The Ultimate Love Island USA Season 1 Update: Where Are The Winners, Finalists, And Fan-Favorites Now In 2025?

It has been over five years since the very first American Islanders entered the villa in Fiji, kicking off the U.S. version of the global reality phenomenon, Love Island USA. The inaugural season, which aired in the summer of 2019, introduced a cast of hopefuls who quickly became fan favorites, defining the blueprint for every season that followed. The current date is December 2025, and the biggest question remains: which couples from the original cast have actually managed to make their love last outside the villa?

The answer, as of late 2025, is a resounding zero. While no original couples are still together, the lives of the Season 1 cast members have dramatically evolved, featuring new careers, new reality TV appearances, and even new family additions. From an advertising executive and a grocery store cashier winning the $100,000 prize to a fan-favorite welcoming a baby in 2024, the journeys of the Season 1 Islanders are arguably more dramatic now than they were on television.

Love Island USA Season 1: Full Cast & Biography Profiles

The first season of Love Island USA was filmed in Fiji and premiered on July 9, 2019. It featured a diverse group of singles, each looking for love and a chance at the grand prize. Here is a look at the key Islanders and their original profiles:

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

• Elizabeth Weber (Winner): An Advertising Executive from New York City. She was 24 years old at the time of the show. She coupled up with Zac on Day 1 and remained paired with him until the finale.
• Zac Mirabelli (Winner): A Grocery Store Cashier from Chicago, Illinois. He was 22 years old. Zac was known for his sweet and genuine nature, which quickly won over Elizabeth and the public.
• Alexandra Stewart (Runner-Up): A Publicist from Los Angeles, California. She was 25 years old. She coupled up with Dylan Curry, and their relationship was one of the most stable in the villa.
• Dylan Curry (Runner-Up): A Fitness Coach from Redondo Beach, California. He was 25 years old.
• Caro Viehweg (Finalist): A Marketing Student from Los Angeles, California. She was 21 years old and known for her effervescent personality and fluency in three languages.
• Ray Gantt (Finalist): A Digital Media Strategist from Sewell, New Jersey. He was 27 years old. He was paired with Caro in the finale.
• Kyra Green: A Musician/Model from Los Angeles, California. She was 22 years old. Kyra was involved in a memorable love triangle with Cashel Barnett and Eric Hall.
• Cashel Barnett: A Musician/Model from Sacramento, California. He was 27 years old. His original coupling with Kyra was a major storyline.

The Shocking Status of Love Island USA Season 1 Couples in 2025

The most pressing question for any reality dating show is whether the relationships survive the real world. For Love Island USA Season 1, the answer is a definitive no. As of 2025, every single couple from the debut season has officially broken up.

Elizabeth Weber & Zac Mirabelli: The Winners' Short-Lived Fairytale

Elizabeth and Zac were the definition of a "day one" couple, instantly connecting and sailing smoothly to win the $100,000 prize. They were the fan-favorite couple, a classic reality TV romance that seemed destined for a long future.

However, the pressure of the real world proved too great. They broke up just a few months after leaving the villa, shocking fans who had heavily invested in their relationship. Elizabeth has since channeled her experience into media, co-hosting the popular "After Love Island" podcast, where she discusses the show's dynamics and behind-the-scenes life.

• The Chilling True Story 5 Key Facts About Richard Evonitz The Serial Killer Who Kidnapped Kara Robinson Chamberlain Xpjje

Alexandra Stewart & Dylan Curry: The Runner-Ups' Quiet Split

Alexandra and Dylan were the steady, second-place couple who finished strong. Like the winners, they tried to make their relationship work outside the villa but eventually drifted apart. Their split was amicable, and Alexandra remains a prominent figure in the Love Island community, co-hosting the "After the Island" podcast with Elizabeth Weber.

Caro Viehweg & Ray Gantt: A New Chapter for Caro

Caro and Ray finished in third place, with a relationship that had its share of ups and downs. They, too, broke up after the show. However, Caro Viehweg has arguably had the most significant life update of the entire cast.

In a major life announcement, Caro revealed she was pregnant and welcomed her first child, a daughter, with her new husband in April 2024. This exciting news has delighted fans who followed her journey from the villa to motherhood, proving that while the show didn't find her a partner, it launched her into a new, fulfilling life.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

From The Villa to The Challenge: Season 1 Islanders Who Became Reality TV Stars

While the romantic relationships may have fizzled, the reality TV careers of several Season 1 Islanders are still going strong. The biggest crossover success story involves two former love interests who reunited on a different, more grueling competition show: The Challenge: USA.

Kyra Green and Cashel Barnett’s Reunion

Kyra Green and Cashel Barnett had a tumultuous, on-again, off-again relationship that was a central focus of Love Island USA Season 1. They officially split for good in February 2020.

In 2022, both Kyra and Cashel appeared as contestants on the first season of The Challenge: USA, a spin-off of the long-running MTV competition series. This reunion was a major talking point for fans, as the ex-couple were forced to compete alongside each other. Kyra's reality TV pursuits did not stop there; she also appeared on the 2021 show Match Me If You Can. This shift from dating shows to competitive reality has established both Kyra and Cashel as versatile reality personalities.

The Legacy and Controversies of The First Season

The debut season of Love Island USA holds a unique place in the franchise's history, but it wasn't without its criticisms. The show faced a common fan complaint that the U.S. adaptation felt rushed compared to its British counterpart. Many viewers felt the pacing was too fast, which prevented storylines and relationships from developing naturally.

Furthermore, a major concern among the fanbase was the motivation of the contestants. After seeing the success of the UK version, many viewers worried that the American Islanders were more focused on gaining Instagram followers and influencer status than finding genuine love. This debate over "clout-chasers" versus genuine romantics has persisted throughout the show's subsequent seasons.

Despite these criticisms, Love Island USA Season 1 set the stage for the show's continued success, proving that the format could translate to an American audience. The original cast members, including Zac, Elizabeth, Alexandra, Dylan, Caro, Ray, Kyra, and Cashel, laid the groundwork for the future of the American reality dating landscape, even if their own romantic journeys from the villa did not result in a long-term connection. Their individual success stories in media, podcasting, and new family life prove that the $100,000 prize was just the beginning of their post-villa careers.