We’re The Millers 2: 7 Shocking Reasons Why The Sequel Is Officially Dead (Aniston And Poulter’s Grim 2025 Update)

The question of whether We’re The Millers 2 will ever hit the big screen has been a persistent Hollywood mystery for over a decade, and as of late 2025, the updates are grimmer than ever. While the original 2013 comedy was a surprise box office smash, earning over $270 million worldwide on a modest budget, the promised sequel has been stuck in a frustrating state of development hell, leaving fans of the fake family—David, Rose, Kenny, and Casey—in perpetual limbo. The latest comments from the core cast, including Jennifer Aniston and Will Poulter, suggest that the window for a reunion may have finally closed, offering a disappointing but definitive answer to the sequel's fate.

Originally confirmed by New Line Cinema shortly after the first film’s success, the follow-up project, sometimes referred to as We're Still the Millers, has failed to materialize, despite the clear audience demand. The reasons for this cinematic stall are complex, ranging from scheduling conflicts among the A-list cast to a fundamental shift in the movie business. Here is a deep dive into the seven most shocking reasons why the highly anticipated We're The Millers 2 is officially considered a lost cause, based on the most current information available.

The Millers Family: Key Cast and Crew Biography Profiles

The success of the original We're the Millers was largely due to the electric chemistry and star power of its main cast. Here is a brief profile of the core entities involved in the potential sequel:

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

• Jennifer Aniston (Rose O'Reilly/Sarah Miller):
  • Born: February 11, 1969 (Sherman Oaks, California)
  • Career Highlights: Star of the iconic sitcom Friends (Rachel Green); Golden Globe and Emmy winner; known for romantic comedies (The Break-Up, Marley & Me) and her recent dramatic role in The Morning Show.
  • Latest Update on Sequel: Expressed doubt in 2023, stating the sequel "didn't happen" and that she is "too old now" to reprise the role of the stripper Rose.
• Jason Sudeikis (David Clark/David Miller):
  • Born: September 17, 1975 (Fairfax, Virginia)
  • Career Highlights: Former Saturday Night Live cast member; Creator and star of the critically acclaimed series Ted Lasso (Emmy and Golden Globe winner); known for comedies like Horrible Bosses and Hall Pass.
  • Latest Update on Sequel: Has been largely focused on his Emmy-winning work on Ted Lasso, making his schedule a major factor in the sequel's delay.
• Emma Roberts (Casey Mathis/Casey Miller):
  • Born: February 10, 1991 (Rhinebeck, New York)
  • Career Highlights: Star of American Horror Story and Scream Queens; known for her work in teen and horror genres; niece of Julia Roberts.
• Will Poulter (Kenny Rossmore/Kenny Miller):
  • Born: January 28, 1993 (Hammersmith, London, England)
  • Career Highlights: BAFTA Rising Star Award winner; known for roles in The Maze Runner, The Revenant, and joining the MCU as Adam Warlock in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.
  • Latest Update on Sequel: Gave a "grim" update in 2025, stating he does not expect to return for a sequel, citing the long passage of time.
• Rawson Marshall Thurber (Director):
  • Career Highlights: Directed DodgeBall: A True Underdog Story and the Netflix hits Central Intelligence and Red Notice.
  • Sequel Involvement: Was slated to return for the sequel, but his busy schedule with major studio projects has also contributed to the delay.

The 7 Shocking Reasons Why We’re The Millers 2 Is Stalled (2025 Update)

Despite being a major box office success that warranted a quick sequel announcement, the follow-up film has languished in development for over a decade. The current consensus among the cast and industry insiders points to a series of insurmountable hurdles.

1. Jennifer Aniston’s "Too Old Now" Comment

In 2023, while promoting Murder Mystery 2, Jennifer Aniston provided the most definitive and disheartening update on the sequel. When asked about We’re The Millers 2, she simply stated, "That didn't happen," and jokingly added, "I'm too old now." This comment, while lighthearted, underscored the reality that the central dynamic of the film—Aniston's character, Rose, as a stripper—would be difficult to revisit more than 10 years later without a significant shift in the plot. Her focus has clearly moved to more mature, dramatic projects like The Morning Show, making a return to the raunchy comedy genre less likely.

2. Will Poulter’s "Grim" 2025 Expectations

The most recent and perhaps final nail in the coffin came from Will Poulter in early 2025. The actor, who played the fan-favorite Kenny, told a reporter at a SXSW premiere that he "does not expect to return for a sequel" to the 2013 comedy. He acknowledged the passage of time as the primary factor, essentially confirming the sequel's unlikelihood. Poulter's career has skyrocketed since the first film, moving into major franchise roles (like the MCU's Adam Warlock), making his availability and interest in revisiting a decade-old comedy increasingly slim.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

3. The Studio’s Initial Confirmation Led to Development Hell

Back in 2014, New Line Cinema officially confirmed that a sequel was in the works, with screenwriters Adam Sztykiel and Rawson Marshall Thurber attached. However, this early momentum quickly stalled. The project never progressed beyond the initial script development phase. A lack of a compelling script that could recapture the magic of the original—while also justifying the return of the fake family—is a common reason for sequels to die in "development hell," which is where We're The Millers 2 has been for years.

4. The Main Cast’s Exploding Schedules

The original film benefited from catching its stars at a perfect career moment. Today, the core cast members are some of the busiest people in Hollywood. Jason Sudeikis spent years dedicated to Ted Lasso, a project that consumed his time and creative focus. Will Poulter is now an established blockbuster star. Jennifer Aniston is tied to major streaming projects. Coordinating the schedules of four A-list actors for a comedy sequel is a logistical nightmare, and the longer the delay, the harder it becomes.

5. The Comedy Genre Shift in Cinema

Since 2013, the landscape for theatrical comedies, particularly R-rated ones like We're the Millers, has drastically changed. Many mid-budget comedies now go straight to streaming services, and studios are hesitant to invest in a major theatrical release for an R-rated sequel unless the concept is a guaranteed hit. The long gap between films makes a sequel a riskier proposition, as the original audience may have moved on.

• The Facts Of Life Cast Where Are Eastlands Girls Now 2024 Updates 2tx8p

6. The Unresolved Plot Challenge: Where Do They Go Next?

The original film ended with the Millers successfully completing their drug run, narrowly escaping the cartel, and using the money to buy a house and become a real, functional family. This provided a satisfying conclusion, but it also painted the sequel into a corner. The central premise—a fake family forced into a criminal enterprise—is resolved. A sequel would need an equally outrageous and compelling reason to force David, Rose, Kenny, and Casey back into a dangerous, criminal scheme, a plot element that screenwriters have likely struggled to crack.

7. The Loss of Momentum and Audience Interest

While fan interest remains high on social media, the reality is that over a decade has passed since the original movie. The energy and cultural zeitgeist surrounding the 2013 film have faded. Studios are aware that the longer they wait, the less "fresh" the sequel will feel. The initial interest from 2014, when the sequel was announced, has waned, making the financial incentive for New Line Cinema to push the project forward less urgent than other, newer franchise opportunities.

What Would We’re The Millers 2 Have Been About?

While no official plot details were ever widely released, industry speculation and the ending of the first film offer strong hints about a potential storyline. The most logical continuation would involve the Millers' happy new life being interrupted by a threat from their past.

Possible Sequel Plot Scenarios:

• The Cartel’s Revenge: The sequel could have focused on the Millers being tracked down by the surviving members of the Mexican drug cartel (led by Pablo Chacón, played by Tomer Sisley) seeking revenge for the stolen money and their foiled operation.
• The Return of the Fitzgeralds: The Millers could have run into the genuinely wholesome RV-driving family, the Fitzgeralds (played by Nick Offerman and Kathryn Hahn), who might accidentally expose their past or get pulled into their new problems.
• A New, Bigger Scam: To save their real family life, David would be forced to take on one last, even more outrageous criminal job, this time perhaps involving the entire family—including the now-adult "kids," Kenny and Casey—to pull off a massive heist or smuggling operation.

Given the recent "grim" updates from Will Poulter and Jennifer Aniston, it is highly likely that the sequel is now permanently shelved. Fans will have to re-watch the original We're the Millers to relive the chaotic charm of the fake family's road trip, as a cinematic reunion seems increasingly impossible.