7 Shocking Ways Evan Peters And Emma Roberts' Tumultuous Split Propelled Their Careers To New Heights In 2025

The tumultuous, seven-year, on-again, off-again romance between actors Evan Peters and Emma Roberts remains one of Hollywood's most captivating and complex celebrity relationships. While the pair were once the definitive 'It' couple of the *American Horror Story* universe, starring alongside each other in multiple seasons, their professional and personal paths diverged dramatically following their definitive split in 2019. As of December 2025, both stars have achieved phenomenal success, but in completely separate spheres, proving that sometimes, a painful ending is the catalyst for individual greatness.

This article dives deep into the legacy of the "AHS Power Couple," detailing their relationship timeline, the dramatic circumstances of their breakup, and the subsequent career and personal milestones that have defined their lives five years later. From Golden Globe wins to new engagements and the joys of motherhood, their story is a fascinating study in post-breakup evolution.

Evan Peters and Emma Roberts: A Complete Biography and Relationship Timeline

To understand the magnitude of their split, one must first appreciate the history of the relationship that defined a generation of *American Horror Story* fans.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

Evan Peters Profile

• Full Name: Evan Thomas Peters
• Born: January 20, 1987 (Age 38 in 2025)
• Birthplace: St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.
• Occupation: Actor
• Known For: Playing multiple roles across the *American Horror Story* anthology series, Quicksilver in the *X-Men* film series, and Jeffrey Dahmer in *Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story*.
• Key Awards: Golden Globe Award, Primetime Emmy Award, Critics' Choice Television Award.
• Current Relationship Status (2025): Widely reported as single and focused on his career.

Emma Roberts Profile

• Full Name: Emma Rose Roberts
• Born: February 10, 1991 (Age 34 in 2025)
• Birthplace: Rhinebeck, New York, U.S.
• Occupation: Actress, Singer, Producer
• Known For: Roles in *Scream Queens*, *American Horror Story: Coven*, *Unfabulous*, and films like *We're the Millers* and *Madame Web*. She is the niece of Julia Roberts.
• Personal Life: Mother to son Rhodes Robert Hedlund (born December 2020); reportedly engaged to actor Cody John.
• Other Ventures: Co-founder of the popular book club, Belletrist.

The On-Again, Off-Again Relationship Timeline (2012–2019)

• 2012: The Start. Peters and Roberts meet on the set of the film *Adult World* and begin dating shortly after.
• 2013: The Incident. The relationship gains notoriety when Roberts is arrested in Montreal following a domestic dispute where Peters was found with a bloody nose. No charges were filed, and a joint statement called the event an "unfortunate incident."
• 2013-2014: Engagement and AHS. They become engaged over the Christmas holiday and star together in *American Horror Story: Coven*, where their onscreen chemistry as the witch Madison Montgomery and the fraternity boy Kyle Spencer captivated audiences.
• 2015-2016: The First Splits. The couple breaks off their engagement in June 2015, only to reconcile and re-engage by late 2016.
• 2019: The Definitive Breakup. After seven years, the couple reportedly ends their engagement for good in March 2019. Sources indicated the relationship had simply "run its course."

1. Evan Peters’ Post-Breakup Golden Globe Triumph (Dahmer)

The most dramatic divergence in Peters' career came three years after his final split from Roberts. While he had always been a critical darling of the *AHS* universe, his portrayal of the notorious serial killer in the 2022 Netflix miniseries, *Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story*, catapulted him to a new level of mainstream recognition and critical acclaim.

This intense, career-defining role earned him the Golden Globe Award for Best Actor in a Limited Series, a Primetime Emmy Award, and a Critics' Choice Television Award.

The sheer intensity and commitment required for the role, which Peters has openly discussed as being emotionally draining, arguably cemented his status as a serious dramatic actor capable of carrying a massive project. For many fans, this post-breakup era marked a shift from the quirky, fan-favorite AHS star to a respected, award-winning dramatic lead.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

2. Emma Roberts Embraces Motherhood and New Engagements

Following the 2019 breakup, Emma Roberts quickly moved on, finding a stable, long-term relationship with actor Garrett Hedlund. The most significant personal milestone of her life occurred in December 2020, when she gave birth to their son, Rhodes Robert Hedlund.

Roberts has since been candid about the challenges and profound joy of motherhood, discussing the "dark nights" and the need to find a balance between her career and raising her child.

While her relationship with Hedlund ended in 2022, Roberts has continued to prioritize her personal life, reportedly becoming engaged to actor Cody John in 2024. This sequence of events shows a clear and decisive move toward building a family life, a stark contrast to the turbulent, unanchored nature of her relationship with Peters.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

3. Their Separate, High-Profile Reunion with Ryan Murphy

The third major point of divergence is their continued, yet separate, professional relationships with producer Ryan Murphy, the creator who brought them together on *American Horror Story*.

• Evan Peters' New Murphy Era: Peters' Golden Globe-winning turn in *Dahmer* was a Ryan Murphy production. Their collaboration is set to continue with the highly anticipated FX series *The Beauty*, slated for 2026, solidifying Peters as Murphy's current dramatic muse.
• Emma Roberts' AHS Return: Roberts, meanwhile, returned to the AHS universe for the 12th season, *American Horror Story: Delicate*, in 2023, marking her first season back since the 2019 split. Her continued involvement in the franchise, alongside her work on other Murphy projects like *Scream Queens*, maintains her status as a key player in the "Ryan Murphy universe," but now without Peters.

4. Evan Peters’ Blockbuster Future: TRON: Ares (2025)

In 2025, Evan Peters is set to cement his transition from television star to major blockbuster actor with a leading role in the highly anticipated Disney sequel, *TRON: Ares*. This high-profile, big-budget franchise entry indicates a strategic move to diversify his portfolio beyond the dark, intense roles he's become known for, showcasing his ability to lead a major Hollywood tentpole film.

5. Emma Roberts’ Superhero Debut: Madame Web (2024)

Emma Roberts also made a significant foray into the blockbuster world in 2024, starring in the Sony/Marvel film *Madame Web*. While the film received mixed reviews, her involvement in a major superhero franchise demonstrates her continued relevance and appeal across different genres, from horror-comedy (*Scream Queens*) and romance (*Holidate*) to comic book adaptations.

6. The Rise of Emma Roberts’ Book Club Empire (Belletrist)

Beyond acting, Roberts has successfully cultivated a separate identity as a literary tastemaker through her book club, Belletrist. Launched in 2017, the club has grown into a significant brand, promoting reading and connecting a community of book lovers. This venture provides Roberts with an influential platform outside of her acting career, showcasing her entrepreneurial spirit and passion for literature, a domain entirely separate from her ex-partner.

7. The End of On-Screen Collaboration

Perhaps the most definitive sign of their separate paths is the complete cessation of their onscreen collaborations. Since the 2019 split, the two actors, who shared intense chemistry and numerous scenes across seasons like *Coven*, *Freak Show*, *Cult*, and *Apocalypse*, have not appeared in any joint projects. While both remain close to Ryan Murphy, the conscious decision to cast them in separate projects—Peters in *Dahmer* and *The Beauty*, Roberts in *Delicate*—underscores the professional boundary that has been established, ensuring their individual successes are not overshadowed by the legacy of their shared past.