5 Shocking Revelations About Teddi Mellencamp's Horse Trainer Scandal And Divorce Fallout

The recent news surrounding Teddi Mellencamp’s divorce and the explosive details of her alleged affair with her horse trainer, Simon Schroeder, have captivated the reality television and equestrian worlds. As of December 18, 2025, the former *Real Housewives of Beverly Hills* star is grappling with the public fallout of her split from husband Edwin Arroyave, coupled with shocking personal revelations she has shared on her own terms. This article dives deep into the full timeline, the key players, and the controversial statements that have defined this A-list accountability coach's dramatic personal reckoning.

Teddi Mellencamp: Biographical Profile and Career Highlights

Teddi Jo Mellencamp Arroyave is a well-known American television personality, podcast host, and fitness enthusiast who gained significant fame through her appearances on Bravo's *The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills* (RHOBH).

• Full Name: Teddi Jo Mellencamp Arroyave
• Date of Birth: July 1, 1981
• Place of Birth: Bloomington, Indiana, United States
• Parents: Daughter of legendary rock musician John Mellencamp.
• Career: Television personality (*RHOBH*), podcast host (*Two Ts In A Pod* with Tamra Judge), and founder of the wellness and fitness program "All In by Teddi."
• Marital Status: Filed for divorce from Edwin Arroyave in November 2024 after 13 years of marriage.
• Children: Shares three children with Edwin Arroyave.
• Equestrian Background: Teddi is an avid equestrian, having ridden as a professional for about 10 years with trainer Archie Cox.

1. The Identity of the Horse Trainer: Simon Schroeder and Schroeder Sporthorses

The man at the center of the cheating scandal is Simon Schroeder, a highly respected figure in the competitive equestrian circuit. Schroeder, a show jumper specialist, was not just a casual trainer; he was a professional with an established career and a family of his own. Schroeder's background is rooted in Europe. He was born and raised in Germany, with his hometown reportedly located just outside Frankfurt. He later relocated to the United States as a young adult to pursue his professional riding and training career. He specializes in training and showing jumpers, guiding horses from young prospects all the way up to top-tier competition. His professional expertise is undeniable, having trained alongside world-renowned figures like Herbert Meyer and Franke Sloothaak. The crucial detail that intensified the scandal is that Simon Schroeder was also married. He co-founded Schroeder Sporthorses, a prestigious training, sales, and investment show barn based in Moorpark, California, with his wife, Karli Schroeder Postel, whom he married in 2019. The alleged affair, which reportedly lasted for months, meant both Teddi Mellencamp and Simon Schroeder were married at the time.

2. The Explosive Divorce Timeline and Edwin Arroyave's Discovery

The announcement of Teddi Mellencamp's divorce from her husband of 13 years, Edwin Arroyave, was sudden and shocking to the public, but the underlying reason was the alleged affair with her horse trainer. The timeline of the public split is remarkably tight:

• November 1, 2024: Teddi Mellencamp officially filed for divorce from Edwin Arroyave in court.
• November 2, 2024: The former Bravo star announced the news of their separation and divorce filing to her followers on Instagram.

Reports suggest that Edwin Arroyave discovered the affair only a day before the divorce announcement was made public, indicating a rapid and dramatic end to their long-term marriage. The revelations quickly led to a media frenzy, with the term "riding more than horses" becoming a popular, albeit crude, summary of the situation on social media. Edwin Arroyave, the CEO of Skyline Security Management, has remained largely silent on the personal details of the split, focusing on the welfare of their three children.

3. Teddi Breaks Her Silence and Admits to the Affair

After weeks of speculation and rumors, Teddi Mellencamp chose to address the cheating scandal publicly. She used her platform, specifically an appearance on *The Jamie Kern Lima Show* podcast, to break her silence and confirm the infidelity. In her candid discussion, Teddi expressed deep regret and remorse for her actions, acknowledging the pain she caused her family. She admitted to being "extremely sorry and regretful" for cheating on Edwin Arroyave with Simon Schroeder. This public admission marked a significant turn, moving the narrative from rumor to confirmed fact by the reality star herself. Her decision to speak out was framed as a necessary step toward taking accountability, a core tenet she promotes through her *All In by Teddi* brand.

4. The 'Karma' Comment: Linking the Affair to Her Cancer Diagnosis

Perhaps the most controversial and widely discussed revelation came when Teddi Mellencamp connected the affair to her ongoing health battle with skin cancer. Teddi has been very open about her diagnosis and treatment for melanoma, often urging her followers to get their skin checked. However, during her public discussion of the affair, she shockingly questioned whether her cancer diagnosis might be a form of "karma" for her infidelity. This statement sparked a massive debate among fans and critics alike. Many found the self-inflicted link between a serious illness and a personal mistake to be a troubling display of guilt and self-punishment. The "karma" comment highlighted the enormous weight of the cheating scandal and the emotional toll it was taking on the former *RHOBH* star, going far beyond the typical celebrity divorce drama.

5. The Future of Mellencamp's Equestrian and Media Career

The affair has irrevocably linked Teddi Mellencamp's name with the competitive equestrian world, specifically with the high-stakes world of show jumpers and trainers. While she has a long history with horses, including her professional riding days with trainers like Archie Cox, the scandal with Simon Schroeder casts a shadow over her "equestrian style" and involvement in the community. The public scrutiny is intense, given that the horse world is often a close-knit community where personal and professional lines can blur. The fallout has implications not only for her personal life but also for her business ventures. Her podcast, *Two Ts In A Pod*, has been a primary vehicle for discussing her life, and the scandal has provided a massive, albeit painful, topic. Moving forward, Teddi Mellencamp faces the challenge of rebuilding her life and reputation. Her focus remains on co-parenting with Edwin Arroyave, managing her health, and navigating the complexities of her public-facing career while dealing with the consequences of the affair that ended her 13-year marriage. The story of the A-list accountability coach who failed her own accountability test remains a defining chapter in her life.