The Ultimate Love Island USA Season 5 Update: Which Couples Are Still Together In 2025? (The Engagement News You Missed)

The fifth season of *Love Island USA*, which aired in the summer of 2023, delivered a spectacular mix of heartwarming romance, explosive drama, and unexpected twists, culminating in one of the show's most successful outcomes to date. As of December 18, 2025, the legacy of the Fiji-based villa continues to captivate fans, largely due to the enduring connections and major life milestones achieved by the winning couple, Marco Donatelli and Hannah Wright, as well as a few other fan favorites who managed to make their relationships last outside the Peacock reality series. This deep dive offers the most current and fresh information on the *Love Island USA* Season 5 cast, detailing who found lasting love, who split after the cameras stopped rolling, and the monumental post-show news that has cemented this season as a standout in the franchise's history. The season, hosted by the charismatic Sarah Hyland, spanned 32 days and featured a staggering 33 contestants overall, but only a few truly found their soulmates.

Love Island USA Season 5 Finalists and Key Cast

The fifth season of *Love Island USA* introduced viewers to a memorable lineup of Islanders, from the day-one originals to the game-changing Casa Amor bombshells. The season was characterized by strong initial pairings, dramatic love triangles, and a few emotional journeys that resonated deeply with the audience.

Key Season 5 Islanders

• Marco Donatelli: The eventual winner, known for his consistent connection with Hannah.
• Hannah Wright: The eventual winner, who entered the villa on Day 3 and quickly formed a stable bond with Marco.
• Carsten "Bergie" Bergersen: The wholesome, initially unlucky-in-love Islander whose journey became a major storyline, ultimately coupling up with Taylor Smith.
• Kassy Castillo: Known for her dramatic journey, coupled with Leonardo Dionicio and later with Johnnie Garcia.
• Leonardo Dionicio: A source of much of the season's drama, particularly in his relationship with Kassy.
• Vickala "Kay Kay" Gray: Coupled with Keenan.
• Destiny Davis: An original Islander who coupled with Marco initially.
• Carmen Kocourek: Entered on Day 3 and coupled with Kenzo Nudo.
• Taylor Smith: A bombshell who made a lasting connection with Bergie.
• Johnnie Garcia: A Casa Amor bombshell who caused a stir and later coupled with Kassy.

The season’s format saw 33 total contestants enter the villa in Fiji, including bombshells like Victor Gonzalez, Anna Kurdys, and Casa Amor additions such as Allie Ryan, Ashley Sims, Brandon Janse Van Vuuren, Dasja Johnson, Eddie Brown, Isiah “Zay” Harayda, and Kyle Darden.

The Unbreakable Bonds: Which Love Island USA Season 5 Couples Are Still Together?

The true test of any reality dating show is whether the connections can survive the transition back to the real world. *Love Island USA* Season 5 has proven to be one of the most successful seasons in terms of post-show longevity, with multiple couples still thriving as of late 2025.

Marco Donatelli and Hannah Wright (Winners)

The relationship between Marco and Hannah was a fan favorite from the start, known for its stability and genuine connection amidst the villa chaos. They were crowned the winners of *Love Island USA* Season 5.

Their post-show life has been a whirlwind of commitment and milestones. Shortly after the finale, Hannah moved to Boca Raton, Florida, to live with Marco. The couple has been living together for over 10 months and even expanded their family with a Goldendoodle named Guiseppe.

The biggest news, however, came with their engagement. Marco and Hannah, the season 5 winners, are now officially engaged, marking one of the most significant success stories in the entire *Love Island USA* franchise. Their journey provides a powerful counter-narrative to the common belief that reality TV romances are fleeting, showcasing a deep, lasting love.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

Carsten "Bergie" Bergersen and Taylor Smith (Finalists)

Another couple that defied expectations and found a lasting connection is Bergie and Taylor. Bergie's journey was initially one of struggle, but the arrival of Taylor Smith later in the season brought him the stable and loving partnership he was looking for.

As of 2025, Bergie and Taylor are still together, much to the delight of their dedicated fanbase. Their relationship is often cited as a testament to the fact that sometimes, the best connections take time to develop, even in the fast-paced environment of the villa.

Carmen Kocourek and Kenzo Nudo

Carmen and Kenzo formed a strong connection after Carmen entered the villa as a bombshell. They also made it to the final, showing a stable and mature relationship.

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

While their current relationship status in 2025 may not be as frequently updated as the winners, they were one of the stable pairings to leave the villa together, and their journey is an essential part of the season's legacy of successful couplings.

The Drama and Dynamics That Defined Season 5

Beyond the winning couples, *Love Island USA* Season 5 was packed with memorable drama, making it a highly-rated season with a score of 7.5. The season provided plenty of water-cooler moments that kept viewers hooked on the Peacock streaming platform.

The Kassy and Leonardo Saga

The tumultuous relationship between Kassy Castillo and Leonardo Dionicio was a central source of drama. Their back-and-forth, coupled with Casa Amor temptations, created a classic *Love Island* rollercoaster. Leonardo's actions during Casa Amor, in particular, led to emotional fallout and shifts in the villa dynamics.

The Bergie Effect

Carsten "Bergie" Bergersen became the season's endearing underdog. His initial difficulties in coupling up, followed by a dramatic save by the public, made his eventual pairing with Taylor all the more satisfying. His wholesome persona and genuine search for love resonated with many viewers, making his eventual success a highlight of the season.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

The Casa Amor Chaos

The infamous Casa Amor segment once again proved to be the ultimate test for the couples. This season’s Casa Amor bombshells, including Zay Harayda and Johnnie Garcia, successfully turned heads and caused major shifts in the original pairings, leading to dramatic recouplings and emotional confrontations upon the Islanders' return to the main villa.

The drama, while sometimes polarizing to viewers, ultimately contributed to the season's high entertainment value and its overall success in generating buzz and discussion.

Love Island USA Season 5: A Look Back at a Fan Favorite

The fifth season of *Love Island USA* stands out not just for its drama, but for its lasting success stories. The engagement of winners Marco Donatelli and Hannah Wright, coupled with the enduring relationship of Bergie and Taylor Smith, shows that the *Love Island* format can indeed produce authentic, long-term love. The focus on genuine connection, despite the initial mixed reviews on the cast selection, ultimately paid off. The season's high rating of 7.5 reflects a solid performance for the reality dating show. As fans eagerly await the next season, the couples of Season 5 continue to be the gold standard for what a successful *Love Island* journey can achieve: finding love, moving in together, and even planning a wedding. The journey of these Islanders from the Fiji villa to a shared life in Boca Raton, Florida, complete with a dog named Guiseppe, is the ultimate reality TV happily ever after.