed lineup for Love Island All Stars Season 2 was a dream for viewers, featuring Islanders from Series 2 all the way up to Series 11.

Key Islanders and Their All Stars Impact

• Scott Thomas (Series 2): A true OG, Scott's return was highly anticipated. Known for his relationship with Kady McDermott in his original season, his presence brought a level of maturity and reflection to the villa.
• Marcel Somerville (Series 3): Returning after his relationship with Gabby Allen in Series 3, Marcel’s second chance at love was a central storyline. His calm demeanor and status as a former Blazin' Squad member made him a respected figure.
• India Reynolds (Series 5): India's return was a surprise, as she was a late arrival in her original season who found a strong connection with Ovie Soko. Her second stint was marked by a search for a more permanent partnership.
• Luca Bish (Series 8): Luca's journey in Series 8 was defined by his tumultuous relationship with Gemma Owen. His return to the All Stars villa was an attempt to shed his previous image and find a connection without the intense pressure of his former high-profile romance.
• Olivia Hawkins (Series 9): Known for her dramatic moments and strong personality, Olivia's return guaranteed fireworks. She was quick to voice her opinions on the other couples, providing plenty of commentary for viewers at home.
• Grace Jackson (Series 11): Grace's entry, paired with her eventual second-place finish alongside Luca Bish, proved the power of a late arrival in the All Stars format.
• Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu (Series 8): While some sources mentioned Ekin-Su, the actual cast list varied. However, the energy and drama associated with her name perfectly encapsulated the type of powerful, high-impact personalities the show sought to bring back.

The Drama Unpacked: Exes, Bombshells, and The South Africa Villa

The premise of All Stars is inherently dramatic: bringing back exes and former flames to live under one roof. Season 2 of the show, filmed in a luxurious South Africa villa, capitalized on this tension. The winter setting provided a stunning backdrop for the intense emotional rollercoaster. The villa, reportedly valued at £1.2 million, once again became the epicenter of reality TV romance.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

The main source of conflict often stemmed from Islanders having to navigate their past while trying to build a future. The initial few weeks were a masterclass in awkward encounters, as several former couples had to share the same space. The strategic introduction of bombshells, a tradition for the show, was even more potent in All Stars, as every new arrival was a familiar face with existing history with someone in the villa.

The show's host, Maya Jama, played a crucial role, delivering the inevitable re-coupling twists and dramatic dumpings with her signature style. Her presence at the fire pit always signaled a moment of high tension, forcing Islanders to make difficult decisions that impacted the entire villa dynamic.

Relationship Statuses Post-Villa (Late 2025)

While Gabby and Casey took the crown, the success of a season is often measured by how many couples remain together months later. The post-villa life is the true test for any Love Island relationship.

• Gabby Allen & Casey O'Gorman: Still together and frequently sharing updates on social media. They have been praised by fans for their genuine connection and have even hinted at moving in together.
• Grace Jackson & Luca Bish: Finishing in a respectable second place, their relationship was a major talking point. After leaving the villa, they faced intense scrutiny. As of late 2025, their status is often debated, with some reports suggesting they are taking things slow outside of the Love Island bubble.
• Other Notable Couples: The other final couples and fan-favorite connections from the season have also been under the microscope. The reality of dating outside the controlled environment of the South Africa villa often proves challenging, with some pairs announcing splits shortly after the finale, while others continue to explore their connection away from the cameras. The intense scrutiny of the public eye remains a key challenge for all returning Islanders.

The legacy of Love Island All Stars Season 2 is one of redemption and second chances. It proved that even years after their initial appearance, fan-favorite Islanders can return to the villa and find a genuine connection. The season successfully blended nostalgia with fresh drama, paving the way for future All Stars seasons and solidifying the show's dominance in the reality dating landscape.