The Shocking Truth: Are Tyler Breshears And Kay Carlson Still Together After Temptation Island?

The dramatic and controversial pairing of Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson, who captivated viewers on the latest season of *Temptation Island* on Netflix, has been the subject of intense speculation since the season finale aired. Their journey—which saw Tyler end his long-term relationship with Tayler Byrd to pursue a connection with single Kay—left fans desperate for a definitive update on their relationship status.

As of today, December 17, 2025, the latest reports confirm that the whirlwind romance that began on the island has officially fizzled out. Despite leaving the Hawaiian villa together, Tyler and Kay are no longer a couple, with both reality stars having moved on to new chapters in their lives. The post-show reality proved to be a far cry from the paradise they found in front of the cameras.

Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson: Complete Reality Star Biographies

The relationship between Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson was one of the most talked-about storylines of their season of *Temptation Island*. Their respective backgrounds and the circumstances of their meeting provide essential context for their ultimate split.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

• Tyler Breshears:
• Age: 27 (at time of filming)
• Hometown: Nashville, Tennessee
• Profession: Model and Professional Trainer
• Original Relationship: Entered the island with his girlfriend, Tayler Byrd (a 30-year-old Health Education Specialist), whom he had been dating for two and a half years. Tyler had previously been married for six years before dating Tayler.
• Temptation Island Journey: Developed a strong connection with Kay, ultimately choosing to end his relationship with Tayler at the final bonfire to leave the island with Kay.
• Kay Carlson:
• Role on Show: Single/Tempter
• Hometown/Residence: Resides in Miami, Florida
• Profession: Social Media Personality and Fitness Content Creator
• Social Media Presence: Known for posting fitness content, workout videos, and POV videos. She is also reported to have an OnlyFans account under the name @kaygcarlson.
• Temptation Island Journey: Was the single woman who successfully tempted Tyler Breshears away from his partner, Tayler Byrd.

The Post-Island Reality: Why Tyler and Kay Broke Up

While the final bonfire saw Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson walk away hand-in-hand, seemingly ready to start a new life together, the connection quickly unraveled in the real world. The drama of the show was replaced by the complexities of everyday life, leading to a surprising and swift breakup.

Kay’s Decision: The Need for Single Life

The primary reason for the split, as revealed in a March 2025 update, was Kay Carlson’s decision to pump the brakes on the relationship. According to the reports, Kay felt that Tyler needed time to truly experience single life before committing to another serious relationship. Tyler had moved from a six-year marriage directly into his relationship with Tayler Byrd, and then immediately into a potential relationship with Kay. Kay’s perspective was that Tyler needed a period of self-discovery, unattached to a partner, to ensure their new bond was built on solid ground, a sentiment that ultimately led to their separation.

The Awkward Aftermath and Moving On

The breakup was seemingly amicable, though the aftermath was not without its awkward moments. In a relatable twist of fate for a couple living in the same area, the two have reportedly run into each other in public, including an uncomfortable encounter at a Costco store.

• 7 Shocking Things Jessica Capshaw Revealed About Growing Up With Steven Spielberg As Her Stepfather 892ho

However, both reality stars have since found new romantic partners, confirming that the Tyler and Kay chapter is definitively closed.

Where Are Tyler and Kay Now? Their Current Relationship Statuses

Since their split, both Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson have provided updates on their personal lives via social media and interviews, solidifying their status as single individuals who have moved on from their controversial reality TV romance.

Tyler Breshears’ New Relationship with Lauren

Tyler Breshears is currently in a new relationship with a woman named Lauren, who was not a cast member on *Temptation Island*. This relationship began after his split from Kay, indicating that he did not remain single for long following Kay’s request. Tyler has been open about his new partner, sharing details on social platforms, which confirms his romantic life has moved forward decisively away from his reality TV co-star.

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

Kay Carlson’s New Chapter and Media Appearances

Kay Carlson has also moved on and is reportedly dating someone new. She has been active on social media, continuing to focus on her career as a fitness influencer and content creator. She has also used her platform to speak about her experience on *Temptation Island*, including an unofficial reunion and tell-all video, giving her perspective on the drama and her connection with Tyler. She has described her time on the show as the "best experience of her life," despite the relationship not working out.

The Legacy of Tyler and Kay: Topical Authority and LSI Entities

The short-lived romance between Tyler and Kay has become a key reference point in the wider *Temptation Island* universe, often cited in discussions about the difficulty of maintaining a reality TV relationship in the real world. Their story highlights the common theme of post-show fizzle, where the intense, isolated environment of a show like *Temptation Island* fails to translate to a lasting partnership once the cameras stop rolling.

Key Entities and LSI Keywords Related to Their Story:

• *Temptation Island* Netflix Reboot
• Tyler Breshears and Tayler Byrd (Original Couple)
• Final Bonfire Decision
• Reality TV Relationship Failure Rate
• Post-Show Fizzle
• Kay Carlson OnlyFans
• Tyler Breshears Professional Trainer
• Awkward Costco Run-ins
• Mark L. Walberg (Show Host)
• *The Viall Files* (Podcast where cast members discussed the show)

In conclusion, the answer to the burning question, "Are Tyler and Kay still together?" is a definitive no. The controversial couple from *Temptation Island* parted ways shortly after leaving the island, with both Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson finding new partners and moving on with their lives in 2025. Their dramatic story serves as a perfect example of how the intense pressure and unique environment of reality television rarely result in long-term romance.