The Baby-Sitters Club: Where Are The Cast Now? (2025 Updates On The Netflix Stars)

The Baby-Sitters Club, the beloved Netflix adaptation of the iconic book series by author Ann M. Martin, captured the hearts of a new generation of viewers with its modern take on friendship, entrepreneurship, and diversity. The show, which premiered in 2020, was a critical darling, winning a Peabody Award and an Emmy, but was sadly canceled after just two seasons in March 2022, becoming a high-profile victim of the streaming platform's "two-season curse."

As of December 2025, the young stars who brought Kristy, Claudia, Mary Anne, Stacey, and Dawn to life have moved on to major new roles across film and television. From starring in blockbuster fantasy reboots to leading roles in independent films, the cast has proven that their time in Stoneybrook, Connecticut, was just the beginning. Here is a comprehensive look at what the main cast of the Netflix series is doing now.

The Baby-Sitters Club: Main Cast Biography & Current Projects (2025)

The core of the show was the five founding members of the club. Their chemistry and commitment to the characters of the original 1986 book series were widely praised. Here is a detailed look at the actors who played the central roles and their latest career developments.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

1. Sophie Grace as Kristy Thomas (The Boss)

• Full Name: Sophie Grace Schave.
• Birthday: April 4, 2006 (Age 19 as of December 2025).
• Character Role: Kristy Thomas, the energetic and ambitious founder of The Baby-Sitters Club (BSC).
• BSC Tenure: Season 1 & 2.
• Post-BSC Career Update: Following the cancellation of the series, Sophie Grace has continued to focus on her career while also becoming an advocate. She is an Emmy Award-winning actress for her work on the show. While her most prominent post-BSC acting roles haven't yet reached the screen, she has been actively involved in philanthropic work. In 2022, she was announced as a youth ambassador for the HALO Foundation, using her platform to support and empower young people globally. Her previous credits include the films *Terror in the Woods* and *Business as Unusual*.

2. Momona Tamada as Claudia Kishi (The Artist)

• Full Name: Momona Tamada.
• Birthday: September 28, 2006 (Age 19 as of December 2025).
• Character Role: Claudia Kishi, the artistic Vice President of the BSC, known for her unique fashion sense and love of junk food.
• BSC Tenure: Season 1 & 2.
• Post-BSC Career Update: Momona Tamada has landed one of the most high-profile roles of any BSC cast member. She starred in the major Netflix live-action adaptation of Avatar: The Last Airbender (2024), where she played the fan-favorite character Ty Lee, a cheerful and acrobatic warrior. This role cemented her status as a rising star in the fantasy genre. She also previously appeared in the *To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before* film series.

3. Shay Rudolph as Stacey McGill (The Fashionista)

• Full Name: Shay Rudolph.
• Birthday: September 6, 2005 (Age 20 as of December 2025).
• Character Role: Stacey McGill, the stylish New York transplant who serves as the BSC's Treasurer, managing her Type 1 Diabetes with grace.
• BSC Tenure: Season 1 & 2.
• Post-BSC Career Update: Shay Rudolph's career is thriving with several new films. In 2024, she starred in the family-friendly film The Present, alongside Isla Fisher and Greg Kinnear. She is also set to appear in the highly anticipated 2025 film I Wish You All the Best, based on the popular young adult novel. Her continued work across different genres showcases her versatility as a young actress.

The Expanding Club: Mary Anne and Dawn’s New Ventures

The BSC expanded its membership and its stories in the second season, bringing in new talent to round out the core group. The commitment to diversity in the casting—a point praised by original author Ann M. Martin—was a hallmark of the adaptation, particularly in the casting of Mary Anne Spier and the recasting of Dawn Schafer.

4. Malia Baker as Mary Anne Spier (The Heart)

• Full Name: Malia Simphiwe Baker.
• Birthday: December 18, 2006 (Age 19 as of December 2025).
• Character Role: Mary Anne Spier, the shy but deeply empathetic Secretary of the BSC, who finds her voice throughout the series.
• BSC Tenure: Season 1 & 2.
• Post-BSC Career Update: Malia Baker, a Botswana-born Canadian actress, has a packed slate of upcoming projects. She is set to join the massive Disney franchise with a role in the upcoming movie Descendants: Wicked Wonderland. Her other anticipated films include the independent features Spider & Jessie, Harvest Moon, and the 2025 drama What We Hide. Baker's consistent film work demonstrates a strong trajectory in the industry, moving from the cozy world of Stoneybrook to major film sets.

5. Kyndra Sanchez as Dawn Schafer (The Activist)

• Full Name: Kyndra Sanchez.
• Birthday: December 29, 2006 (Age 18 as of December 2025).
• Character Role: Dawn Schafer, the free-spirited, environmentally conscious Treasurer (later Vice President) who moves from California to Stoneybrook.
• BSC Tenure: Season 2 (Replaced Xochitl Gomez).
• Post-BSC Career Update: Kyndra Sanchez, who took over the role of Dawn in Season 2, has continued her acting career with a notable role in the 2023 comedy film Theater Camp, which was a hit at the Sundance Film Festival. Her seamless transition into the role of Dawn after the departure of Xochitl Gomez (who left to star as America Chavez in *Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness*) was a testament to her talent, and she continues to build a strong resume in both film and television.

More BSC Entities: The Adult Cast and Supporting Club Members

Topical authority for The Baby-Sitters Club extends beyond the main five. The show was also praised for its strong adult cast and the introduction of junior members, all of whom have continued their careers.

The Adult and Supporting Cast’s Notable Moves

The series benefited greatly from the presence of established actors, particularly Alicia Silverstone as Kristy’s mother, Elizabeth Thomas-Brewer, and Mark Feuerstein as her fiancé, Watson Brewer. Silverstone, a 90s icon, has maintained a busy schedule, starring in films like *Reptile* and continuing her work in advocacy. Feuerstein has also appeared in various television roles following the series' conclusion.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

The junior members of the club, Mallory Pike (played by Vivian Watson) and Jessi Ramsey (played by Anais Lee), also continue to be active. Vivian Watson and Anais Lee, who joined the cast in Season 2, brought more of the beloved characters from the original BSC books to the screen, deepening the show's connection to the source material. Their future projects are eagerly anticipated by the BSC fandom.

The Netflix series cancellation in 2022 was a shock to fans and critics alike, who felt the show had much more story to tell. Despite the abrupt ending, the show's legacy endures, not only in the way it successfully modernized the classic tales but also in launching the careers of a new generation of talented young actors. The continued success of stars like Momona Tamada in *Avatar* and Shay Rudolph in feature films proves that the spirit of entrepreneurship and ambition embodied by the BSC is alive and well in its cast members. The possibility of a future BSC cast reunion or even a revival remains a hopeful dream for fans of the Stoneybrook gang.